Barry Presents: Sergio Leone Mafia / Una Mafia Del West Game Thread

[Comrade Khan]

I was pushing Sky hard af but go off.

Did you? I just did a quick search and found no evidence of a vote on sky. in fact. afaik, you've only voted for:
CP
Haza
OMB

 

[Chris]

I lean Smark as scum more than Odo obviously but after that last exchange if Smark were to flip town I'd wanna consider Odo as scum more where previously I would have leaned town/town exchange if Smark flipped town.

Logically I just can't see Smark as scum using or knowing about the usage of the sheriff role and then coming in saying "Hey thanks for saving me stranger" when he only had 3 votes. Most likely scenario feels like he assumed wrongly it was the definition of "governor" he knew which only works if a lynch was achieved I guess. If it seemed like he only came up with that governor semantics argument a little bit later, I'd say it was definitely a scum defense.

His confusion about the role seemed genuine I guess is the point I'm getting at, where I don't think that would have happened if he was scum unless he's just playing dumb but once again the sheriff usage still leaves Smark as clear target for day 2 and I'm not convinced he was going towards a lynch day 1 either to warrant that save unless the scum team REALLY needed his night role and were really scared about his wagon

 

[RDK]

Yes, it’s a fucking Blue role to give, and the moment you use it, you’re an idiot if you’re town

hey now, that's not a very nice thing to say

 

[Smart Marx]

So voting without getting a read is the way we play now. Noted.

 

[Comrade Khan]

CP was for same reasons as everyone, u followed me on Haza, and OMB seems like a throwaway from my pov as well

 

[Tweet]

I was pushing Sky hard af but go off.

Yeah and as I said I read Sky town pretty early on so it's a no from me. Also going for Sky is literally the easiest thing one could do as scum.

 

[Odo]

Also since I stupidly wrong on the Smark wagon, @Odo would you agree Phenom's wagon is the dirtier one?

as things stand, I think Phenom is town and Haza is scum. Aware lethal started the wagon, but his play makes sense to me so far and I think his posts are solid

I’ll have to dig it up, but when the heat started being applied to smark, Haza then added to phenoms wagon, but used some real flimsy ass reasoning (talking about quick lynches)

 

[RDK]

I think Smark is town

 

[Smart Marx]

Yeah and as I said I read Sky town pretty early on so it's a no from me. Also going for Sky is literally the easiest thing one could do as scum.

So I can't push people you town read or elsewhere I'm listed as pushing no one? Noted.

 

[Rugrat]

hey now, that's not a very nice thing to say

go drink soylent

 

[Chris]

I think Lethal looks good rn as well. Obviously none of my reads are any sort of concrete though

 

[Comrade Khan]

as things stand, I think Phenom is town and Haza is scum. Aware lethal started the wagon, but his play makes sense to me so far and I think his posts are solid

I’ll have to dig it up, but when the heat started being applied to smark, Haza then added to phenoms wagon, but used some real flimsy ass reasoning (talking about quick lynches)

He had his weird post about too many flips day 1 as well which seemed very irrelevant to the current situation

 

[Comrade Khan]

edit: it was about too many claims early d1/early game, not too many day 1 flips. misspoke there

 

[Chris]

He had his weird post about too many flips day 1 as well which seemed very irrelevant to the current situation

I think I remember folks talking about too much info being given to scum early on in the last few games here tbh and I also agree that it probably does give scum a headstart. Would be interested to know if the people bringing it up in the past ended up being scum though

 

[Comrade Khan]

And yeah, I'm defo much less strong on Mr. Lethal, as stated I did like his posts as I was leaving last night, and his explanation on starting the Nom wagon makes a lot more sense than the people who hopped on it.