I'm simply baffled how anyone could say RAW had the better show. Either Vince chose to completely ignore TNA and put on the same garbage show he puts on week in and week out or that was him really trying to have a good show and failing miserably.
How ANYONE was watching Orton/Kofi while AJ and Angle were putting on a possibly MOTY candidate just flies completely over my head. The only redeeming quality of RAW last night was Bret's appearance, which due to WWE's below 10 audience was met with a completely luke warm reception.
TNA just stole WWE's second biggest (arguably biggest) face, debuted Hogan among others, put on a MOTY candidate, started some awesome storylines and all you can do is call justify it by saying there was too much going on? They put on perhaps the best wrestling show in 10 years. Who cares if WWE had slightly more wrestling than TNA. The matches TNA did put on blew everything WWE was running at the same time out of the fucking water. And their backstage skits and promos were actually ENTERTAINING.
If last night wasn't a wake up call to Vince I don't know what will be.
I mean, holy shit. Anyone who doesn't think TNA could rival RAW on a weekly basis is out of their minds.
I disagree with 99% you said, AJ/Angle was the best match on tv last night. I'm not out of my mind either, you're justifiably excited but to call that the best show in TEN years is wrong. It wasn't. Not even close.
First of all, WHAT THE FUCK WITH THE COMMERCIALS. Half of Impact was nothing but commercials. The best part was during the main event when Tenay goes "we will stay with this match all the way through it's conclusion..." BAM! Commercial.
They did debut Jeff, that's fine. They handled it in a very shitty manner and shat on the X-division to do it. Not to mention to bring him in with a never was like Shannon Moore was just plain boring and he's a teeny-bopper to boot? Giving 13 year old girls paintings and kisses? Pass.
So many interesting storylines?? Like what? Another nWo rehash with a fat out of shape Hall, and a cast of dudes whom looked like they escaped outta the Wrestler's retirement home? Sting in the rafters...AGAIN! Exciting. I've never seen that before. Lashley and his bitch quitting the promotion before Hogan even showed up? Really? Ripping up the "script" to ruin the card with a boring Joe-Abyss match instead of the advertised bard wire match that had me all excited in the beginning? Hogan coming in as face, then heeling out on Jarrett midway then making it all to obvious of the nWo reformation?
None of that was interesting, and we've seen so many nWo rehashes that it's too old for even novelty. And sadly everything was booked in traditional TNA clusterfuck fashion.
Then the world champ wasn't even featured until the show was two-thirds done, way to feature the young guys TNA! Morgan and Hernandez get a 45 second squash?! Way to feature the young guys TNA! An X-division CAGE match that could and should have stolen the show ends in a FUCKING DISQUALIFACATION?? Not to mention the camera was awful, the cage looked cheesy and the match was half-assed at best. They had the fans chanting "BULLSHIT" 10 minutes into the show. And it was. Jeff Hardy coming out of nowhere to feud with an undercard X-Division wrestler? A waste. He should have been in AJ's face or someone up in the card, not a relative no one like Homicide. I can't see how people don't think Jeff Hardy was handled terribly, he's a bigger name than everyone that debuted not named Flair and Hogan combined.
Then guys like Orlando Jordan, Val Venis, the Nasty Boys, XPac, and Shannon Moore were added to the roster. For what? To basically steal money, deny tv time for young up and coming guys that Hogan and Jarrett promised would shine. These guys have basically zero name value, in Moore and Jordan's cases they never did, and really can't contribute to TNA in any real positive way. It just seems like TNA was giving contracts to anyone WWE has released for shits and giggles. And it's really sad that the Nastys got more screen time than 90% of TNA's homegrown talent.
People talk about how bad WWE's comedy sketches are with DX and the fucking midget, but TNA's idea of comedy sucked far worse and even "strip poker" with some ugly chicks with nice tits couldn't mask that.
Then the wrestling. Yes, Kurt/AJ was fucking awesome. The KO tag match was the next best match, and Kong is the best women's worker going today. Everything else was blah at best. The singles KO match? Botchy, only good thing was Tara's censored ass-crack. I don't need to get started again on the epic failure of the X cage match, Morgan-Hernandez squash was pointless, Joe-Abyss was slow and boring. The only other passable match was Wolfe-Pope and that thing looked like a rehearsal more than what they are capable of doing. WWE presented more wrestling, and more solid wrestling.
And don't get me wrong, I'm not bashing TNA, and there was some good outside AJ/Angle, like the possibility of Flair helping legitimize AJ, the masked man attacking people as corny as it wa, it has me wondering who it is. Jarrett's promo was the best promo cut all night, it was fucking passionate, too bad Hogan had to shit all over it. Pope is over as any young dude on the roster and I think he and Nigel will have some very good matches. Kong is still fucking awesome.
But here's why I can't figure how TNA was better than Raw. They claimed they are wrestling, yet we get thrown back into poor man's WCW in the ECW arena. No namers and washups were given more screen time than the young, talented up and comers, there were too many backstage segments and not enough wrestling. They just plain didn't make good on the promise of a true wrestling show with up and coming exciting talent. The show was a good old boys reunion and was marred with rehashes of stuff ten years past it's prime and dudes no one ever gave a fuck about. And the one true coup they had they fucked up big time. You don't stick a guy who was headlining the only promotion that matters in the mix with undercard guys. You stick him right at the fucking top. TNA, to me, failed to deliver anything fresh or exciting.
Now, don't get me wrong, Raw wasn't exactly the greatest show of the past ten years either. But seeing Bret trumped everyone on TNA sans Jeff, Raw had more solid wrestling, and was a generally better booked show.
TNA had way too much on it's plate and the booking showed as it disregarded what made it unique and tried too hard to get in guys they think would make them relevant and it just failed.
I think people are overly excited that a new show was on the block and that the feeling from wrestling's heyday was back with some semblance to the Monday night wars. But to call it the best show in ten years is incorrect and to be dumbfounded as to why people preferred Raw to TNA is baffling and more of blind bias than fair rationale. Vince has nothing to fear, he's on the Raod to Wrestlemania, perhaps the best WM in years and the product always picks up at this time and in these next four months he'll make more money than TNA will all year. If Heyman gets the book in TNA then maybe he should pay attention.