Oh lawd I forgot about that. Yeah, she was always lame but when she first came to the main roster it was a good lame as she appealed to little kids, especially little girls which worked well for her. Soon as they screwed up that image, she just became what seems to be an air headed woman-child who thinks boys have cooties and being BBF's with Sasha is as important as marriage.
Off-topic pesudo rant, I... don't think the NXT gimmicks are that far off from main roster's. Yeah they have character arcs like the MR doesn't where dudes just spin at the same spot forever, but... Like New Day, one of the last over acts they made, really got over because every week they added one more random thing to their act as soon as it got stale. They decided "ya know that New Day Rocks thing we do, yeah lets do it on a trombone now lol" or "we should come out with unicorn horns this week lol" and they just seemed like three dudes just not giving a damn and doing whatever random crap they felt like doing and it worked, then they put on good matches.
See it the same as Tyler Breeze on NXT, they kept adding little tweaks here and there to keep him fresh but...
Anyway, Bayley... It's sad to say but she kinda feels like Myspace at this point. It's not even that she isn't working now, it's that we look back and wonder how she ever did.
Her matches were damn well booked and she told wonderful stories on the brand that actually tells stories, and her gimmick of little girl superfan come to life worked like a charm.
Take the storytelling away and it's like... wow.