Ys Origin Mafia - Game Thread

[Smart Marx]

He literally couldn’t win with town if Jeff/sky die assuming that’s true, as the moment the scum leader is dead, he then becomes a killer

We don’t know that for a fact, but the list of possibilities is very short

ok fair enough.

 

[Odo]

I literally don’t have any other possibilities other than some hokey theme specific crap

 

[Smart Marx]

If he did become a serial killer with a kill that’s worth noting for later.

 

[Lethal]

for some reason I got you confused with Alco as I wanted him to contribute, but thanks for your reads.

I think this is a fair set of reads. Many people have noticed that Smark is more active as town, how does this fly with your scum lean on him?

For reasons I outlined in response to his query

 

[Comrade Khan]

@Odo why do you think Barry is town btw? I've heard why from Smark but I have my own reservations.

 

[Rugrat]

Either way, in general people are way too eager to kill someone scum don’t need around either.

Not really. He was the likely direction and it was good chance of a no lynch otherwise.

I don’t subscribe to auto-lynch survivors, but I’d much rather lynch a player who isn’t town and MAY be scum than get no flip.

 

[Smart Marx]

Not really. He was the likely direction and it was good chance of a no lynch otherwise.

I don’t subscribe to auto-lynch survivors, but I’d much rather lynch a player who isn’t town and MAY be scum than get no flip.

With how many people I’m feeling good about town, I’d have rather just tested an inactive.

That said, if he actually would have become a serial killer, I’m fine with the lynch.

 

[Rugrat]

With how many people I’m feeling good about town, I’d have rather just tested an inactive.

That said, if he actually would have become a serial killer, I’m fine with the lynch.

Inactives don't get lynched on D1. It's too early to whack them when they may contribute later and, in addition there will be various people with stronger reads who will be displeased about their scum leans/reads being put on the backburner for a stab in the dark.

 

[Odo]

Lynching an inactive day 1 is an extremely desperate play that isn’t really worth considering outside of real exceptional circumstances cause it’s gonna be real hard to force it through on scum, and if it’s town, it tells us precisely nothing.

Lynching a confessed non town who may be lying (as Haza was) is far better

 

[Odo]

So big mans only post so far was don’t replace me

Did Phenom add anything to his initial interest here’?

 

[Odo]

@Odo why do you think Barry is town btw? I've heard why from Smark but I have my own reservations.

Vibe, and I think smarks read of him carries some weight, regardless of smarks own alignment

 

[Comrade Khan]

So big mans only post so far was don’t replace me

Did Phenom add anything to his initial interest here’?

yes and no, respectively

 

[Odo]

Vig plz

 

[Rugrat]

Vig plz do not piss shots away on unclaimed roles

 

[Banez]

1. Tearjerker
2. Big Man
3. Jeffatron
4. Juice
5. Char Aznable
6. PHEN0M
7. Odo
8. Alco
9. Darth Lethal
10. TheRedPrince
11. Banez
12. Showtime
13. Sexpun T'Come
14. Raidokken
15. Hohenheim of Light
16. Rugrat
17. MyPrerogative

I think I'm around here rn. I'm not usually a strong day 1 guy tho like Rugrat said.

So why are you giving Barry the solid blue at that stage?

And i'm your only scum lean? Okay then, good read.

1. Tearjerker
2. Big Man
3. Jeffatron
4. Juice
5. Char Aznable
6. PHEN0M
7. Odo
8. Alco
9. Darth Lethal
10. TheRedPrince
11. Banez
12. Showtime
13. Sexpun T'Come
15. Hohenheim of Light
16. Rugrat
17. MyPrerogative

Degrees of the blue and yellow/orange indicate my levels of lean. I'm null on the rest. Scum could be in there.

This is interesting. You move Jeff into solid blue, which i fine. I like Jeff.

CP with his few posts is scummy to you?

I'm scummy because i play weird? Okay?

Rugrat is scummy because?

And you give ALCO of all people scumread? Why are all your scum leans either people who are inactive or people who have habit of fucking around in the game like me and Rugrat?

And why doesn't PHENOM get same treatment as Alco?

And how do you not have opinion of Magic yet? Or Hohenheim of Light a.k.a Goku was it? Or is he Doddsy, i still can't tell which one.