World of Horror: An End of the World MAFIA Game Thread

[Maestro]

He could easily be both scum and telling the truth about losing his role fwiw

i also think this could be his last ditch effort

 

[Marty McFourth]

He could easily be both scum and telling the truth about losing his role fwiw

With him being roleless now (presumably), I actually think it's worth taking a stab at this lynch. What do you think?

If not him, I'd probably take the chance on lynching Big Man because I don't really trust the claim.

 

[Maestro]

Fair.

Is Tweet your only read, do you have any others?

necro is still there, a few caught my eyes as well, plan to do an iso on them

 

[Maestro]

Timing and we don't know it is real role without lynching him.

i meant to know in what way you dont like that? as in if you think he could be scum?

 

[Poyser]

My only slight pause atm is one of his gifts could have been a vote for me lmao

 

[Comrade Khan]

Something truly evil was posted in orange and by theme knowledge, I would assume it's very likely to be indy.

I would also like to know why I was given said item, since Tweet offered no reads last night to my knowledge

If we assume something truly evil is the indy, then we cannot clear Tweet on the fact he was vanillad

 

[Marty McFourth]

i meant to know in what way you dont like that? as in if you think he could be scum?

I think it's likely. I've had Big Man in my scum pool for a while this game because of the nature in which he's playing or lack thereof.

 

[Grimoire Lenin]

Vote Count:

Tweet (4) - Poyser, Jeff, Smark, CP, SA

 

[Poyser]

I dunno, I don’t really mind big man’s claim if I’m honest

I’m not really sure how you could have an active scum read on him, he’s not really provided anything either way. I know you say it feels like his scum game but to me his scum game is trying to remain useful whilst staying under the radar, not generally doing nothing. And he can often just not bother as town. He has also not bothered as scum too so I’m not saying he is town, but on the face of it I think I wanna buy his claim

 

[Marty McFourth]

My only slight pause atm is one of his gifts could have been a vote for me lmao

Does Tweet normally just sort of give up like that though as town? He admitted he isn't really catching-up and has made the claim, and yeah..

 

[Comrade Khan]

the two things that would give me pause:
- I can, at the very least, see the same parallel in how Tweet is responding to this threat to when we pushed him last game. However, I have no concrete evidence that he could care equally as little as scum
- Poyser's point of some of these gifts being to fix some neg usage is town is valid and iirc Barry's last game had two gift givers. one of which was town and the other scum

 

[Maestro]

anyway i think we shoud resolve tweet today, and if he truly is vanilla he wouldnt be much of a use eitherway.

lynch tweet

 

[Poyser]

Does Tweet normally just sort of give up like that though as town? He admitted he isn't really catching-up and has made the claim, and yeah..

He has stopped playing as town before yeah, but I’ve never seen him just do NOTHING as town before. He’s usually pretty eager to give thoughts and stuff lol

 

[Comrade Khan]

I dunno, I don’t really mind big man’s claim if I’m honest

I’m not really sure how you could have an active scum read on him, he’s not really provided anything either way. I know you say it feels like his scum game but to me his scum game is trying to remain useful whilst staying under the radar, not generally doing nothing. And he can often just not bother as town. He has also not bothered as scum too so I’m not saying he is town, but on the face of it I think I wanna buy his claim

fwiw, unless were afraid its a setup for pgo (which is unlikely due to chris's claim ) , i likely would not waste a lynch of big man. vigging him would be better if thats available imo

 

[Marty McFourth]

I dunno, I don’t really mind big man’s claim if I’m honest

I’m not really sure how you could have an active scum read on him, he’s not really provided anything either way. I know you say it feels like his scum game but to me his scum game is trying to remain useful whilst staying under the radar, not generally doing nothing. And he can often just not bother as town. He has also not bothered as scum too so I’m not saying he is town, but on the face of it I think I wanna buy his claim

I think we should resolve Tweet first then.

I just think the timing of Big Man's claim was pretty odd and I don't typically like those roles that cannot be proven without actually lynching them. Very easy fake.