"Lawyer Fucked Me" A Shawshank Redemption Mafia Game Presented By Barry (Game Thread)

[Fuji Vice]

SK was already investiagtion immune so that's a lot of redundancy

Good point. I can't see another investigation proof, so that should cover Wang.

So, where we're both concerned, it's between Looch and Troop. Let's hear what Ax and Wang have to say.

 

[Fuji Vice]

Obviously our best case scenario is to lynch one and investigate the other. Provided I survive the night, that would resolve our issues.

If we lynch Looch/Troop and they are town, I investigate the other. If they return mafia we're good. If they return town as well, it would obviously have to be Sky. This makes sense.

 

[Wang Chung]

Town to scum.

Me
Fuji
Avi

These 3 can be interchange but would lean one of the VTs are scum and not the stump.
Sky
Looch
Troop

 

[Loochquake]

Perhaps it would be best for all remaining players to give their top suspect lists. I'm not so sure I'm willing to believe the Tree Stump role claim, but on the other hand, it seems more plausible than having 6 Vanilla Town players. Booty and Mochi were both VT, so if we're to believe everyone else still alive then we're left with 3 more. It's much more apt to believe that Sky is telling the truth and one of Looch/Troop/Wang is lying about being VT. If we eliminate Wang, it HAS to be Looch or Troop. So...

I'm not sure I get the reasoning here, that would make Sky more believable than Troop or me, if it comes down to the VT claims. If you're not sure about the Tree Stump claim, then why would you still rather think Sky is VT, than just the other three being what they have claimed before. Why would Sky claim to be Tree Stump instead of just claiming to be VT... that claim didn't came at a point where Sky was in immediate danger of being lynched.

 

[Loochquake]

Obviously our best case scenario is to lynch one and investigate the other. Provided I survive the night, that would resolve our issues.

If we lynch Looch/Troop and they are town, I investigate the other. If they return mafia we're good. If they return town as well, it would obviously have to be Sky. This makes sense.

Well, I'm fine with dying for the cause, but like I said we could also just do it the other way around and go with the person with the weakest case of being Town, which is Sky.

Heck, the way I'm pushing, If Sky flips town, I'm toast tomorrow anyways and the Town W is imminent.

 

[Fuji Vice]

I'm not sure I get the reasoning here, that would make Sky more believable than Troop or me, if it comes down to the VT claims. If you're not sure about the Tree Stump claim, then why would you still rather think Sky is VT, than just the other three being what they have claimed before. Why would Sky claim to be Tree Stump instead of just claiming to be VT... that claim didn't came at a point where Sky was in immediate danger of being lynched.

The reasoning is she claimed the role because it's her actual role. Rather than just making a bullshit VT claim. I know it's flimsy, but I'm at least willing to entertain the idea of it.

I'm also fine with lynching Sky, as it will still give the same scenario as I outlined above. Any one of you, Troop or her can make it work.

 

[Loochquake]

I dunno if it still matters, but obviously my prime suspect stays Sky. I stated I can see the Troop/Poyser altercation being a play, with many people would just brush it off as genuine, when they know Troop. I gave plenty of reasons for suspecting me, but I still think I still have the stronger case out of us three with, even with how weak it generally is.

There are no other suspects, unless there is a GF, but I trust your more experienced players instinct that there probably isn't.

 

[Fuji Vice]

So, with that being said, I'll defer to the majority opinion.

 

[Loochquake]

The reasoning is she claimed the role because it's her actual role. Rather than just making a bullshit VT claim. I know it's flimsy, but I'm at least willing to entertain the idea of it.

I'm also fine with lynching Sky, as it will still give the same scenario as I outlined above. Any one of you, Troop or her can make it work.

I can see what you mean, but Sky is an experienced player with knowledge of roles and the Tree Stump is such a nothing role at the end of day, that it's almost like VT for me... of course, I honestly never heard of the Stump role before, so maybe that's why.


I guess the question is can Avie doctor you a second night in a row, because she said she doctored you last night.

 

[Loochquake]

And I'm pretty sure I never played a game where the Doctor, or at least a similar role, could do that twice in a row with the same player.

 

[Fuji Vice]

And I'm pretty sure I never played a game where the Doctor, or at least a similar role, could do that twice in a row with the same player.

I’m pretty sure she’s saved me two nights in a row already. Even if she hasn’t, it’s a chance we have to be willing to take.

 

[Loochquake]

I’m pretty sure she’s saved me two nights in a row already. Even if she hasn’t, it’s a chance we have to be willing to take.

Avie or the doctor role in general? Because Avie doctored Sky in N2 and you last night, which was N3.

 

[Fuji Vice]

Avie or the doctor role in general? Because Avie doctored Sky in N2 and you last night, which was N3.

I thought it was Sky N1 and me the following 2 nights but I’ll wait for her clarification. Also, regardless of her role specifics, she obviously shouldn’t state exactly what they are, to keep mafia guessing.

Again, it’s likely a chance we’re going to have to take unless we hit mafia on lynch today.

 

[Fuji Vice]

Also, continuing to speculate on the doctor’s abilities isn’t helping us in the slightest so we should probably just shut up about them for now.

 

[Loochquake]

I thought it was Sky N1 and me the following 2 nights but I’ll wait for her clarification. Also, regardless of her role specifics, she obviously shouldn’t state exactly what they are, to keep mafia guessing.

Again, it’s likely a chance we’re going to have to take unless we hit mafia on lynch today.

No, Avie doctored Sky N2... that's also why there was the whole hubbub about the non-kill N2, not *just* the (apparent) commute shot.

Also, continuing to speculate on the doctor’s abilities isn’t helping us in the slightest so we should probably just shut up about them for now.

Agreed.