Throwback Music Mafia [Game Thread]

[Barry Poppins]

Silly goose Barry thinking that's real

Fuck off.

 

[Marty McFourth]

1. Odo
2. Doddsy
3. Chloe B
4. Kajuh
5. Chevy
6. T-Pein
7. Lethal
8. Tweet
9. Ace
10. PHEN0M
11. The Fourth Wall
12. Curry
13. Rugrat
14. Blaine
15. CP
16. Barry
17. Alco

If I die, you guys should follow these reads

Can you do a proper version of this. If you flip, it would be good to look back on.

 

[Evans]

feels like an awfully angry reaction for someone who’s winning a duel

 

[Barry Poppins]

feels like an awfully angry reaction for someone who’s winning a duel

Yeah, I'm angry, because you decided to stupidly duel me and cause me to out my role. You ruined the game for me on Day 1.

 

[Evans]

Can you do a proper version of this. If you flip, it would be good to look back on.

Yeah I’ll follow up with an actual detailed reads list in a short while

 

[Evans]

Yeah, I'm angry, because you decided to stupidly duel me and cause me to out my role. You ruined the game for me on Day 1.

 

[Marty McFourth]

What has been up with my play around Blaine? Nobody has given a reason as to why it was poor play, let alone scummy

Well, you keep defaulting to the town motivation for it. I feel like if you know Blaine has easy buttons to press, you can find out if he's got a role with relative ease, like what happened. Which would obviously be beneficial info for a scum team, as well.

Literally the only thing giving me pause on my read of you is you saying the vote was deliberate when Curry gave you an easy out with the vote being within the same minute as Flay. I feel like that would have been an easy out. Nothing else about your play on a read back seems overly town.

 

[Marty McFourth]

I guess we are pretty stalled now until Poyser logs on. I'm not sure if Smark is just doing vote counts and doesn't have roles.

I'll be back, I'm going to go over some of my reads again in the meantime. I've got a notebook at hand this game to keep track, that's a first lol

Still need to hear from Ace, either he is busy or stalling out time.

 

[Curry]

I didn’t like the wagon, I just new he’d be easily rattled with a few votes so we could get a read.

the only thing you can claim to be a lie is my motivation which is unverifiable.

if you think I’m lying and now bricking it under the pressure (of zero votes) why aren’t you voting me?

@The Fourth Wall take it for what you will but after I asked that then decided it didn't matter (10/10 questioning btw) I saw this ~50 posts earlier than me "giving him" the easy out and the first line seems to suggest he knew about the previous vote.

 

[Odo]

Trouble is, Barry outed himself immediately for no real reason. Should have made the best of it and let things play out. We’re going to learn absolutely nothing from this duel

 

[Evans]

Trouble is, Barry outed himself immediately for no real reason. Should have made the best of it and let things play out. We’re going to learn absolutely nothing from this duel

The immediate Barry claim made me more confident in my read

 

[Marty McFourth]

Trouble is, Barry outed himself immediately for no real reason. Should have made the best of it and let things play out. We’re going to learn absolutely nothing from this duel

I mean, they've both posted a fair bit. Especially Chevy. At least they have post history to comb through. Plus, perhaps we'll hear from Ace too. Then night flips maybe.

We're going to learn more about this day phase than we would have originally, although I'm not fond of the duel being used so early.

 

[Marty McFourth]

The immediate Barry claim made me more confident in my read

Why?

If it's a fake claim, he came up with it pretty quick. If it's his real role, it doesn't tell us a lot as it can be either alignment.

I probably would claim immediately as well if someone pitted me in a duel with them, just because I expect most players not to fake it.

 

[Tweet]

 

[Curry]

Too general a role to fake blindly. If he's scum he'll be watcher/rolewatcher.