Save the Cheerleader, Save the World: Heroes Mafia Game Thread

[Ace]

Christo, given the above implies you have more than 1 shot of your lie detector, is there a reason after everything that was said in the thread after you used your first shot on me, that you did not use a second shot on Gambit, or at least ask if you should do so?

@Chr1st0 pls answer

 

[Guts]

Its not setup spec. That is my role.

Tell you what, you lynch me then you follow my lead on the next lynch deal?

That said you should still wait for others to chime in. There's plenty left in Day and I'd like to see who's gonna jump at this chance. You gain nothing from quick lynching me off of info

 

[Tweet]

What are you on about lol

It's okay I'm just nitpicking at this point

 

[RDK]

I actually agree that it is a kinda weird role to give to town so I can't really argue here.

That said, it is worth considering why I would claim this as my second role if I have said my abilities have been stolen.

If my abilities hadn't been stolen it would have made more sense as the alternative would be faking my second role, or never having claimed to have one at all.

But since I don't need to prove that I ever had this role any more, it would make much more sense for me to claim something that is easier to justify as town.

I know this delves into WIFOM territory but eh.



Fair enough, people have been talking about protecting me etc so I probably misinterpreted that.

Just went back and checked and it was actually a kill delay in mr robot so obviously this version is much more town friendly and believable.

 

[Guts]

Grim Cornette
Chris
Chr1st0 (Hank) - Not Mafia
Jeff Valley Driver
Gambitto
mikey damage
Raidokken
NotBrutus

^Scum in here IMO. If Gambit is scum I wanna say I don't think Barry is but him wanting to lynch Doddsy over him this phase is strange to me so I wouldn't rule it out entirely. Haza would probably be the last one of those I'd lynch and I thought I had Chris as Town earlier but I can't remember why but maybe he can be cleared somehow if you do some digging

 

[Ace]

Just went back and checked and it was actually a kill delay in mr robot so obviously this version is much more town friendly and believable.

Either way its safe to assume this is in non-town's hands now and it is a pretty useful role to them to stop certain town roles like BG (if Gambit is a town BG), trackers, and watchers.

 

[Smart Marx]

A Demo God Production of Heroes Mafia
Common people discover that they have super powers. Their lives intertwine as a devastating event must be prevented.

Doddsy has challenged Chr1st0 to a duel and he cannot decline.

Place a vote for the player you wish to win alongside your lynch votes. The first player to achieve 10 votes is locked in as the winner. If no majority is reached, the player with the most votes will win. If there is a tie, Doddsy wins the duel. The loser will die at the end of day. When placing your votes, please bold vote X to win the duel. Good luck and God have mercy on your souls.

Neither player may vote for themselves.​

 

[Chris]

He's saying he doesn't buy the Lie Detector.

There's not really much more I can say, you either buy the claim or you don't. Like I said, it's a slim chance but if a Tracker did Track you then they'd at least know who you got the guilty on. I don't know what other abilities I'll get ftr

If you're an ascetic then a bus driver couldn't have driven you though right? So how would Tweet's target have changed?

 

[Smart Marx]

Was gonna say the same, Sylar cuts people heads open to take their power where as Arthur takes them with his power.


Also

Duel chr1st0

Good morning

vote Guts

This is info

vote Doddsy to win the duel

Can't imagine we have a cop and a lie detector

Vote doddsy to win the duel

Oh he said he'd use his other shot I guess we should wait for that incase

Unvote doddsy to win the duel

Vote Guts

I don't think setup spec can really override a cop result

A Demo God Production of Heroes Mafia
Common people discover that they have super powers. Their lives intertwine as a devastating event must be prevented.

Midday 3 Vote Count

Guts (2) - Tweet, Doddsy

Duel Scoreboard

Doddsy (1) - Tweet

With 18 players remaining in the game, it takes 10 votes to reach a lynch.

Day 3 will end on Tuesday, Oct 27th, at 2:35 AM ET.​

 

[Chris]

I'm down to lynch Guts off the cop result and vote Doddsy to win the duel tbh. I do want to wait for what Chr1sto comes back with his lie detector shot as well though.

I can't see Tweet lying here, the hints were there D2 and the ascetic claim makes it less likely his result was tampered

 

[RDK]

Doc always does those lists on his own, and doesn’t usually reveal them day one.

As either alignment presumably?

 

[RDK]

considering there was some lapse, its possible you quickly came up with it. fairly sure odo pointed that the list itself wasnt overly compelling either iirc on my read back. nice try tho

the list was fine. I thought Odo's analysis of it was a little harsh because it was definitely based on interactions and more than just votes. I know because I had similar thoughts. You should go back and look for yourself rather than shading something you haven't read because Odo did

 

[PHEN0M]

Vote: Guts

Vote: Doddsy to Win the Duel.

 

[Doddsy]

I actually agree that it is a kinda weird role to give to town so I can't really argue here.

That said, it is worth considering why I would claim this as my second role if I have said my abilities have been stolen.

If my abilities hadn't been stolen it would have made more sense as the alternative would be faking my second role, or never having claimed to have one at all.

But since I don't need to prove that I ever had this role any more, it would make much more sense for me to claim something that is easier to justify as town.

I know this delves into WIFOM territory but eh.



Fair enough, people have been talking about protecting me etc so I probably misinterpreted that.

Quite like this post actually, it's a fair point.

Not sure what to think of Ace getting his role stolen, I'd like to think people were okay with the claim and the role he claimed was easily provable so I'm leaning that this claim of having his role stolen is not a PLAY.

It does fit a player we know is in the game from Poyser's flip as well.

Its not setup spec. That is my role.

Tell you what, you lynch me then you follow my lead on the next lynch deal?

That said you should still wait for others to chime in. There's plenty left in Day and I'd like to see who's gonna jump at this chance. You gain nothing from quick lynching me off of info

Set-up spec is based off you being Claire. The ascetic portion is just outright convenient don't you agree?

Also what do you mean follow your lead on the next lynch?

If you're an ascetic then a bus driver couldn't have driven you though right? So how would Tweet's target have changed?

Ascetic automatically redirects roles targeting them to someone else at random

 

[Doddsy]

Happy to wait for everyone to give extra thoughts and stuff as well, no need to rush anything