Barry Presents: Whodunnit 2: The West Smithton Sagas GAME THREAD

[Poyser]

You think that he would play with an overarching strategic game plan like that tho?

Nah I think he just thought it an easy thing to say tbh. Feels like he’d have chosen to mention me if he were town and saw a wagon on me rather than just being like hmmm dunno about that town read man

 

[Smart Marx]

You think that he would play with an overarching strategic game plan like that tho?

Mitch? Probably not. Not in his first post, anyway.

 

[Tweet]

Actually

unvote
vote Mitch

 

[Odo]

So to reframe, in a world where you’re town and he’s scum, wouldn’t a likelier play be for him to just limp on to your wagon, in your opinion?

 

[Smart Marx]

Actually

unvote
vote Mitch

You think Poyser's onto something? Seemed desperate to me to move the attention.

 

[Poyser]

So to reframe, in a world where you’re town and he’s scum, wouldn’t a likelier play be for him to just limp on to your wagon, in your opinion?

Nah Mitch id probably expect him to try and keep out of it a bit tbh. I’ve never seen him play as mafia so ? Can’t have been scum much and first instinct is to not really want to be on a mislynch wagon. It’s a trap that OMB regularly falls into

 

[Poyser]

Actually

unvote
vote Mitch

Talk me through how you think I’m scum and flip to following my vote?

 

[Tweet]

@Chris don't mean to be harsh buddy but please don't like peoples posts if you're not in the game. It's frowned upon for people outside the game to get involved in even the slightest fashion.

You can like this post if you want if you understand

 

[Smart Marx]

Talk me through how you think I’m scum and flip to following my vote?

Yeah, I'm not a fan of this flip either. I need the thought process here.

 

[Odo]

Nah Mitch id probably expect him to try and keep out of it a bit tbh. I’ve never seen him play as mafia so ? Can’t have been scum much and first instinct is to not really want to be on a mislynch wagon. It’s a trap that OMB regularly falls into

I mean I don’t really know the answer either

 

[Smart Marx]

It's been a few years since I played with a scum Mitch, but I want to say he hangs in the background.

I'm not sure his first move is to discredit a town read.

 

[Leon TrotSky]

Did anyone actually look up my first post voting habits btw? I’m interested to hear your conclusions

I couldn't find a recent game where you opened with just a vote

 

[Poyser]

Well if smark says he’s town, he’s probably town

 

[Tweet]

Talk me through how you think I’m scum and flip to following my vote?

First off a vote within the first hour doesn't necessarily mean I think you're scum, just that I wanna see what happens if I vote you.

My thought process was that much like Smark, I got the feeling that you were looking to direct attention literally anywhere but yourself, and your vote on Mitch seemed like more of that, but then I read your reason for voting him and remembered that you caught Lethal pretty much the same way in Game Show Mafia and thought maybe I oughta give you a chance especially after being dead wrong about you early on two games ago. Also you voting Mitch after his first post is in line with what you frequently do, which is going after weaker players early on and see how they handle the pressure.

 

[Leon TrotSky]

It's been a few years since I played with a scum Mitch, but I want to say he hangs in the background.

I'm not sure his first move is to discredit a town read.

On the other hand, it is easy for him to say given last game + the relative ease with which wagons seem to build on me