Barry Presents: Whodunnit 2: The West Smithton Sagas GAME THREAD

[Comrade Khan]

Poyser wagon seems beaten to death at this point, here's some cool interesting stuff:



The game wasn't even 2 hours old at this point and she posted this. Isn't it too early to post a "conflicting feelings" list? At this point me, KIF, Lethal, Alco, OMB, Haza, and Big Man hadn't even posted yet. Was this really necessary?

I also found the Banez hostility towards Sky really weird. As she seems to be the only person Banez isn't hostile towards.








Good thing about Banez though, judging from his last town game, he's been active. But as previously stated, his hostility seems weird. Either they're scum together and sussing each other. Or perhaps Banez is onto a scum Sky

He's giving me "conflicted feelings"

The list post definitely seemed unnecessary to me, even if she is town. Poyser's posts haven't looked like his usual town self.

This reminds me of last game though, because I remember Sky trying to wagon one of you or Poyser early in the game. It made me question if Sky would do that as scum, as I thought she would be too scared to do it as scum. I town read her because of that and she turned out to be scum so lol. They could be scum together, and she is just trying to play to her "meta".

I also didn't entertain the fact that Banez could be scum with Poyser, and he could just be defending his scum partner from Sky.

Main issue would be those two sentences, that's a lot of scum connections, and not a lot of town reads.Seems a bit fence-sitty, but it could also be him trying to actually work a scum read out. Sample size is also disappointing, unfortunately. The problem is that Brutus is a lazy fuck as all alignments, so I'm not the best at reading those types of players. I will say he doesn't get a town read from me at this time.

 

[RDK]

What does my good friend @Big Man have to say?

 

[Poyser]

Mitch, tweet and I think there’s a fair chance brutus is scum based off of his entrance. I know he has apparently been careful with his vote as town too but I think it looks like a scum entrance tbh

in terms of town ive got jeff, Sky, OMB, haza and lethal. Also think Banez is probably town too

 

[Comrade Khan]

@Odo what are your town reads at the moment ?

 

[Banez]

I've had very little interaction with Poyser.

If i was scum with him, i'd be telling him in QT that we would need to interact bit more.

 

[Comrade Khan]

 

[Mitch Buchannon]

Not a fan of KIF taking Poyser’s side and blindly voting for me, it is KIF though


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[Comrade Khan]

I also noticed some strange talks of Odo being indy? what's that about

 

[Odo]

@Odo what are your town reads at the moment ?

fairly confident on sky and OMB, you to a lesser extent

 

[Leon TrotSky]

I'm not convinced in lynching poyser now for info on his wagon that will still be there if he flipped later. If you think he is scum then thats another thing

1) If we wait till later, more active town / people who opposed him will be dead.
2) What's your alternative?

 

[Odo]

There’s just no way Haza and Poyser can be scum together lmao

 

[Leon TrotSky]

I’ll help.

Unvote, Vote: Poyser

So, Poyser's flip will tell me some things about N0M

 

[Odo]

I don’t think phenom has made a post that makes me think he’s town this year

 

[Banez]

I also noticed some strange talks of Odo being indy? what's that about

What?

Who has made talk of Odo being indy?

 

[Comrade Khan]

KIF and possibly magic agreeing I think it was (don't quote me), I swear I saw it when I was skimming through. found it odd that indy talk would even be mentioned on d1