WS Christmas Mafia 2021

[CakeWalker]

600 pages and 9000 posts

 

[CakeWalker]

relaxing game

 

[Dr_Professor83]

I also do want to know the split but i feel bad lynching doink for it on the off chance he town and gonna keep giving us good roles. his resistance to lynch is the one thing that looks a bit bad. as town i kind of expected a bit more "if u lynch me, do this this then this when i flip town" and i havent seen that. tough call, once again

We’ve got good numbers. I’d rather hit others in the POE first and see if he gets something good that can help us.

 

[Jobber Doink]

If people want to waste time lynching me - then just speed lynch me

But its alright wasting a lynch on me? Based on "his role seems not town"

I also do want to know the split but i feel bad lynching doink for it on the off chance he town and gonna keep giving us good roles. his resistance to lynch is the one thing that looks a bit bad. as town i kind of expected a bit more "if u lynch me, do this this then this when i flip town" and i havent seen that. tough call, once again

Its bad to explain the reasoning why lynching me is a bad idea? Like how is that bad exactly

"Here is how I am town, if this doesn't work then I can't prove anything"

That's a bad thing to do? Like seriously this is just a lazy way to look at it lol. Town shouldn't roll over to get lynched, they should explain why its a bad idea to lynch them to hopefully help narrow down the list instead of just throwing darts at the board and see what sticks.

 

[Comrade Khan]

We’ve got good numbers. I’d rather hit others in the POE first and see if he gets something good that can help us.

if thats the case then ya id lynch juice , at worse alco i guess

 

[CakeWalker]

Or Doink is SK with these random role each day, and we just allow him to carry on killing us off, whilst doing PoE on everyone else.

 

[CakeWalker]

But its alright wasting a lynch on me? Based on "his role seems not town"

I am prepared to die for the benefit of town, are you?

Its bad to explain the reasoning why lynching me is a bad idea? Like how is that bad exactly

"Here is how I am town, if this doesn't work then I can't prove anything"

That's a bad thing to do? Like seriously this is just a lazy way to look at it lol. Town shouldn't roll over to get lynched, they should explain why its a bad idea to lynch them to hopefully help narrow down the list instead of just throwing darts at the board and see what sticks.

 

[Chris]

I think I'd leave doink at this point. I don't get the point of confirming the split unless you think there is 4 indy potential?

 

[Comrade Khan]

But its alright wasting a lynch on me? Based on "his role seems not town"



Its bad to explain the reasoning why lynching me is a bad idea? Like how is that bad exactly

"Here is how I am town, if this doesn't work then I can't prove anything"

That's a bad thing to do? Like seriously this is just a lazy way to look at it lol. Town shouldn't roll over to get lynched, they should explain why its a bad idea to lynch them to hopefully help narrow down the list instead of just throwing darts at the board and see what sticks.

its not bad, and its not lazy. im trying to put myself in your shoes as either alignment and trying to gauge your reaction to being lynched for the greater good/the split. its not throwing darts either as ur in poe for indy, it just is what it is. so yes, gauging ur reaction on how badly u want to survive is a fine way to read u partially. i never said it was the only metric to read u either, im debating value as well. again, ur insistence on reacting strongly here is, in fact, not a great look imo

 

[Dr_Professor83]

Or Doink is SK with these random role each day, and we just allow him to carry on killing us off, whilst doing PoE on everyone else.

You will not answer me on the T-Pein thing. Also your argument makes no sense when we have one person left to find and have numbers to spare.

 

[Comrade Khan]

I think I'd leave doink at this point. I don't get the point of confirming the split unless you think there is 4 indy potential?

well the 4th thing is dumb. lets change the wording then.

we need to clear poe and he's in it

 

[Jobber Doink]

its not bad, and its not lazy. im trying to put myself in your shoes as either alignment and trying to gauge your reaction to being lynched for the greater good/the split. its not throwing darts either as ur in poe for indy, it just is what it is. so yes, gauging ur reaction on how badly u want to survive is a fine way to read u partially. i never said it was the only metric to read u either, im debating value as well. again, ur insistence on reacting strongly here is, in fact, not a great look imo

Lol, you want me to read the game and respond to things, then I give the responses and since its not

"Please yes kill me so you can lazy your way outta this instead of thinking about it"

Is bad? Right.....

Its not about surviving its about trying to narrow the actual list of people to lynch to give us better odds to win. You can just start rando lynching but that tends to end up bad usually because you aren't actually trying to figure things out instead its just leeroy jenkins this shit.

 

[CakeWalker]

All it takes is a few MLs and we lose.

Indie 2 = Jeff Indie 3 = Doink/Dr.Prof

That is just where I sit.

Everyone else - is an afterthought

 

[Comrade Khan]

we should in fact remove any reasoning thats "finding out the split" , ur right. thats not valid reasoning for a lynch. u either believe the split or u dont, and in both cases u should be lynching doink for being bad indy or scum lying about there being 3 indies, which seems unlikely.

 

[Chris]

well the 4th thing is dumb. lets change the wording then.

we need to clear poe and he's in it

I think we just need to lynch the 3rd indie and I'm not sold its him anymore? He's clearly still in POE obviously but I'm confused on the current wanting to lynch him just for that reason. Since scum doesn't seem to have tracked him, I've really cooled off on the idea of him being the indy we want