Barry Presents: an Oversimplified MAFIA Game Thread

[RetepAdam.]

What is it exactly thats giving you such a hard scum read on phenom in particular?

He's the only player in the entire game who hasn't had a post I've read and though "Oh, I like this."

That's an enormous red flag. Literally no trace of him having had a thought process or trying to solve.

 

[Poyser]

That no one else had actually committed at the time, so him joining the wagon when he did feels unnecessary if they were actually aligned.

And he had previously advocated for lynching Doddsy, though I'd have to go back and check when in the scheme of things that was.

He didn’t advocate lynching Doddsy before Doddsy became a main target. He just kept Doddsy in his poe. That’s it.

i don’t see it as unnecessary lol, what do you think the game plan would be if the last 3 scum are Doddsy, CP and one of blaine/phenom? Do you think they’d go all out to lynch the non teammate first and hope nobody lynches them or do you think they might do some bussing lol

 

[Poyser]

Because by your logic, phenom also strongly advocated to lynch Doddsy!

 

[RetepAdam.]

He didn’t advocate lynching Doddsy before Doddsy became a main target. He just kept Doddsy in his poe. That’s it.

i don’t see it as unnecessary lol, what do you think the game plan would be if the last 3 scum are Doddsy, CP and one of blaine/phenom? Do you think they’d go all out to lynch the non teammate first and hope nobody lynches them or do you think they might do some bussing lol

With 10 players left, knowing it could potentially be 3/3/1 if things broke right at Night...?

Also, not convinced that the split would've been 10/4/1 in a vanilla game, but that's neither here nor there.

 

[Canadian Dragon]

im paying attention btw i just think this is a good discussion and dont have much to add to the current subject

 

[RetepAdam.]

Because by your logic, phenom also strongly advocated to lynch Doddsy!

As opposed to himself?

 

[Lethal]

Were you pre-annoyed by the questioning before I even asked any?

i ask because you literally said you were gonna do a readback and prepare for the grilling and said you’d bring lube lol

I just think you’re full of shit tbh (in-game!)

THEN FUCKING LYNCH ME. Jesus you're beyond scummy, such a hard-on, but you've got the cop result and the lynching of Tweet & Doddsy.

I have started my readback, but hey, why the fuck should I do it when this fucked narrative continues?

 

[Poyser]

With 10 players left, knowing it could potentially be 3/3/1 if things broke right at Night...?

Also, not convinced that the split would've been 10/4/1 in a vanilla game, but that's neither here nor there.

33% of the game is 10/5 town go non town which is generally the rule we use. 25% mafia which is obv somewhere between 3 and 4. It’s barry, there’s not a chance in hell he only gave them 3 members lolol

and you can’t count on it being 3/3/1 in any case because if you lynch the only townie in poe then you’re just narrowing the field for the cop and SK to hit you. I’m not saying they wouldn’t jump on a phenom lynch if it were possible but in their situation with the game looking not great, I really don’t see them extending themselves going for a mislynch there

 

[Lethal]

Day 1 Vote Count:

Haza (8) - PHEN0M, CP, Sky, Chris, Smark, Poyser, Jeff, TFW
Tweet (2) - Lethal Banks, RetepAdam.
Chris (2) - Tweet, T-Pein
Sky (1) - Haza

Day 2 Vote Count:

Blaine (1) - CP
T-Pein (7) - Sky, Poyser, Jeff, Smark, Lethal, Chris, Doddsy
Chris (1) - T-Pein

Day 3 Vote Count:

Doddsy (6) - Sky, CP, Smark, PHEN0M, Jeff, RetepAdam.

I want to do some work on this later.

Right ==> I've found my night kill post, 44 pages. Juicy times ahead.

 

[RetepAdam.]

With 10 players left, knowing it could potentially be 3/3/1 if things broke right at Night...?

I want to stay on this, though.

In this scenario: It's 6/3/1 at the time of the phase. A mislynch would bring it to 5/3/1. Night would have a chance to bring it to 3/3/1 or 4/3. Why bus if you can avoid it?

 

[Chris]

im paying attention btw i just think this is a good discussion and dont have much to add to the current subject

Same, I'm still pretty split on N0M and CP myself

 

[Poyser]

THEN FUCKING LYNCH ME. Jesus you're beyond scummy, such a hard-on, but you've got the cop result and the lynching of Tweet & Doddsy.

I have started my readback, but hey, why the fuck should I do it when this fucked narrative continues?

Yeah, I look super scummy except being copped town and going for the 2 flipped scum. But if you ignore all that I’m the scummiest player in the game!!!!!

 

[Lethal]

Yeah, I look super scummy except being copped town and going for the 2 flipped scum. But if you ignore all that I’m the scummiest player in the game!!!!!

Worried?

 

[RetepAdam.]

33% of the game is 10/5 town go non town which is generally the rule we use. 25% mafia which is obv somewhere between 3 and 4. It’s barry, there’s not a chance in hell he only gave them 3 members lolol

and you can’t count on it being 3/3/1 in any case because if you lynch the only townie in poe then you’re just narrowing the field for the cop and SK to hit you. I’m not saying they wouldn’t jump on a phenom lynch if it were possible but in their situation with the game looking not great, I really don’t see them extending themselves going for a mislynch there

You know what's worse than narrowing the field for the cop and SK to hit you?

Actively killing your teammates.

 

[Poyser]

You know what's worse than narrowing the field for the cop and SK to hit you?

Actively killing your teammates.

I feel like you’re just being dense on purpose here tbh

you have to think about life after the current phase, you know? The only chance any of those guys have of escaping poe is to bus and look good from flips