Who is the overall best member of The Shield?

[The Phenom]

I had this same discussion on a former forum and it got a lot of replies and activity....So lets see what happens here. So this question came up in a convo with me and my two brothers...We were watching Raw one night and I was spewing my dislike for Roman Reigns!.....Anyway that convo led to Who is the overall best member of The Shield? I personally feel it is The Architect Seth Freakn Rollins my brother Twon is going with The Lunatic Fringe and my brother Sosa is going with Roman Reigns (I know right LMAO) WHO IS THE BEST OVERALL MEMBER OF THE SHIELD?

FEEL FREE TO JUST VOTE ON THE POLL BUT A COMMENT ON WHY YOU CHOSE YOUR PICK WOULD BE BETTER!

 

[smarkouts]

Reigns on the sneaktip.

I know it's trendy to hate on him, however i contend a lot of his issues stem from his booking.

Dude does nothing but put on quality match after quality match. If they would give him the stick and get out of his way with the scripts, i think he'd be easier to get behind.

Sent from my SM-G935P using Tapatalk

 

[The Phenom]

My choice which is also stated in the thread is Seth Freakn Rollins...... With out a doubt he is the best wrestler and has the best arsenal of moves out the bunch....He's neck and neck with Ambrose in promo skills but both could be a little better IMO....Seth just stands out in the group...In all fairness Dean was my favorite when the group first debuted but overtime I grew to appreciate Seth Freakn Rollins.....Now if he can just make it to a WrestleMania we would be in Business!

 

[smarkouts]

I've cooled a little on Rollins, maybe because it's they have him in the face role right now.

He's at best an anti hero - preferably heel.

Sent from my SM-G935P using Tapatalk

 

[The Phenom]

Reigns on the sneaktip.

I know it's trendy to hate on him, however i contend a lot of his issues stem from his booking.

Dude does nothing but put on quality match after quality match. If they would give him the stick and get out of his way with the scripts, i think he'd be easier to get behind.

Sent from my SM-G935P using Tapatalk

I'm not going to lie Roman is putting on way better matches then he ever has BUT I hate how much he relies upon that Garbage ass Superman Punch

 

[smarkouts]

I'm not going to lie Roman is putting on way better matches then he ever has BUT I hate how much he relies upon that Garbage ass Superman Punch

Agreed. I think the spear should be more of the common finish or set up to whatever. I think though, Seth will go the farthest. He has more of 'it'. I like Reigns better - but, and maybe it's the difference in booking, but Rollins when he's playing the whiny heel is so good.

Sent from my SM-G935P using Tapatalk

 

[The Phenom]

Yes, If there is one thing I can say good about Roman it would be that spear...It is like a beautiful train crash with that impact!! If he dropped the Superman Punch, work on his promos and then turned heel I would be able to tolerate him and may actually turn into a fan of his!

 

[Messiah]

Probably Seth Rollins, but they all excel in different areas.

Seth Rollins is the best in-ring worker, maybe the best mic worker to and is the most popular among the male audience.

Roman Reigns has the best look out of any of the members. Like it or not, it's a cosmetic business, it's very important. Not to mention he has a strong connection with the younger audience.

Dean Ambrose has the most defined character out of any of the Shield members being his lunatic gimmick, and the women and kids love him as well, some hardcore fans to.

 

[Drew]

I'm a fan of Dean, but it's gotta be Seth(if he can stay healthy, ugh).

 

[Sabretooth]

I love all of them but man it's gotta be Seth. Dude can do everything so naturally.

 

[Deezy]

Look at my av

 

[Cwalker]

Roman...

Marks can't admit it but the guy has it all. Doesn't have bad matches, can talk, has the look.

 

[Crippler]

Can talk when he's given free reign and is not told to say some of the awful tater tots lines.

 

[Roadster]

He can talk when not having regurgitated lines on a script. Plays the badass/cool guy shtick well.

 

[Cwalker]

Can talk when he's given free reign and is not told to say some of the awful tater tots lines.

Vince killed him for a while with that sufferin succotash shit