Barry Presents: an Oversimplified MAFIA Game Thread

[Comrade Khan]

also explain the nature in which all three of those players and why it makes them lean town

 

[Comrade Khan]

Why don’t you buy jt

seemed generous given the player

 

[Comrade Khan]

IF you're honest? Okay that raises a red flag for me!

I'm always honest, they call me Honest Jeff even

 

[Chris]

Tbf I'm still null-ish on Sky. Her posts have pinged me the most but she's always played pretty scummy as town so I can see her wishing for a distraction either way

I would also like more elaboration on those town reads from TFW too, seem pretty easy

 

[Comrade Khan]

yes please, don't dodge me fourth

 

[RDK]

Haza and CP playing mafia together again

 

[Smart Marx]

We’re not lynching/wagoning sky day one. Let her play.

I'm with nom on this one.

 

[RDK]

Together but not TOGETHER, we aren't on a scum team if that's what you're thinking

 

[Comrade Khan]

Together but not TOGETHER, we aren't on a scum team if that's what you're thinking

so more like a platonic couple

 

[Leon TrotSky]

We’re not lynching/wagoning sky day one. Let her play.

Not sure how to feel about this to be honest.

 

[Smart Marx]

IF you're honest? Okay that raises a red flag for me!

It's a figure of speech.

 

[Smart Marx]

Not sure how to feel about this to be honest.

I agree with him. It's your first game back, we can circle back to you if it becomes obvious you're trouble.

 

[Leon TrotSky]

Like, I see a possible angle of trying to protect me to win town points for when I do die, but I think SCUMN0M would be more opportunistic. Nevertheless, a little weirded out

 

[Marty McFourth]

It'd be easier if I just pick out their posts I liked

Why does it worry you that you don't specifically find TFW scummy without anyone on your radar? Do you think you're supposed to?

Sky needs a day 0 read list from TP

But seriously, not a fan of that post or a lot of others from Sky so far. Those kinds of distractions are almost never good for town and just let scum have a crutch to lean on so I wouldn't want want at all, the game can get moving without them and it seems like this one is

^ Feels like town posts to me. Indepedent thought process, questioning. Just vibing geniune.

More pressure on CP imo.

In all seriousness, CP, thoughts on this Poyser and Sky interaction and Jeff's "facetious" comments about it?

Just want to hear more from him.

^ Kinda feels like town Smark questioning everything around him, pressuring people and feeling others out. CP hasn't really done anything I would not expect from him though fwiw, in fact I'd say he's done more than I recall this early.

Interesting that you're able to glean a vibe after such a time away for both of us and after so few posts

In all seriousness, I really don't like this being defensive over a clearly humorous post. Feels like something I'd pull

I'd say "maybe you should make that more clear" but maybe if you did that you'd have come across even more defensive

I don't find TFW's actions immediately suspicious, and that worries me. Because by now usually someone's on my radar. Am I just rusty

It was a misunderstanding and you explained that. Now I'm back to a bunch of nulls

The question is, how do you feel you usually enter a game? Especially in games when you're entering during the fluff phase

^ I would say all these posts felt like they came from a town player. To me Sky feels very comfortable in this game thus far.

I want to stress that these are really early reads, a lot of it is just because how they are vibing in the thread to me. I just like how they all approached the game, and these are the only people I would say I felt anything about so far. Rest of the players are pretty null, and I need to see a lot more content and people posting.

 

[Leon TrotSky]

A lot of people say I come across more comfortable as town, which is interesting. That may be, but I feel more comfortable as scum. Knowing a few alignments right off the bat helps me get a foothold in understanding the game, and I like figuring out of the game regardless of alignment