"Lawyer Fucked Me" A Shawshank Redemption Mafia Game Presented By Barry (Game Thread)

[Wang Chung]

He reminds me of OMB.

Nah

 

[R-Troop]

It shouldn’t. It’s just a game my good dude. Cheers.

Now, is Sky your top suspect? How do you feel about Looch?

I have been on Sky since the beginning. Same with Poyser and (to a lesser extent) Jean.

The Tree Stump thing feels moot to me. I don't care if a dead person can do Game Chat if they can't vote. Also who's to say Mafia Tree Stump can't exist.

 

[Loochquake]

My apologies for being new to this.

I can now see why everyone hated the Mafia people on this forum back when the old crew was here. This game is making people toxic.

From what I've seen and heard the "old" crew had more toxicity flowing through. While I can see how this game can be frustrating as fuck, I haven't really seen a single moment that was really out of line, flat out toxic behavior. Just saying... I know everyone has their own borders and stuff when it comes to these things.

 

[Fuji Vice]

I hate to say this but our safest route today maybe lynching Sky. We lose her vote if she is what she says she is but we dont lose her voice.

This would allow us to see if Troop is right and since we still have the numbers in the game we can them allow Fuji to check someone else and give us a checkmark off the board.

Then we go the other way the next day?

5 vs 1.

We can Mislynch today be at 4 vs 1

IF mafia hits tonight its then 3 vs 1

If we mislynch again its 2 vs 1.

IF mafia gets a kill through its game over.

So essentially we have today and tomorrow to get this rights.

Yeah, I tend to agree with this line of thinking. Besides, I have already lined out above how this SHOULD get us the final mafia, provided I make it through the night. Even if I don't, you'll have a 50/50 shot the next day.

 

[Fuji Vice]

I have been on Sky since the beginning. Same with Poyser and (to a lesser extent) Jean.

The Tree Stump thing feels moot to me. I don't care if a dead person can do Game Chat if they can't vote. Also who's to say Mafia Tree Stump can't exist.

Nobody would listen to a word a mafia stump said. It's strictly a town role, albeit an non-powerful one.

Stump is a fun role in certain games. For example, in a WWE themed game, it was the Undertaker character, who still helped town after he died. In a Harry Potter one, it was Moaning Myrtle, though that player didn't help us at all, haha.

Anyways, I digress. I'm ok with lynching Sky if that's what the majority wants. As Wang said, it would also help to clear up some feelings about you, seeing as you've been on her for awhile. I really think that's our best bet.

 

[Fuji Vice]

It does seem like the majority here feel strongly that Sky is potentially the final mafia. It won't kill us to find out if that's the case.

 

[R-Troop]

Nobody would listen to a word a mafia stump said. It's strictly a town role, albeit an non-powerful one.

Stump is a fun role in certain games. For example, in a WWE themed game, it was the Undertaker character, who still helped town after he died. In a Harry Potter one, it was Moaning Myrtle, though that player didn't help us at all, haha.

Anyways, I digress. I'm ok with lynching Sky if that's what the majority wants. As Wang said, it would also help to clear up some feelings about you, seeing as you've been on her for awhile. I really think that's our best bet.

My question is what benefit does Tree Stump have. Like you dead but can still Game chat. OK it isn't like Tree Stump can say "so and so killed me" or go into dead chat and the other Mafia people spill who their partner is.

Plus, a stump is dead they can't win if town wins after they die right?

 

[Loochquake]

Anyways, I digress. I'm ok with lynching Sky if that's what the majority wants. As Wang said, it would also help to clear up some feelings about you, seeing as you've been on her for awhile. I really think that's our best bet.

From all the lists and suspects everyone gave, I guess it does come down to what Wang and Avie want to do. Unless Sky or Troop wanna change their paths, that's pretty much it.

@Aviexo

 

[Sky]

I hate to say this but our safest route today maybe lynching Sky. We lose her vote if she is what she says she is but we dont lose her voice.

Honestly you're probably going to lose my voice too because the win route is Looch and Troop while keeping me alive. It's too close to call between those two

 

[Sky]

Seriously considering just not talking if I'm taken out, given that voting me throws the game

 

[Loochquake]

My question is what benefit does Tree Stump have. Like you dead but can still Game chat. OK it isn't like Tree Stump can say "so and so killed me" or go into dead chat and the other Mafia people spill who their partner is.

Plus, a stump is dead they can't win if town wins after they die right?

The group always wins together. If you die during the game, you can still claim victory for yourself if your side wins. When people say it's a team game, they do mean it. ...well except for the Indie role

Tree Stump can only help by talking, but that can be very helpful especially in late game. Also Tree Stump is confirmed town, so their words are immediately a bit trustworthier.

 

[Fuji Vice]

Seriously considering just not talking if I'm taken out, given that voting me throws the game

We've already outlined how voting for you (or Looch or Troop) does not "throw" the game in the slightest. This just seems like you're protesting too much.

Tbh, if I were the stump, I wouldn't even care if town wanted to lynch me. I'd still get the win if they came through and I'd still be able to post. Acting defeatist is not helping your cause.

 

[Fuji Vice]

One more thing, regardless of who we decide to vote for, we need to wait for Avi to show up so we can make sure she's on the same page as the rest of us.

 

[Wang Chung]

My question is what benefit does Tree Stump have. Like you dead but can still Game chat. OK it isn't like Tree Stump can say "so and so killed me" or go into dead chat and the other Mafia people spill who their partner is.

Plus, a stump is dead they can't win if town wins after they die right?

A stump pretty much becomes a ghost they can talk and help solve the game they just cant vote in the game.

They can still be a voice of reason to help town and they wouldn't be in the dead chat because they are here still in the game.


Now Sky is stating that she may not even talk after becoming the stump can hinder us if she doesnt want to help us solve to get the win.

 

[Wang Chung]

One more thing, regardless of who we decide to vote for, we need to wait for Avi to show up so we can make sure she's on the same page as the rest of us.

This I agree with we cant hastily make a decision without everyone here to discuss the route we need to go.