A Good Day to Die Hard: Mafia with a Vengeance [Game Thread]

[Poyser]

I mean you’re like the best player here.

I’d love to see the win ratio for survivors on here and WF. I can almost guarantee it’s like 15% at best.

I’d this section didn’t have mass claim it would be different, but town never lets a survivor live once they are forced to claim.

Not on recent showings

 

[Comrade Khan]

Nah most people advocate for letting survivors go. It depends on the situation of the game. If you don’t have to claim until D3 then town usually can’t lynch you anyway or want to lynch scum over you. And when you claim mafia aren’t gonna kill you. Legit all you gotta do is skate by for 2 days lol

I suppose I've never seen a survivor claim I believed to be fair, and 99% they have just been the sk so its likely a bias around here. If a player played well n claimed it at mass claim it may survive. Its never surviving a d1 claim under pressure though imo , unless an sk happens to flip shortly after

 

[Dolph Zinger]

A lot of things I'd do differently this game for sure. I still don't really understand the other side to being Mafia, like killing actions and fake claiming etc. The one thing I feel like I've learned is to at least replicate my town play a bit better. I was nowhere near as active as I am as town in this game, but I did my best to try and blend in and seem like I was scum hunting. Fell apart a bit later on.

I knew when you voted for me, similar to how I knew Sky was town when she voted for me

 

[RDK]

Can I get added to scum chat

 

[Poyser]

I suppose I've never seen a survivor claim I believed to be fair, and 99% they have just been the sk so its likely a bias around here. If a player played well n claimed it at mass claim it may survive. Its never surviving a d1 claim under pressure though imo , unless an sk happens to flip shortly after

It wouldn’t survive a D1 claim most likely, but how hard is it to get through D1 without claiming? If you don’t manage that then you hardly deserve to win lol

 

[Dolph Zinger]

At the end of the day, mafia pulled off 3 myslynches before the final phase. Regardless of if they used one of the two roles town know exist or if town myslynched Wang on their own, and chances are they do, mafia earned this win. Town didn’t play well. Just didn’t.

Mafia pulled off 2 mislynches, Ekko did the 3rd one by himself

 

[Comrade Khan]

It wouldn’t survive a D1 claim most likely, but how hard is it to get through D1 without claiming? If you don’t manage that then you hardly deserve to win lol

I don't disagree

 

[Chris]

Mafia pulled off 2 mislynches, Ekko did the 3rd one by himself

Fair account of things lol

 

[Comrade Khan]

Mafia pulled off 2 mislynches, Ekko did the 3rd one by himself

Sometimes the mafia gods gift those worthy of its boons.

 

[Poyser]

Anyway I have my opinions on the setup but I don’t actually wanna take anything away from scum. They did enough and we didn’t. I’m extra annoyed because I know I missed some easy shit and it’s hard to take that it was such an easy game to figure out and I didn’t do it quick enough. As haza said, town just didn’t play well when it was all said and done.

 

[Smart Marx]

Mafia pulled off 2 mislynches, Ekko did the 3rd one by himself

He’s still town, though.

Sucks when a teammate does that.

 

[Poyser]

Mafia pulled off 2 mislynches, Ekko did the 3rd one by himself

Yep lol

 

[Marty McFourth]

You did stick out, but you did just enough to never make yourself a top priority, which is the sign of a good game imo. There’s pitfalls to appearing too townie as well when you’re scum. The claim was a notch but there was so many other distractions by that time that it didn’t matter!

im not gonna lie I’m super annoyed at myself. The night I shot zinger I actually wanted to shoot you or blaze. But I wasn’t confident enough to shoot you and thought it would be fucking WOAT shit If you were town and I killed your role lmao. And then I didn’t shoot blaze because I wanted to see if you would choose him to target over Peter. So I shot zinger. Didn’t matter really since you guys shot him anyway but pretty shit shot lmao

Yea, I miss out on that extra notch from my town game naturally. I would say early on I tried to push things as genuine as I could, stuff I'd actually likely push if I was town too. I lack the confidence in late game a lot.

Oh, we definitely were vibing that you might. I was worried about Blaze especially, I was fully expecting you to shoot him and I was prepared for him to go out on the night we shot Zinger. Very lucky night for us.

 

[Comrade Khan]

Other times you play like a genius n lose anyways. Mafia is a fickle bitch

 

[Poyser]

That Ekko shit was legit infuriating lmao.