Throwback Music Mafia [Game Thread]

[Marty McFourth]

As much as I'm enjoying interacting with Chevy, I haven't got a Town read on him yet. Take that as you will. I'm going to read over his posts.

 

[Marty McFourth]

I am in for a Rugrat Lynch or an Ace Lynch.
Maybe one today and one tomorrow.

Let's see what Ace claims and then go from there. I would be happy with an Ace flip unless he claims a Town power role or something. I'd like Ace to defend himself and post more, to get more info obviously. He's only made 7 posts.

 

[T-Pein™]

No more votes on ace now pls

why?
lets get him out of here.
He will probably spend the whole game trying to push against all of my susses / wagons again

 

[Evans]

why?
lets get him out of here.
He will probably spend the whole game trying to push against all of my susses / wagons again

View attachment 9101

If Ace is town, he is absolutely a player who can be beneficial later in the game. It’s D1 we shouldn’t be rushing to get anyone out of the game unless they’re obv scum

 

[Marty McFourth]

why?
lets get him out of here.
He will probably spend the whole game trying to push against all of my susses / wagons again

View attachment 9101

I'm not about that, let him claim and defend himself. If he's Town we learn nothing much. When I used to play we never pushed Wagons to lynch without a claim. It's not good play imo.

 

[Odo]

why?
lets get him out of here.
He will probably spend the whole game trying to push against all of my susses / wagons again

View attachment 9101

that wouldn’t necessarily make him scum tho would it

 

[T-Pein™]

Let's see what Ace claims and then go from there. I would be happy with an Ace flip unless he claims a Town power role or something. I'd like Ace to defend himself and post more, to get more info obviously. He's only made 7 posts.

I mean I guess...
But last game all he did was claim "a strong town role".
Why wont he just do that again?
We need to get him out of here.
We have to go with our gut lads.

but never forget rugrat was down to lynch a town for no reason whatsoever.
how much scummier can you get?
he never pushed or sussed Blaine?
He just voted for him and then when I called him out he quickly unvoted.
Like he got spooked or something...

 

[Evans]

@T-Pein™ - inactivity isn’t as alignment indicative as you may be used to here bud

 

[T-Pein™]

that wouldn’t necessarily make him scum tho would it

well did we not see him Argue with me Over trying to lynch both the scums?
then after a while when it was clear people would follow the vote he just gave up.
Anti town AF.

he might do the same and this time it might work..
dangerous dude to have around.

And he is inactive so +1 on that.

 

[T-Pein™]

@T-Pein™ - inactivity isn’t as alignment indicative as you may be used to here bud

Lies,
The innactives are always a natural SUS for me.
Also.
We can see that it is easy for mafia to hide among them.
Last game I had a list of 4 people and two of them was mafia...

 

[Marty McFourth]

I mean I guess...
But last game all he did was claim "a strong town role".
Why wont he just do that again?
We need to get him out of here.
We have to go with our gut lads.

but never forget rugrat was down to lynch a town for no reason whatsoever.
how much scummier can you get?
he never pushed or sussed Blaine?
He just voted for him and then when I called him out he quickly unvoted.
Like he got spooked or something...

And was he Town last game or did he flip scum?

Rugrat had an explanation lined up, but I do think he was quick to unvote at the moment he got any pressure. He said he forgot his vote was on Blaine, but I don't know how to feel about that.

 

[T-Pein™]

why are we ignoring that Rugrat and Ace literally dipped out when they got sussed?
did they do this so we forget?
Do they not realize I have notes?
I never forget.

 

[Marty McFourth]

Lies,
The innactives are always a natural SUS for me.
Also.
We can see that it is easy for mafia to hide among them.
Last game I had a list of 4 people and two of them was mafia...

View attachment 9103

Listen, your logic on inactives is sound, but one game you're gonna end up being bit on the ass with this line of thinking. People could be busy or any other multitudes of reasons, it's not always alignment indictive.

One game, you're gonna get a scum team full of actives, maybe it's this game. It's going to shatter your entire view on inactives. You shouldn't read too much in to it. I am fine with pushing them later in the game if they have done nothing, but don't focus super hard on it.

 

[T-Pein™]

And was he Town last game or did he flip scum?

eh...
He was culted LOL

But I have NO idea why he was arguing with me?
Like even if the person I wanted killed flipped mafia or town then that would had been OK for him?
like I think he is just being edgy/confrontational for the sake of it.
Maybe he really is trying to get me on his good side this time?
Instead of trying to buddy me to keep me off of him?
Or not.
Either way he is dangerous.
we need him gone.

But again this is just a Gut Read...

 

[Marty McFourth]

why are we ignoring that Rugrat and Ace literally dipped out when they got sussed?
did they do this so we forget?
Do they not realize I have notes?
I never forget.

View attachment 9104

I don't think anyone has lol, we're pushing Ace right now and I have been saying Rugrat has been quiet a lot and he hasn't done anything to warrant being Town.

I think Ace is gonna be shocked when he logs back on, I was actually not paying as much attention to him last night but after a couple of guys highlighted his posts, I looked back and he doesn't look great. I could definitely see him as scum keeping a lowkey profile.