Barry Presents: Sergio Leone Mafia / Una Mafia Del West Game Thread

[Tweet]

Like sure, Alco could potentially be the SK, but this suggestion comes out of the blue to such a degree that I smell a rat.

 

[Comrade Khan]

The other thing I noticed is that Smarks role PM says Watcher, which would be weird cause Odo was also the Watcher, but the role described in Smarks role PM isn't even a Watcher.

"Each night you may also choose to visit a player and see what power they use, but not who they visited."

That's not what a Watcher does, that role is called Follower. Which in my estimation looks like a weaker Rolecop in scums hands.

could also mean we have a weaker cop of our own?

 

[Leon TrotSky]

oh we got their strongman too, ok ya Odo was the scum kill, he asked for protection.

Not necessarily

 

[Comrade Khan]

Like sure, Alco could potentially be the SK, but this suggestion comes out of the blue to such a degree that I smell a rat.

While I initially thought it was indeed a possibility that he is. I do not disagree with you that it does seem out of nowhere shade. Which kind of sucks for my read on him, but that's to be expected with a newer player.

 

[Tweet]

I'd like Chris to answer first, then I'll share my suspicions.

 

[Comrade Khan]

Ok so banez should be cleared imo yea?

 

[Tweet]

Yep I think Banez is almost certainly town

 

[Comrade Khan]

Darth Lethal
Jeffatron - daykiller
PHEN0M
OMB
TheRedPrince - Silvanito, Vanilla Townie
Chris
NotBrutus - mason
Banez - recharger, wtv u wanna call it
9. @TKOK - Cheyenne, Miller
Laughable Chimp
Raidokken - Angel Eyes, Villain Strongman/Gov
Mr.Tweetums
V. Skybox
Tearjerker - Ramon & Esteban, Villain DV/Watcher
Alco
Odo - Nobody, Watcher
Rugrat - Juan Miranda, Mason

claims so far for reference.

 

[Chris]

This entire post feels wrong on so many levels. Where do I begin.
1) Why would you start wild SK spec out of the blue?
2) Why Alco in particular?
3) How have you determined that Alco is more active than usual in your first game of playing with us?
4) What makes you think activity or playing well is an indicator of if Alco might be the SK or not? (You kinda answered this but it's still weird, Alco has played this game for like 500 years, I doubt he's one to get too excited over playing indy

I have a theory on what's going on here

unvote
vote Chris

1. SK had been brought up as the Rugrats potential killer, realized after my post that SK spec was pretty pointless now as Jeff pointed out quickly as well.
2. You answered this yourself in question 4, and I also clearly stated that if it was a terrible take that I'd want someone like you or Jeff to shut it down quickly which you did
3. Because I barely remember seeing his name in any of the games played here even though he's been signed up for most of them I believe
4. No clue how long Alco has played so you're probably right here.

 

[Chris]

I'd like Chris to answer first, then I'll share my suspicions.

Can we share now?

 

[Leon TrotSky]

Unvote
Vote Chris

Since no one is team N0M. Plus I like theories

 

[Tweet]

1. SK had been brought up as the Rugrats potential killer, realized after my post that SK spec was pretty pointless now as Jeff pointed out quickly as well.
2. You answered this yourself in question 4, and I also clearly stated that if it was a terrible take that I'd want someone like you or Jeff to shut it down quickly which you did
3. Because I barely remember seeing his name in any of the games played here even though he's been signed up for most of them I believe
4. No clue how long Alco has played so you're probably right here.

Yes, indy hunting is generally frowned upon in this section early on into a game, like speculation and stuff is fine but actually making it your top priority isn't a good look. As town you just let scum and the SK care about each other and figure out how to circumvent one another. Those answers are fair enough but still, it came outta nowhere to such a degree and with such unnatural conviction it just rubbed me the wrong way.

 

[Kim Jong Umb]

Darth Lethal
Jeffatron - daykiller
PHEN0M
OMB
TheRedPrince - Silvanito, Vanilla Townie
Chris
NotBrutus - mason
Banez - recharger, wtv u wanna call it
9. @TKOK - Cheyenne, Miller
Laughable Chimp
Raidokken - Angel Eyes, Villain Strongman/Gov
Mr.Tweetums
V. Skybox
Tearjerker - Ramon & Esteban, Villain DV/Watcher
Alco
Odo - Nobody, Watcher
Rugrat - Juan Miranda, Mason

I color coated my thoughts right now orange is slight leans to maf red is maf blue is town black idk

 

[Chris]

Yes, indy hunting is generally frowned upon in this section early on into a game, like speculation and stuff is fine but actually making it your top priority isn't a good look. As town you just let scum and the SK care about each other and figure out how to circumvent one another. Those answers are fair enough but still, it came outta nowhere to such a degree and with such unnatural conviction it just rubbed me the wrong way.

What unnatural conviction was there about me saying "idk guys if this is out there then let me know so I can shut it down" lmao

 

[Kim Jong Umb]

I am fine voting Chris tbh but, I rather actually dive deeper into Darth & NotBrutus unless any obvious intel.