Throwback Music Mafia [Game Thread]

[Evans]

deoends how you look at it. I haven’t read your qt. in a competitive game where every lynch will count, it’s bold, but if you don’t really care then it’s whatever

as a play, it’s not what I’d do cause you can’t win til endgame but you can definitely lose, but then that’s me

The teams consensus was to get all 3 players to D5/N5 and win on majority. We had planned for Flay to fake again by blocking someone after no night kills N4 but 3 kills N3 when he was saucered.

IMO it was a very bold play to fake on you

 

[Odo]

I think that’s just bad game management tbh

 

[Marty McFourth]

Unvote: Flay

Fine. If Flay flips scum at any point, I'm definitely coming back to people who subtly defended him. Same goes for any of his defenders flipping scum. At the moment, I still don't trust him fully but I won't tunnel, because that is anti-town play imo.

 

[Marty McFourth]

I think I'd rather push Rugrat than Ace, but Ace's posts haven't pinged me as overly Town, he's pretty neutral. He is someone I'd like to get a read on as I found his Flay town read interesting. I liked Odo's point about it.

 

[Poyser]

Day 1 Vote Count

Flay (2) - Barry, PHEN0M
Ace (4) - Odo, Curry, T-Pein, Evans
The Fourth Wall (1) - Flay

ok you can have one more whilst I wait for the train

With 17 alive, it’s 9 to lynch. You have ~22 hours remaining.

​

 

[Evans]

I think I'd rather push Rugrat than Ace, but Ace's posts haven't pinged me as overly Town, he's pretty neutral. He is someone I'd like to get a read on as I found his Flay town read interesting. I liked Odo's point about it.

same question for yourself as I asked Curry - could you compare his last game vs this one?

 

[Odo]

Unvote: Flay

Fine. If Flay flips scum at any point, I'm definitely coming back to people who subtly defended him. Same goes for any of his defenders flipping scum. At the moment, I still don't trust him fully but I won't tunnel, because that is anti-town play imo.

iust ftr, could I get names on who you think subtly defended flay pls?

 

[Marty McFourth]

I think some people are misinterpreting my words on the Flay wagon. I did say I felt Rugrat/Flay was more likely to be Scum/Town than Scum/Scum but from my perspective placing a sinlge vote on Rugrat at that stage of the game and it sitting there would have been useless. Especially if I have reason to suspect them both and one flip could help me determine the alignment of the other potentially.

 

[Marty McFourth]

iust ftr, could I get names on who you think subtly defended flay pls?

We might have different perspectives on what subtle is:

Ace
Kajuh
Alco

Off the top of my head. Ace probably the least subtle out of them, but I don't know how I feel on him giving Flay a Town pass just because he's amping up aggression.

 

[Marty McFourth]

Kajuh's entrance looked fine ftr, I would say he's the least scummy looking out of that group I just named.

 

[Odo]

It’s not really a town pass tho, it’s just a town read. You don’t need to marry yourself to it. His play is ostensibly pro town and I wouldn’t lynch him today based on it

 

[Evans]

I think it’s definitely in scums benefit for Flay to stay alive as he is a player who is likely to resolve himself and get himself lynched as opposed to putting in effort for his lynch or wasting a factional kill.

 

[Marty McFourth]

It’s not really a town pass tho, it’s just a town read. You don’t need to marry yourself to it. His play is ostensibly pro town and I wouldn’t lynch him today based on it

It would look bad if Ace flips scum tho, no? I see you suspect him.

 

[Marty McFourth]

I think it’s definitely in scums benefit for Flay to stay alive as he is a player who is likely to resolve himself and get himself lynched as opposed to putting in effort for his lynch or wasting a factional kill.

It'll be the same for me, trust me. I'm never high on scum's priority list because I blabber too much and I'm indecisive. Qualities which make me look bad over time, but it's just because I choose to lay out all my thoughts in open rather than being private. As Town, I don't care how that makes me look. I'm not trying to look town, because I am. I generally hope people see that or people I suspect flip scum, obviously that makes things easier lol

 

[Evans]

It'll be the same for me, trust me. I'm never high on scum's priority list because I blabber too much and I'm indecisive. Qualities which make me look bad over time, but it's just because I choose to lay out all my thoughts in open rather than being private. As Town, I don't care how that makes me look. I'm not trying to look town, because I am. I generally hope people see that or people I suspect flip scum, obviously that makes things easier lol

I think we’re going to get along sir