Save the Cheerleader, Save the World: Heroes Mafia Game Thread

[Junkette]

Traitor is a scum who doesn’t know his scum team and i’d Think you’d know this so you’re double down spec is garbage and just screams hoping we believe u over Gambitto

 

[Junkette]

Lmaoooooo Junk still trying to discredit me and call me scum.

Can you point out things ive done/not done or perhaps interactions to support your crusade, Miss Bliss?

Not at night? I’m just saying yours looks more like a setup, I haven’t even called you scum yet, why are you so quick to loldiscredit me?

 

[Comrade Khan]

Traitor is a scum who doesn’t know his scum team and i’d Think you’d know this so you’re double down spec is garbage and just screams hoping we believe u over Gambitto

what is your actual point? I still wouldnt want to actively lynch my potential scummates. I swear people take me for a fucking idiot...

 

[PHEN0M]

Two dead scum both on Day 1 tried to discredit early town reads i made. Think that was a group plan?

 

[Comrade Khan]

And for the record, no amount of attempts at emotional manipulation is going to work (trying to make us feel for you ) Junk, so you can just get that out of your defensive repertoire

 

[Chris]

I think it's pretty clear (and 'provable') that Junk's claim is legit. It's a bad fake because, unlike a PGO, anyone targeting Junk would know they would still have a Day phase to say they did so. If she plays scummy then lynch at a later date.



This isn't a good look

Doc.

Junk was a decent scum player when we were playing regularly and like I said I think there's a significant difference between regular PGO and Poisoner PGO due to the delayed death. I agree she needs to be judged on play and I never gave her a Town read ftr although perhaps you can tell I do think it's likely she isn't Mafia. It's a role which can basically break the game if she is

I actually would be inclined to think Guts was giving a good guy read to Junk here with the "break the game" line, especially now knowing that scum for sure had a redirector. I'm still town on Junk for now

 

[Junkette]

All I’m really getting at is Haza’s suspicion makes sense coming from a town player who’s amazing as scum.

Yours is paint town junk to look like a scum junk by numbers @PHEN0M

 

[RDK]

im in, my GOOD friend poyser

Why is GOOD bold here. Tell me it's an inside joke thing and not you trying to get Poyser's attention

 

[Chris]

Guts voted Jeff on D1 and then Jeff started asking about Guts' scum meta afterwards. Clearly not aligned IMO....knowingly at least bc Jeff could still be traitor.

 

[Comrade Khan]

Why is GOOD bold here. Tell me it's an inside joke thing and not you trying to get Poyser's attention

lol yeah just the GOOD FRIEND thing we always bold.

 

[Junkette]

I’m an emotional player, town Odo even knew this, using emotion to defend my emotional actions ain’t scummy when I do it as both alignments

If I can be emotional wouldn’t u want me to be open about them as town to see where I’m coming from?

 

[PHEN0M]

You’re right, you haven’t outright said that I’m scum but you sure have been throwing shade my way the entire game and won’t commit to the scum read. Why is that Junk?

 

[Comrade Khan]

I will say though @Chris ès point is valid. redirector+poison on the same team seems very cheesy

 

[Junkette]

Because rn I admittedly look bad and don’t want to lead town astray again, I’m in defence mode, come at me

 

[Chris]

Ultimately, I'd like a more convincing case because I do think I may have picked up on something

@Raidokken I meant one of them not both but either works. If you assume one is scum and Chris were scum with one of them then there is a benefit to bringing up the role overlap in thread

This is where he throws out that Junk/Odo/myself might be a scum team and that's why I'd bring up role overlap lmao