Barry Presents: Sergio Leone Mafia / Una Mafia Del West Game Thread

[Comrade Khan]

Theres 0.way town used a gov shot here lol. While i disagree its always given to scum (ive had the displeasure of drawing it as town). There's 0 reason for town to.use it here on d1.

Scum used it to pidgeonhole us to smark, end of story. Wethere that means yes scum or not is the only relevant thing to discuss on the matter imo

 

[Chris]

Unless Barry changed his version, day doesn't end unless I was already lynched.

You didn't have anywhere near enough votes for a lynch though right? Unless we're assuming what an executioner? Whatever it is that lets scum hammer early or something

 

[Smart Marx]

You didn't have anywhere near enough votes for a lynch though right? Unless we're assuming what an executioner? Whatever it is that lets scum hammer early or something

Then this is different altogether. I have no idea. Governor overturns a lynch. It doesn't stop day.

 

[Smart Marx]

You didn't have anywhere near enough votes for a lynch though right? Unless we're assuming what an executioner? Whatever it is that lets scum hammer early or something

Executioner would stop day early if the wagon had half the vote needed, but that kills the person.

 

[Chris]

With no setup spec whatsoever bc I have no idea where to start on that. The sheriff definitely feels scummy to me for the timing. I don't see how it helps town since we just started to talk about OMB as well

 

[Tweet]

Yes indeed. It was 1/10 effort to start something to maybe get him into playing. Similar tact to what I used with Big Man in Ys origin. The fact that Banez and Haza followed it is where I'm looking tomorrow.

Once again,

 

[Lethal]

The fact that the Governor didn't claim or use the role in public is a sure sign that they didn't use their role for all the right reasons. It means they used it either because both they and you are scum, or because they are scum making town Smark look even worse. The latter seems like a waste cause you were headed for a lynch anyway. Any way you slice it, that was just not a town usage.

Unless Barry changed his version, day doesn't end unless I was already lynched.

What role is it then?

 

[Comrade Khan]

Theres also going to logically be scum on smarks wagon regardless of his allignment fwiw

 

[Comrade Khan]

The fact that the Governor didn't claim or use the role in public is a sure sign that they didn't use their role for all the right reasons. It means they used it either because both they and you are scum, or because they are scum making town Smark look even worse. The latter seems like a waste cause you were headed for a lynch anyway. Any way you slice it, that was just not a town usage.

This. 100x this.

 

[Chris]

Then this is different altogether. I have no idea. Governor overturns a lynch. It doesn't stop day.

Yeah it doesn't sound like this was related to any lynch as far as I can see from the voting so maybe we should just call it sheriff instead of governor to get away from definition arguments

 

[Smart Marx]

What role is it then?

I could look into it. Only executioner comes to mind. Barry could have crossed the two, but IDK.

 

[Odo]

The semantics of what the role is called are irrelevant

a role that stops day 14 hours early with no discussion that isn’t submitted in the thread is a scum role

this isn’t up for debate

 

[Odo]

Or from another angle, if it’s a town role, I look forward to them claiming and justifying the usage

 

[Odo]

Theres also going to logically be scum on smarks wagon regardless of his allignment fwiw

how do you work this? There’s only 3 players right?

 

[Smart Marx]

I like how Odo thinks he's always in charge of what's up for debate.

Now that I know I wasn't lynched, it does seem more geared to be a scum role. I will say.

Why use it when I wasn't even lynched yet?