Save the Cheerleader, Save the World: Heroes Mafia Game Thread

[Ace]

No. Hosts can't give scum that sort of information, obviously. But I will say Smark helps scum teams more than any other host I know.

So we're working under the assumption that if Gambit is scum but not BG, he would be gambling by claiming to be one?

 

[Ace]

Yo @Tweet what are your thoughts on me?

 

[RDK]

So we're working under the assumption that if Gambit is scum but not BG, he would be gambling by claiming to be one?

Yes. He would have to be gambling that the game setup mapped out in his favor over the course of the game. And the likelihood is, it wouldn't. I can't see him taking the risk.

 

[Comrade Khan]

So we're working under the assumption that if Gambit is scum but not BG, he would be gambling by claiming to be one?

not gambling. like smark is the kind of host who would craft a fake BG claim for scum, if that was an available fake

 

[Ace]

Yes. He would have to be gambling that the game setup mapped out in his favor over the course of the game. And the likelihood is, it wouldn't. I can't see him taking the risk.

Agreed. Basically assuming he is a BG but not sure of alignment then.

not gambling. like smark is the kind of host who would craft a fake BG claim for scum, if that was an available fake

Did we not just determine that Smark wouldn't give this information to scum?

Or are you implying available fake means "one of scum has a BG ability"?

 

[Comrade Khan]

I know you're not talking to me here but Odo made a big post on why he thinks Chimp is town and I got my own reasons to think likewise. I'm not a fan of you pushing the exact opposite of what I'd like to be pushing right now.

not sure i have plausible reasons to link junk to poyser however,unles that was some outrageoussly overacted bussing (and given poysers role, i wouldnt have agreed to that to save a poisoner).

not to get overly speccy here, but i don't really see Junk being anything but t/i here?

 

[Comrade Khan]

Agreed. Basically assuming he is a BG but not sure of alignment then.

Did we not just determine that Smark wouldn't give this information to scum?

Or are you implying available fake means "one of scum has a BG ability"?

well smark usually would give a usuable fake (hes all abou tthat). so i guess in this theoretical example, Gambit could the scum jailkeeper with a BG fake (just an example)

 

[Ace]

well smark usually would give a usuable fake (hes all abou tthat). so i guess in this theoretical example, Gambit could the scum jailkeeper with a BG fake (just an example)

Gotcha. So for a BG fake, scum would need a similar role that could be faked to be the BG.

Also agree with you on the Junk point, there's like no chance Junk and Poyser were/are aligned.

 

[Comrade Khan]

Gotcha. So for a BG fake, scum would need a similar role that could be faked to be the BG.

Also agree with you on the Junk point, there's like no chance Junk and Poyser were/are aligned.

I would assume so, unless they taking a big gamble. or someone else on their team has that role. but usually , from my experience, smark usually gives something quasi believable

 

[Comrade Khan]

Gotcha. So for a BG fake, scum would need a similar role that could be faked to be the BG.

Also agree with you on the Junk point, there's like no chance Junk and Poyser were/are aligned.

outside of her going full madlass rogue, which i guess is technically possible. but logic would dictate thats unlikely imo

 

[Comrade Khan]

I mean anectodal but he gave me 3 seperate fakes in star wars

 

[Comrade Khan]

If Tweet isn't town I'll eat my hat too , as an aside

 

[Tweet]

Those following Odo's reads why are you going for Guts over Ace or Gambit?

I'm still not a huge fan of Gambit but am also loathe to lynch the claimed BG. Far as Ace goes, he's null to me but also looks like low hanging fruit that if he's town, scum will wanna direct us towards.

 

[Tweet]

Also you know, since Guts wants to go for Ace rn that's another reason for why I don't want to.

 

[Comrade Khan]

Call me adventurous, don't mind calling the bluff. Not like it would clear him, either

In any case Tweet, my axe is available on Guts as well. ideally I don't see why we could not wagon both and use our time efficiently. Ace has already seemingly said he's willing to claim with pressure, so I see no reason to not see that through as well