Ys Origin Mafia - Game Thread

[Odo]

@Odo I'd like a list from you as well when you got time. Same goes for @PHEN0M, @Big Man and @Showtime

Loosely, you can put Barry, you and sky in the town column for various reasons, and then I’d list the inactives + CP + Banez + MP + Juice as folk I’m not too enthusiastic about. I don’t really have a preferred direction for day 2 beyond making these guys play more, then we’ll see where we are at

 

[Lethal]

can you post a read list plz

Why? It's not like it's worth a pinch of shit to anyone.

But, for shits and giggles

Town - Jeff, Barry, you, Hohenheim of Light
Scum lean ~ Banez, Smark, MP

Everyone else is null, although Odo putting off that aura of town. I'm not even engaging in reading Scumbox because it's an avenue I don't care to explore right now.

elaborate

Considering I have you as town this should be good.

Elaborate on how I’m leading down a dangerous line?

The updating of Magic from seemingly nothing, making a 'doesn't sit well' read from CP claiming duellist is odd, and then engaging in setup spec which has no positives towards scum hunting at all. Trying to link them together using activity as a gauge defeats the very purpose of what Smark hates when people question him on it being his meta.

I also dislike his attitude towards me, just every post seems to have some element of harshness towards it. I'll gladly engage in discussion with you though Jeff.

 

[Smart Marx]

Why? It's not like it's worth a pinch of shit to anyone.

But, for shits and giggles

Town - Jeff, Barry, you, Hohenheim of Light
Scum lean ~ Banez, Smark, MP

Everyone else is null, although Odo putting off that aura of town. I'm not even engaging in reading Scumbox because it's an avenue I don't care to explore right now.




The updating of Magic from seemingly nothing, making a 'doesn't sit well' read from CP claiming duellist is odd, and then engaging in setup spec which has no positives towards scum hunting at all. Trying to link them together using activity as a gauge defeats the very purpose of what Smark hates when people question him on it being his meta.

I also dislike his attitude towards me, just every post seems to have some element of harshness towards it. I'll gladly engage in discussion with you though Jeff.

I have zero issues with you, my dude. You're the one who's not stopped making derogatory remarks about me and my attitude.

I just want to play a game. You seem to be harboring latent issues with Barry and transferring them to me.

As for the Magic read, why can't I change my mind on hon 5 seconds after I post my list after I thought it about it for another second?

Since when is setup spec not a good thing if it can help track down the right scum or prevent someone lynching the wrong person?

Since when do I hate people using my meta. I bring it up more than anyone?! What are talking about?

 

[Lethal]

Most likely still thinks I’m scum because of the argument yesterday.

 

[Smart Marx]

Both since you scum read me immediately after our argument and you only have to look at my many posts to see I'm clearly town.

 

[Lethal]

I have zero issues with you, my dude. You're the one who's not stopped making derogatory remarks about me and my attitude.

I just want to play a game. You seem to be harboring latent issues with Barry and transferring them to me.

As for the Magic read, why can't I change my mind on hon 5 seconds after I post my list after I thought it about it for another second?

Since when is setup spec not a good thing if it can help track down the right scum or prevent someone lynching the wrong person?

Since when do I hate people using my meta. I bring it up more than anyone?! What are talking about?

After last night, I really do struggle to believe that, but whatever, water under the bridge.

We want the same thing. I'm not calling back to it again re: Barry and the nonsense from last night.

You're normally more careful with your lists. Gut feeling.

I'd rather hunt on play and setup spec is a distraction.

You argue with it all the time when people try and say it's your meta and activity is your tell.

You even mention your 'many posts' as a reason to read you town. You caught Haza? He exposed himself.

 

[Smart Marx]

After last night, I really do struggle to believe that, but whatever, water under the bridge.

We want the same thing. I'm not calling back to it again re: Barry and the nonsense from last night.

You're normally more careful with your lists. Gut feeling.

I'd rather hunt on play and setup spec is a distraction.

You argue with it all the time when people try and say it's your meta and activity is your tell.

You even mention your 'many posts' as a reason to read you town. You caught Haza? He exposed himself.

I was only trying to diffuse a situation based on a misunderstanding. Sounds good. Water under the bridge.

I am. That said, as scum I'd be more careful. I gave like a gazillion town reads. I put myself in a bad spot to lynch a lot of people.

You can hunt on play and that's fine. I think any tool that helps me find scum is a good thing. That's how I play.

No, I really don't. I consistently mention it. Like I'm telling you right now you're cray if you think I'm the top poster and scum.

My problem is when some1 shades me when I'm sleeping and uses that to say I'm scum.

I never said I caught Haza. I think his lynch was a fuckin' mistake. Lynching him helped scum get closer to winning.

 

[Odo]

I don’t really have a convincing reason to think lethal is town yet, come to think of it. He’s posted a lot but a lot of it is just confrontation with Barry / Smark

Does somebody want to tell me why I’m wrong?

 

[Comrade Khan]

I was only trying to diffuse a situation based on a misunderstanding. Sounds good. Water under the bridge.

I am. That said, as scum I'd be more careful. I gave like a gazillion town reads. I put myself in a bad spot to lynch a lot of people.

You can hunt on play and that's fine. I think any tool that helps me find scum is a good thing. That's how I play.

No, I really don't. I consistently mention it. Like I'm telling you right now you're cray if you think I'm the top poster and scum.

My problem is when some1 shades me when I'm sleeping and uses that to say I'm scum.

I never said I caught Haza. I think his lynch was a fuckin' mistake. Lynching him helped scum get closer to winning.

perhaps. but thats not 100% considering his flip also mentioned something if the leader of scum team died, which he conveniently failed to mention. I dont think its a mistake personally, still better than a no lynch imo

 

[Odo]

... that said, maybe if he were scum, he’d know for certain I’m town, so not listing me among his primary town reads given my activity and effort wouldn’t be what I’d expect ...

Yeah cancel the above

 

[Odo]

I’m assuming he’d become a serial killer under those conditions. Him being dead is a net positive, case closed

 

[Comrade Khan]

I’m assuming he’d become a serial killer under those conditions. Him being dead is a net positive, case closed

Good to see we were both thinking the same way regarding that.

 

[Rugrat]

Why? It's not like it's worth a pinch of shit to anyone.

But, for shits and giggles

Town - Jeff, Barry, you, Hohenheim of Light
Scum lean ~ Banez, Smark, MP

Everyone else is null, although Odo putting off that aura of town. I'm not even engaging in reading Scumbox because it's an avenue I don't care to explore right now.




The updating of Magic from seemingly nothing, making a 'doesn't sit well' read from CP claiming duellist is odd, and then engaging in setup spec which has no positives towards scum hunting at all. Trying to link them together using activity as a gauge defeats the very purpose of what Smark hates when people question him on it being his meta.

I also dislike his attitude towards me, just every post seems to have some element of harshness towards it. I'll gladly engage in discussion with you though Jeff.

for some reason I got you confused with Alco as I wanted him to contribute, but thanks for your reads.

I think this is a fair set of reads. Many people have noticed that Smark is more active as town, how does this fly with your scum lean on him?

 

[Odo]

He literally couldn’t win with town if Jeff/sky die assuming that’s true, as the moment the scum leader is dead, he then becomes a killer

We don’t know that for a fact, but the list of possibilities is very short

 

[Smart Marx]

Did his actually say he became a serial killer or assumption?

Either way, in general people are way too eager to kill someone scum don’t need around either.