Save the Cheerleader, Save the World: Heroes Mafia Game Thread

[Ace]

Btw since I've had my abilities stolen I may as well mentioned the other one since it is now in the hands of non-town.

I could delay someone's action by one night - so if they were to, for example, kill someone tonight, but i used the ability on them, their kill would only go through the next night.

It was not evolvable.

 

[Ace]

The Lie Detector might be a complete hoax, if it's a multi-shot role I absolutely don't see Hank completely fail to use the role on multiple occasions.

Yup, it is very easy to "clear" a person who claims Hiro with a fake lie detector since it's such a primary role in the show that it is extremely unlikely to be a fake for scum or 3p.

The other claims were not nearly as easily-confirmed and would instant out scum to 3P or vice versa if it was an incorrect fake clear, so it would not make sense to fake the lie detector result in these scenarios.

 

[Doddsy]

Read a few posts up Doddsy

Oh okay. That's fairly convenient. Why would Claire be a developer?

 

[Guts]

Not a question for me. The developer aspect seems loosely tied in to the flavour unless you assume it's something to do with the experiments but I don't have theme knowledge so can't really comment

 

[Ace]

As much as saying this might hurt me, If people are largely willing to accept I'm town based off a Hiro claim, surely the same needs to be true of Claire? Either we need to mostly trust Guts or trust me less if we're basing things on claims.

 

[RDK]

Btw since I've had my abilities stolen I may as well mentioned the other one since it is now in the hands of non-town.

I could delay someone's action by one night - so if they were to, for example, kill someone tonight, but i used the ability on them, their kill would only go through the next night.

It was not evolvable.

Yeah this is usually a scum role from my experience

 

[Doddsy]

As much as saying this might hurt me, If people are largely willing to accept I'm town based off a Hiro claim, surely the same needs to be true of Claire? Either we need to mostly trust Guts or trust me less if we're basing things on claims.

I think you're over valuing how much people are sure of you being town tbh. Your claim makes much more sense from a theme perspective than docs does. I'm weighing it up while I'm working but I don't really buy it.

Yeah this is usually a scum role from my experience

Do you have some examples?

 

[Guts]

If we're operating under the assumption that scum have full fakes then does that change anything for you Doddsy? Not to mention Smark says not to hunt off flavour

 

[RDK]

I think you're over valuing how much people are sure of you being town tbh. Your claim makes much more sense from a theme perspective than docs does. I'm weighing it up while I'm working but I don't really buy it.



Do you have some examples?

I know we had a kill delay in Mr. Robot, i'll take a look at other games

 

[RDK]

If we're operating under the assumption that scum have full fakes then does that change anything for you Doddsy? Not to mention Smark says not to hunt off flavour

Scum have full fakes but not all slots will have claimable roles. From my experience with Smark games a couple will and for the rest he is happy to create fakes based on what the slot decides they want to claim. As I said, he's a very generous host.

 

[RDK]

Well I'm Noah Bennet, x-shot Cop who investigated you last night and got told that "your target is Mafia".

If a Bus Driver did something to Guts last night they oughta speak up post haste.

Also I copped TKOK n1, he is not Mafia. That's the sorta formatting I get my results in, target is Mafia/not Mafia.

Can't imagine we have a cop and a lie detector

Vote doddsy to win the duel

 

[RDK]

Oh he said he'd use his other shot I guess we should wait for that incase

Unvote doddsy to win the duel

 

[Tweet]

I'm not clearing anyone based on character spec btw. All I know is I got a guilty result on Doc.

 

[Tweet]

Oh he said he'd use his other shot I guess we should wait for that incase

Unvote doddsy to win the duel

So you don't think I'm the Cop?

 

[RDK]

So you don't think I'm the Cop?

I think you are. That's why I plan on voting Doddsy to win the duel after Christo uses the second shot he claims to have.