No. Neither of them would win that match, so I'd rather have the previous two that could actually make the match more exciting.
This is my card:
WHC Championship
John Cena(c) vs Batista
WWE Championship (I agree, maybe TLC, maybe, if not then just any Hardcore stipulation. The ladders will eventually coming out
Jeff Hardy vs Edge(c)
Randy Orton vs Stone Cold
HBK vs JBL
Women's Championship
Beth Pheonix vs Melina
MITB Ladder Match
Rey Mysterio vs Umaga vs John Morrison vs Evan Bourne vs Kofi Kingston vs Shelton Benjamin vs The Brian Kendrick vs Ted DiBiase
Mr. Kennedy vs MVP
Winner gets Kelly-Kelly
Kane vs CM Punk
Either HHH vs The Undertaker or Y2J vs The Undertaker
ECW Championship
Matt Hardy vs Battle Royal Winner
I also see a Brand vs Brand happening, to give a match to either HHH or Y2J, depending on who doesnt face The Undertaker