Ys Origin Mafia - Game Thread

[Comrade Khan]

not sure! its not an absolute that lethal and HOL both be scum together, but my POE is getting pretty fucking small.

 

[Smart Marx]

not sure! its not an absolute that lethal and HOL both be scum together, but my POE is getting pretty fucking small.

I'm just curious as to the difference between duelist and vig is to you that DV and duelist can't be connected (I agree now) but DV and vig can?

 

[Comrade Khan]

should we consider the possibility that scum could lift the curse for the petrify? it would make more sense on why they'd use it on one of their own if we are to believe magic was scum.

My current theory is that he is unpetrified once the petrifier died (since no one has claimed healer and i think they would have by now?)

Now, that still doesn't clear magic, because I can see the play of freezing their own teamate, and him unfreezing later when they lose the petrifier and he looks great to cruise to victory.

 

[Comrade Khan]

I'm just curious as to the difference between duelist and vig is to you that DV and duelist can't be connected (I agree now) but DV and vig can?

the main reason for me is that DV and duelist are both day roles so they just seem way too op together, considering that they could do that after the potential skip.

Vig and DV could coexist on a scum team, obviously the vig would be a fake in this case. if it is a fake, id even push the theory that Lethal is the petrifier.

 

[Comrade Khan]

As a side note @Tearjerker , how certain are you on barry after d1?

 

[Comrade Khan]

Fwiw, all theories aside, I still think it's much likelier CP is scum than Lethal atm.

 

[Smart Marx]

the main reason for me is that DV and duelist are both day roles so they just seem way too op together, considering that they could do that after the potential skip.

Vig and DV could coexist on a scum team, obviously the vig would be a fake in this case. if it is a fake, id even push the theory that Lethal is the petrifier.

Fair. I didn't consider both being dayroles. If Lethal is scum, I do think he faked his vig claim.

He could be the petrifier, actually.

 

[Hohenheim of Light]

Big Man - x-shot gunsmith, N2 copped smark
Jeffatron - mason, princess
Tearjerker#2 - vanilla (copped by big man for no gun)
Grim - vanilla (copped by rugrat)
Laughable Chimp - some protective role
Alco - vanilla
Darth Lethal - 2-shot vig, shot banez and CP, both failed
TheRedPrince - duelist
Showtime - petrified
Skybox - mason, princess
Hohenheim of Light - double voter
Rugrat - vanilla cop, copped banez and grim vanilla
MyPrerogative - x-shot watcher, N1 watched jeff no result

Is this right? And only chimp hasn't fully claimed but we know he's not the unpetrifier?

 

[Grimoire Lenin]

I think Rugrat might be the fake tbh.

It's a ridiculously specialized role and I find it absolutely hard to believe that any scum would have been given vanilla townie as a fake if this were the case.

 

[Lethal]

ok well I'm x-shot gunsmith. didn't use it N1 as I didn't want to waste one of my shots having only read a portion of the thread. used it on Juice last night and got back my target doesn't have a gun.

So after a full read through you decide on the bloke with 2 posts? Brilliant.

Does no gun work for godfather? If not, Smark is cleared.

I went to bed right after seeing Day posted and submitted my role, and I only woke up like 3 hours ago. don't think I was on discord in my sleep so not sure what you're on about.

You've just contradicted yourself here. Didn't use it N1 because of skimming, but saw day posted and put the role in right away? Huh????

the main reason for me is that DV and duelist are both day roles so they just seem way too op together, considering that they could do that after the potential skip.

Vig and DV could coexist on a scum team, obviously the vig would be a fake in this case. if it is a fake, id even push the theory that Lethal is the petrifier.

Here we go. I do love how I come up in these situations. think though, would I be good enough to pull this and not crumble? I would typically crumble right about now.

I'm also pointing back to CP's edited post. He claims to have mentioned character which gave him the pass earlier on, but nobody saw it, Tweet knows about it, and nothing happened.

As a side note @Tearjerker , how certain are you on barry after d1?

iirc Rugrat cleared him

 

[Grimoire Lenin]

In fact, I think Rugrat may actually be the petrifier.

 

[Lethal]

I think Rugrat might be the fake tbh.

It's a ridiculously specialized role and I find it absolutely hard to believe that any scum would have been given vanilla townie as a fake if this were the case.

How did Rugrat know Banez was telling the truth?

 

[Comrade Khan]

I think Rugrat might be the fake tbh.

It's a ridiculously specialized role and I find it absolutely hard to believe that any scum would have been given vanilla townie as a fake if this were the case.

I will fully admit that the role sticks out compared to all the others, no denying that.

But...there's more than ONE fake out there

 

[Grimoire Lenin]

How did Rugrat know Banez was telling the truth?

Because Rugrat would be scum and Banez would be town.

 

[Comrade Khan]

How did Rugrat know Banez was telling the truth?

I mean I can answer that easily. If he's scum, he would know banez is town and had no reason to be lying about being vt