Barry Presents: Whodunnit 2: The West Smithton Sagas GAME THREAD

[Comrade Khan]

You"d probably spend all day not wanting to lynch scum anyways

 

[Odo]

Didn't expect Brutus to be scum on play early on Also I can respect the attempts to avert the lynch, gg buddy.

Did N0M get himself modkilled on purpose?

I'll catch up tomorrow. As in when I wake up tomorrow.

no he was trying to get me killed so far as I know

 

[RDK]

You"d probably spend all day not wanting to lynch scum anyways

So you do not think much is scum?

 

[Odo]

Brutus flipping scum makes it less likely imo, based on day 1

 

[Odo]

If one of you could not use your role til deadline so I can get some sleep before finishing this off, I’d appreciate it

 

[Odo]

Btw what the fuck are these scum roles, jeez Louise

 

[Showtime]

Cool, well the reason I didn’t claim was to stop the big man special where he claims last and picks the most powerful / town role left and y’all just march to death

I could easily claim to be a vig / cop / gunsmith but I’m just a VT, I’ll get the details if anyone needs them

Big man isn't scum tho. No scum team is going to pass up using busdriver n1 lol and his complete inactivity supports that.

 

[Odo]

Big man isn't scum tho. No scum team is going to pass up using busdriver n1 lol and his complete inactivity supports that.

bro, I’m referring to something big man has done in other games, I’m not saying he/rugrat are scum

 

[Tweet]

Btw what the fuck are these scum roles, jeez Louise

I think one of two things is true. Either Barry finally heard us when we told him that his scum teams are too strong and too stacked with roles, or scum are 5 players instead of 4. Maybe an outside chance of the final guy having a recruiter type role to get em up to 5.

 

[Odo]

It won’t be 5 scum and a serial killer, town could lose before day 3

 

[Odo]

@Banez you may return if you kiss the ring

 

[Comrade Khan]

@Banez you may return if you kiss the ring

you're such a f a g










of a player

 

[Odo]

So I’d say there are compelling reasons to think Lethal, Rugrat, Jeff, OMB, Tweet and myself are town

then I’d say it’s likely Haza and Magic are, which leaves Banez and Mitch

 

[Odo]

All of the neon signs with those two point towards Banez IMO, when you consider Poysers play. Now we know he specifically took the time to try help Brutus out, the bus on Mitch feels less likely

 

[Comrade Khan]

I will also say a point in mitch's favor is while i disliked his read lists. I do remember goin back and looking at them and they did evolve organically (from his pov). I also made a fairly strong meta case on banez d2. I agree with the assessment that there are more reasons to read mitch town than banez. I don't think that is arguable