Sure, I won't deny that I noticed both Sky and PHEN0M soft protective roles so their flip/claim don't surprise me in the slightest.
I gotta think about your case here because it feels off but not in a scummy kinda way. Like if you're scum there's just no need to suddenly put me into the equation, because if my POE is Brutus+Alco+PHEN0M in that order, you as potential scum would have no reason to change the direction of this phase because at least 2 out of those 3 would not be your teammates. At the same time it feels hecking weird to suddenly play goldfish and throw your read on me overboard like that, especially seeing as I was the first vote on Smark.
It's not a bad theory at all.
I dont know how tweets plays as scum, atleast i can't recall a game with him atm. But then again i'm behind of everyone anyway in terms of play so i wouldn't be able to read half of the people.
Alco has been very active which i like, i've lynched him in past when he wasn't as active and i really wanted to believe he was town.
Alright then, *takes off mask* Alco isn't the SK, I am.
I'm not a standard SK tho, my role is called Bounty Hunter. I gotta kill one character in particular, I'm not allowed to claim which one but if they die at night, I win the game. If they get lynched instead, I lose my shots but can still win with town. I can tell you that Lethal is not the character I'm looking for, if he was I'd have won by now. I got no other roles to balance out this sorta easy win condition, hence why I claimed VT.
I shot Rugrat and Sky cause I was reasonably certain no Watcher would be on Rugrat n1, and also that nobody would think that I as the SK would shoot people who I town read and who sorta town read me in return. I think I gave myself away by just dropping off a cliff with my town play after Smark and Haza died, as well as just being preoccupied with thoughts revolving around the SK. Oh well.
Like I said, even if I don't find my target I can win with town, so killing me essentially gets rid of another townie.