Barry Presents: Whodunnit 2: The West Smithton Sagas GAME THREAD

[RDK]

Is Poyser going after weaker players posts actually a meta-based reason to suspect him?

If he doesn't like Mitch's entrance it shouldn't matter how good Mitch is especially if town Poyser thinks he has a good chance of catching him.

 

[RDK]

Just saying, if Poyser is town, both Banez and Haza look bad, but if he is indeed scum, the scum team has absolutely done a Jeff already

 

[Odo]

Huh

why ask if you’ve Already decided it doesn’t mean anything??

cause the way other players react will help me

 

[Odo]

Why don’t you like haza?

not gonna answer for the lad, but I would ask you your opinion on Haza pls

 

[Poyser]

His post about this case not being a good meta reason to wagon me I think is pretty sharp, but I’m a bit paranoid he’s just trying to get himself on the right side of history here ngl
Though I think not joining my wagon which would be easy to do at this point because he doesn’t trust people on it looks fairly towny overall. Not sure he’s really astute enough to fake it as scum

 

[Poyser]

@NotBrutus now u

 

[Tweet]

Is Poyser going after weaker players posts actually a meta-based reason to suspect him?

If he doesn't like Mitch's entrance it shouldn't matter how good Mitch is especially if town Poyser thinks he has a good chance of catching him.

If he'd do it in a convincing way it'd actually be a reason to read him town, but his play around Mitch looks like fake hunting to me. Starting a wagon on Mitch after one post is inoffensive in itself.

Nah Mitch id probably expect him to try and keep out of it a bit tbh. I’ve never seen him play as mafia so ? Can’t have been scum much and first instinct is to not really want to be on a mislynch wagon. It’s a trap that OMB regularly falls into

Then here he acknowledges that he doesn't have enough grasp of Mitchs meta to reliably interpret his entrance one way or the other but keeps pretending he has a point regardless.

And now he's trying to find more reasons to uphold his suspicions by looking at meta from the past *2* games, which if you know anything about sample size is just a joke.

 

[RDK]

His post about this case not being a good meta reason to wagon me I think is pretty sharp, but I’m a bit paranoid he’s just trying to get himself on the right side of history here ngl
Though I think not joining my wagon which would be easy to do at this point because he doesn’t trust people on it looks fairly towny overall. Not sure he’s really astute enough to fake it as scum

The last sentence doesn't really make sense to me

 

[RDK]

^I should say the second last sentence

 

[Tweet]

@NotBrutus now u

Oh look another diversion attempt

 

[Poyser]

Oh look another diversion attempt

This doesn’t make any sense, I literally already asked him why he doesn’t like haza

 

[Poyser]

^I should say the second last sentence

I’m saying I think staying off my wagon because you don’t trust the people on it looks towny. As in the thought process behind it is the kinda stuff you’d be thinking as town and I don’t think you’re a good enough scum player to fake that.

 

[RDK]

This doesn’t make any sense, I literally already asked him why he doesn’t like haza

I think you're confusing Brutus and Mitch bruh

 

[RDK]

I’m saying I think staying off my wagon because you don’t trust the people on it looks towny. As in the thought process behind it is the kinda stuff you’d be thinking as town and I don’t think you’re a good enough scum player to fake that.

I don't think i'm great but i'm easily good enough to fake that.

 

[Sky]

I’m saying I think staying off my wagon because you don’t trust the people on it looks towny. As in the thought process behind it is the kinda stuff you’d be thinking as town and I don’t think you’re a good enough scum player to fake that.

But does he think in a towny manner as town? A lot of people don't.

Also you're on 6, claim