Ys Origin Mafia - Game Thread

[Comrade Khan]

Has MP said anything about being x-shot, btw?

If there's no full cop, then having both GS and VC doesn't seem out of the ordinary.

he claimed 2 shot

 

[Alco]

Okay, seems to be in line with what the rest has then.

 

[Big Man]

VT cop is a pretty limited role tbh in terms of you can only use it on people who've claimed VT to catch them out.

 

[Comrade Khan]

VT cop is a pretty limited role tbh in terms of you can only use it on people who've claimed VT to catch them out.

i agree that it's not an overly powerful role, yours is by far the stronger of the two

 

[Big Man]

Big Man doing the lord's work.

Any chance you saw my post to you about Hol? With the discussion he can't be scum with CP I'd like your input?

not yet. I only really skimmed since I saw we were mass claiming.

 

[Big Man]

I agree with this section.

btw I think you misunderstood this list. it's a list of who isn't aligned knowingly as scum but they could be aligned as town

 

[Comrade Khan]

the way I see it atm...

I doubt town has a duelist and a vig with the low amount of kills scum seem to have at their disposal. One of them is probably scum.

I doubt scum have a DV and duelist because of my role, one of them is town.

Does that make sense so far?

 

[Ricky Smarks]

btw I think you misunderstood this list. it's a list of who isn't aligned knowingly as scum but they could be aligned as town

Thanks for the clarification. I def think CP is scum and the others are town.

Or at least I did. Odo the Chimp I might be null on now.

 

[Ricky Smarks]

the way I see it atm...

I doubt town has a duelist and a vig with the low amount of kills scum seem to have at their disposal. One of them is probably scum.

I doubt scum have a DV and duelist because of my role, one of them is town.

Does that make sense so far?

That's where my logic is at rn. I always thought the top part, with your new info I believe the second part now.

 

[Comrade Khan]

By that logic, I can almost guarantee CP or Lethal are scum, and if Lethal is scum, I can see HOL being scum as well. If Cp is scum , HOL is town.

please correct me if thats batshit crazy

 

[Ricky Smarks]

By that logic, I can almost guarantee CP or Lethal are scum, and if Lethal is scum, I can see HOL being scum as well. If Cp is scum , HOL is town.

please correct me if thats batshit crazy

You think Hol and Lethal could be scum? I'm not sure I follow.

 

[Comrade Khan]

Also see it as an impossibility that Lethal/CP are scum aligned, because that would be some OP fucking fakes right there with no way of counter claiming them

 

[Ricky Smarks]

Have Hol and Lethal interacted much?

 

[Ricky Smarks]

Also see it as an impossibility that Lethal/CP are scum aligned, because that would be some OP fucking fakes right there with no way of counter claiming them

I agree with this. Vig and Duelist aren't both scum unless Lethal lied.

Why can the vig and DV be scum, though?

 

[Big Man]

should we consider the possibility that scum could lift the curse for the petrify? it would make more sense on why they'd use it on one of their own if we are to believe magic was scum.