Prey At Night: The Strangers Mafia Game Thread

[Grim]

Going to save my thoughts for the outcome of the lynch btw as they're mostly null if he flips scum kek

Lol fair enough. Let's see that scum boi swing.

 

[Spitfire]

And have already been talking about it in scum chat

 

[Grim]

pushing for the next lynch, irrespective of the day 1 lynch - suggests one thing and one thing alone as well, so you might have slipped. It suggest you have prior knowledge of who the FK target is going to me.

Huh? No? I just think you're scum.

Why is it impossible for it to be the simplest answer and not some weird conspiracy you keep coming up with?

 

[Spitfire]

I don't see Grim and Sky part of the same scum team though. But Grim and Blaine could make sense too

 

[RDK]

pushing for the next lynch, irrespective of the day 1 lynch - suggests one thing and one thing alone as well, so you might have slipped. It suggest you have prior knowledge of who the FK target is going to me.

I wouldn't use that for fuel

 

[Spitfire]

Huh? No? I just think you're scum.

Why is it impossible for it to be the simplest answer and not some weird conspiracy you keep coming up with?

Because you have no logical reason to scum read me. Just pulling reads out of a hat, is called lucky dip reading

 

[Grim]

Because you have no logical reason to scum read me. Just pulling reads out of a hat, is called lucky dip reading

What do you... think I've been doing asking you questions and querying your logic?

I find your Blaine push to be bad, the fact you had Haza as a scum lean off one single post, then immediately backed off from it when given some irrelevant thing? You scum leaned on Haza because he said... hello? And wasn't active? Not to mention, "Ekko is invested, he must be town", as if he is incapable of doing so as scum?

Not to mention, Poyser's weird early Town read on something that was pretty NAI, and yeah, I've got plenty or reason to scum lean you and want you pressured next.

You have this weird misconception that all I have is feelings and spur of the moment grab-bag pressures when I am actually looking at people's posts and questioning things I find questionable.

 

[Ekkologix]

This is presumptuous and close minded on everyone else’s ability to see balance.

If dude would have claimed something it could have been discussed and then alternative options could have been discussed were it a believable and helpful role that was claimed. Then you’d have had more support for your Blaine push potentially.

So in fact I don’t see why you weren’t advocating an Ekko claim as well because it could have taken him off the table to make room for the other option you were pushing.

r u saying scums cant fake claim or i am not claiming because i am scum and dont have a claim

 

[Spitfire]

What do you... think I've been doing asking you questions and querying your logic?

I find your Blaine push to be bad, the fact you had Haza as a scum lean off one single post, then immediately backed off from it when given some irrelevant thing? You scum leaned on Haza because he said... hello? And wasn't active? Not to mention, "Ekko is invested, he must be town", as if he is incapable of doing so as scum?

Not to mention, Poyser's weird early Town read on something that was pretty NAI, and yeah, I've got plenty or reason to scum lean you and want you pressured next.

You have this weird misconception that all I have is feelings and spur of the moment grab-bag pressures when I am actually looking at people's posts and questioning things I find questionable.

A predetermined PoE, before the Day 1 flip is suspect. You're either scum telling or bad town. Updating your views and changing your mind is how you win games as town. Ekko was my biggest scum read at one point. Haza also is no longer being scum read. Living in the past, when it only been one day is lazy play.

 

[Sky]

pushing for the next lynch, irrespective of the day 1 lynch - suggests one thing and one thing alone as well, so you might have slipped. It suggest you have prior knowledge of who the FK target is going to me.

How does this even follow??

 

[Grim]

Like I don't care that you defend Ekko. What I don't like is that you're defending him off his investment level when the dude outright said he fights and is active regardless whether he's scum or town.

Am I probably being hypocritical with it because I might have done the same with Wang or Blaine? Probably. But the difference is that I vibe better with Blaine and Wang more than I do your defenses of Ekko.

 

[Ekkologix]

Because not claiming when you're L1 is bad form and deserves to be punished. If you let one person get away with everyone will think they can

so u will claim at L-1 even when the case on u is utter dogshit and u think u shudnt be L-1 if the players were analyzing posts enough?

 

[Grim]

A predetermined PoE, before the Day 1 flip is suspect. You're either scum telling or bad town. Updating your views and changing your mind is how you win games as town. Ekko was my biggest scum read at one point. Haza also is no longer being scum read. Living in the past, when it only been one day is lazy play.

Except, as you so aptly put it, the past should still be taken into consideration. Your thoughts now don't suddenly erase your past thoughts. If your past thoughts stink enough, they're gonna color your current posts.

 

[Ekkologix]

should Ekko have claimed at L-1. Probably. But I doubt it was a critical role to town, otherwise I'd be mega annoyed with him.

its not an important role, it's neiche but can potentially publicly find scum, specially if im night killed

 

[Spitfire]

Like I don't care that you defend Ekko. What I don't like is that you're defending him off his investment level when the dude outright said he fights and is active regardless whether he's scum or town.

Am I probably being hypocritical with it because I might have done the same with Wang or Blaine? Probably. But the difference is that I vibe better with Blaine and Wang more than I do your defenses of Ekko.

Im defending Ekko based on him town telling and getting me to change my mind of him, when he was my biggest scum read.

Vibes? This word doesn't mean anything.