"Glory, Hallelujah" | Barry Presents - The American Civil War - Mafia GAME THREAD

[Comrade Khan]

This is what scum lethal does lol

I can pull receipts

But cop claim is ugh

oh you dont need to convince me pal lol

 

[Comrade Khan]

@RDK what are your thought on abi and really whoever else you didnt mention in your quick read list post?

 

[Ekkologix]

This is what scum lethal does lol

I can pull receipts

But cop claim is ugh

well they used a super powerful fake claim if lethal is a scum with a cop fake. i think we r okay here

 

[Ace Marvel]

i have to ask why yo uare wasting so much time on semantical arguments

is what I do. :/

 

[Oneiros]

if we flip tweet as scum right here and now who wud u gun for next?

My top scum reads are Smark, McNightstalker and Tweet, in this order. So if Tweet flips scum I'd have to rethink Smark as I don't think they are aligned. McNightstalker I was fairly confident on, but like I said in my last post I don't get those scum reads from a scum perspective. So outside of those I'd have to check Baldrick/ Captain Holt/T-Pein. Baldrick I have actually already checked last night before deciding to vote Tweet and he just confuses me.

 

[Ace Marvel]

I order Chinese food, so the logical next step is to play this on loop.

 

[Ekkologix]

Vote Count:

Baldrick (2) - Jeff, SA
Mandalorian (1) - Tommy
Tweet (10) - CP, Smark, Man, Lethal, Ekko, T-Pein, Poyser, Baldrick, Oneiros, Ace Marvel

we still have SA not voting with majority by EoD. this is a factual scummy behavior here

the counter argument is why was he posting in EoD if he is scummate with tweet lol

 

[Ace Marvel]

glgl

 

[Ekkologix]

I order Chinese food, so the logic next step is to play this on loop.

general tso?

 

[Tweet]

to be fair there r way too many things tweet did not comment on, including lethal's comments, but its a good observation

I haven't read the last 100 pages or so so it's only natural I haven't commented on anything recent

 

[Sister Abigail]

can there be a world where both ace and abigail r town or r we of the opinion that if one is town the other is scum

I think we can both be Town. I am kind of leaning that way, but I'm afraid Marvel could be a tricky Wolf.

 

[Ricky Smarks]

I think we can both be Town. I am kind of leaning that way, but I'm afraid Marvel could be a tricky Wolf.

What do you mean exactly when you say tricky wolf?

 

[Comrade Khan]

Notwithstanding, if he is killed him revealing his target of whatever he’s done really doesn’t help us that match unless it’s clear from elsewhere what actual impact it might have had. If he’s a roleblocker and the kill doesn’t go through, yeah, I’ll concede there’s something to work with there, but usually I wouldn’t imagine there to be much upside to town from a claim during night.

yeah and I'd add that with abi's standing in thread, scum would be foolish to shoot them currently. the only towny motivation I could see is them lying to draw the kill but that doesnt seem likely by how they have answered why they did it

 

[Sister Abigail]

You’re now saying that you’re not a power role which means that someone else is. Giving mafia information like that during night isn’t helpful to town.

We might have a different definition of PRs.

Are you scum reading me because I said who i targeted? If not, then let's not go in circles here because I can assure you there is a perfect reason as to why I did what I did.

 

[Ekkologix]

My top scum reads are Smark, McNightstalker and Tweet, in this order. So if Tweet flips scum I'd have to rethink Smark as I don't think they are aligned. McNightstalker I was fairly confident on, but like I said in my last post I don't get those scum reads from a scum perspective. So outside of those I'd have to check Baldrick/ Captain Holt/T-Pein. Baldrick I have actually already checked last night before deciding to vote Tweet and he just confuses me.

tweet - concensus read
mcnight - low hanging fruit. have u read their recent interactions with me/ace/abi? thoughts on those?
smark - probably an indie. i can help u explore this but not b4 we flip like 2 mafia atleast

baldrick/holt both have somewhat self destructive playstyle that makes them look scummy. are u able to tell if what they r saying cannot come from town balrick/holt?

what about tpein makes u wanna check them instead of the other inactives?

i am really not impressed by this list btw. looks like fake reads. do u think all the top posters r town?