Barry Presents: Whodunnit 2: The West Smithton Sagas GAME THREAD

[Ricky Smarks]

well I don't hate this post. By that logic, there's scum on this current wagon yes?

According to most theories a proper flip will give us light on his wagon.

 

[Poyser]

Oh right I missed the question about lethal. He seems fine and I think making the effort to move away from sky is actually good, just because he was right last time so it would be an easy thing to stick to when he nailed her and everyone dismissed him. Also going for tweet rather than just trying to get on one of the two bigger wagons seems fairly good too

jeff do you have any thoughts on how brutus came in?

 

[RDK]

According to most theories a proper flip will give us light on his wagon.

I'm not convinced in lynching poyser now for info on his wagon that will still be there if he flipped later. If you think he is scum then thats another thing

 

[RDK]

well I don't hate this post. By that logic, there's scum on this current wagon yes?

If he is town I'd have to assume so

 

[Lethal]

Now that I think about it... If you think Poy is town and have a strong town read on Odo, but doesn't Odo clearly think Poyser is scum?

Clearly is a strong word, and if he was genuine, I think we'd have the bodybag being prepared.

Vote: Tweets

 

[Ricky Smarks]

I'm not convinced in lynching poyser now for info on his wagon that will still be there if he flipped later. If you think he is scum then thats another thing

I do think he's scum, I'm just saying should he flip town, we still get info.

 

[Ricky Smarks]

Clearly is a strong word, and if he was genuine, I think we'd have the bodybag being prepared.

Vote: Tweets

If you're saying what I thin you're saying, you agreeing with my point of Odo not really being as persistent as he is normally.

We all know Odo gets his way when he wants it so I'll note that.

 

[Comrade Khan]

Oh right I missed the question about lethal. He seems fine and I think making the effort to move away from sky is actually good, just because he was right last time so it would be an easy thing to stick to when he nailed her and everyone dismissed him. Also going for tweet rather than just trying to get on one of the two bigger wagons seems fairly good too

jeff do you have any thoughts on how brutus came in?

let me go take a look

 

[Odo]

I mean, I’ll level with you all, my motivation wasn’t high coming in, and as I said before, some of Poysers points are legitimate in a vacuum.

I do think we should be lynching him tho and I’ll take the rap if it’s wrong

 

[Odo]

I’m also kinda bothered that Poyser hasn’t really tried to change my mind, which is surprising

if I were to rationalise that from a scum perspective, I’d say he probably knows I can’t be arsed and not engaging me preserves that status quo?

 

[Ricky Smarks]

I mean, I’ll level with you all, my motivation wasn’t high coming in, and as I said before, some of Poysers points are legitimate in a vacuum.

I do think we should be lynching him tho and I’ll take the rap if it’s wrong

We agree. What a day.

 

[PHEN0M]

I’ll help.

Unvote, Vote: Poyser

 

[Ricky Smarks]

I’m also kinda bothered that Poyser hasn’t really tried to change my mind, which is surprising

if I were to rationalise that from a scum perspective, I’d say he probably knows I can’t be arsed and not engaging me preserves that status quo?

From a certain perspective it does appear you're not pushing him that hard so to not engage you makes the likelihood of you drawing more support less likely. Which leads me to more conviction he's scum as a town Poyser would confront you and get you into the game.

 

[Poyser]

Meh, I’d say if I was scum you’d be the only person who’s mind I’d be trying to change really lol as that would be the one that would turn the tide

I’m more just annoyed that everybody is ignoring pretty much everything else to focus on me, and I can’t get any traction on anybody that I think is scum even though nobody has really brought forth any counter to my points other than me “lucking” into them which is ????

it’s not really doing much for my motivation either

 

[Odo]

Let’s do a bit of due diligence

what are your reads atm? In terms of scum I’ve got Mitch and tweet as the main candidates?