A Good Day to Die Hard: Mafia with a Vengeance [Game Thread]

[Smart Marx]

Gotta do what you gotta do to win.

 

[Ekkologix]

Also, he should be rewarded for abstaining. After claiming it was his best bet to win. He needed to trick town into thinking there wasn’t a serial killer and it seems like he succeeded. Not killing makes his win take longer so he has to fend off the lynch longer.

There’s risk and reward for both killing and not.

ur still failing to see my point lmao
its okay if he can abstain and literally make everyone fail on him
my role and only my role shud still bypass his defense lol. thats the part we arent agreeing on

because i have no indication or prior knowledge whatsoever that an SK can avoid my ability like that. it becomes bastardy

this isn't like a cop vs godfather, cuz cop is still useful against other mafia roles and this is common knowledge. here i am useless against anyone but the serial, yet i became useless against the serial as well leading into whole bunch of unecessary chaos

him being outed day 1 didnt come from think air lol. we had to hunt him out and force his claim. imagine a world where that didnt happen. i would be using my ability on other players n1 and n2. maybe i wuda died b4 i can check him even

he heard me talk about serial couple of times. he wuda probably shot me for sure and none of this wuda even happened

 

[Ekkologix]

You can't be serious

i actually am lol

 

[Doddsy]

i actually am lol

We didn't waste a phase thinking Poyser was SK cause your shot didn't work we lost a phase thinking Poyser was the SK cause you made a WOAT play

 

[Ekkologix]

We didn't waste a phase thinking Poyser was SK cause your shot didn't work we lost a phase thinking Poyser was the SK cause you made a WOAT play

which happened because my shot didnt work
no reason to make it otherwise

 

[Ekkologix]

imagine u have a role that literally only works againt 1/17 role

well

except it doesnt work on him either

yea im definitely getting trolled so lets call it a day

 

[Smart Marx]

You know godfathers exist and serial killers have a long history of having a similar immunity.

There’s zero reason for you to believe your role is a strongman that can’t be fucked with.

Especially since you got a no result. A bastard result is if I just gave you he’s not a serial killer because you’d have no reason not to believe that result, but with no result there was zero reason for you to clear him.

 

[Smart Marx]

imagine u have a role that literally only works againt 1/17 role

well

except it doesnt work on him either

yea im definitely getting trolled so lets call it a day

It works on him if he’s killing and had he not been caught he’d have been killing.

You’re not getting trolled. For some reason you think the role needs to be protected when regular cops aren’t and that’s just silly. Sorry.

 

[Smart Marx]

which happened because my shot didnt work
no reason to make it otherwise

There wasn’t a reason either way. You never fake info.

 

[Smart Marx]

I’ve used a serial killer cop in most of my games with serial killers. Now I’m definitely gonna fucking question using them ever again if they’re so controversial.

 

[Smart Marx]

Fourth
Haza
Blaze

Since Junk said to give it to Blaze.

 

[RDK]

Well deserved tfw

We straight into Xmas maf sign up now?

 

[Smart Marx]

Yeah, should be X-Mas now if someone has one ready.

 

[Hidden Blaze]

Fourth
Haza
Blaze

Since Junk said to give it to Blaze.

I would’ve been happy either way, as like, I do this for the fun of it and for learning, but thank you!

 

[Smart Marx]

I would’ve been happy either way, as like, I do this for the fun of it and for learning, but thank you!

You earned it! You’re welcome.