The Official 2024-25 MLB Offseason Discussion Thread

[Apoho Creed]

 

[Doom]

Congrats HoHo to see your Phillies make it to the World Series for the first time since 2008 (actually it was 2009). Like the Braves last season, the team got hot at the right time, and finished below 90 wins to make it all the way. I wish the Phillies to best of luck to win it all!

EDITED

 

[Apoho Creed]

Congrats HoHo to see your Phillies make it to the World Series for the first time since 2008. Like the Braves last season, the team got hot at the right time, and finished below 90 wins to make it all the way. I wish the Phillies to best of luck to win it all!

Thank you Doom. The World Series return in 09 still hurts my soul because of who we loss to in the Yankees. I kinda wanna play them to get revenge but either way I know it's going to be Rocky vs Apollo Rocky 2 type of fight in the World Series and I'm ready for it.

 

[Doom]

Thank you Doom. The World Series return in 09 still hurts my soul because of who we loss to in the Yankees. I kinda wanna play them to get revenge but either way I know it's going to be Rocky vs Apollo Rocky 2 type of fight in the World Series and I'm ready for it.

Ah fuck, I meant 2009, was the last time they played lol

 

[Apoho Creed]

Ah fuck, I meant 2009, was the last time they played lol

It's all good Doom.

 

[Lady Redfield]

I want to throw my phone right now.

Yankees just learned base hits will get you runs in, like I’ve been yelling at my tv for weeks.

They’ve made me wait this long, in an elimination game, to finally do the right thing.

You bastards, I don’t have a good heart.

 

[Chris]

 

[Lady Redfield]

Holy fucking shitballs, Yankees


If it's not the batting, it's the pitching.

This is unlike Cortes to be off his game, unfortunate.

Now, we go in to the shaky ass bullpen....might as well just end this now, it's only the 3rd inning.

Go JT Realmuto.

 

[Jam]

Time to become a Cardinals fan

Yankees need a front office change and a new manager.

 

[Storm Trooper]

The only people who should be here next year are Cole, Stanton, Nestor, and the kids. New coaching staff, new front office. New everything. I can't with this shit anymore.

 

[Jam]

The only people who should be here next year are Cole, Stanton, Nestor, and the kids. New coaching staff, new front office. New everything. I can't with this shit anymore.

How about Judge?

Agree with that list, though I'd add Bader. Not sure about Stanton but sure, as long as he never takes the field please. If by kids you mean Cabrera and Peraza, then absolutely. If they can somehow flip Peraza for a pitcher like Castillo, then they gotta do it. Volpe should be on the horizon pretty soon. Unless they're switching Peraza and Volpe's position and one of them plays 2B so the other can play SS.

 

[Storm Trooper]

How about Judge?

Agree with that list, though I'd add Bader. Not sure about Stanton but sure, as long as he never takes the field please. If by kids you mean Cabrera and Peraza, then absolutely. If they can somehow flip Peraza for a pitcher like Castillo, then they gotta do it. Volpe should be on the horizon pretty soon. Unless they're switching Peraza and Volpe's position and one of them plays 2B so the other can play SS.

I honestly am no longer sure. I like him and want to keep him but he is gonna get a 350-400 million dollar contract and don't know if that's a good idea.

I neglected to include Rizzo. He's a keeper.

Stanton is a proven performer in October. And no one is gonna take the contract if you wanted to unload it.

Kids refers to Cabrera, and Peraza. Volpe comes up during next year.

 

[JakeYourBooty]

Gerrit Cole might be the worst contract I’ve ever seen


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro

 

[Lady Redfield]

I don’t think Judge will have many more seasons like this (not including this shit post season…). He’s my current favorite Yankee and I’ll be sad if he leaves, though.

Bader
Rizzo
Cabrera
Benintendi
Peraza
Cortes
Cole
Loaisiga
Peralta


I would keep these guys.

Fuck Stanton, he’s an overpaid bum.


Severino, I’d be okay with, though, between injuries and just plain being a hit and miss pitcher, probably a risk, but, man, we need pitching.

 

[Storm Trooper]

I don’t think Judge will have many more seasons like this (not including this shit post season…). He’s my current favorite Yankee and I’ll be sad if he leaves, though.

Bader
Rizzo
Cabrera
Benintendi
Peraza
Cortes
Cole
Loaisiga
Peralta


I would keep these guys.

Fuck Stanton, he’s an overpaid bum.


Severino, I’d be okay with, though, between injuries and just plain being a hit and miss pitcher, probably a risk, but, man, we need pitching.

I will vehemently disagree with you on Stanton. Your list is more thought out and correct, although I'd obviously add Stanton, and I'd probably remove Benintendi as it's not like he proved much of anything while he's been here. Sevy probably stays too for another year. Yankees need pitching I'd probably end up throwing a blank check at deGrom.