Save the Cheerleader, Save the World: Heroes Mafia Game Thread

[Lethal]

Grim Cornette - ?
Chris - ?
Tweet - Noah Bennett, x-shot Cop
Ace Dalton - Hiro Nakamura, x-shot time traveller (had role stolen)
Doddsy - Kaito Nakamura, Odd Day Duelist
Alco - ?
TKOK - ?
Lethal Banks - Mohinder Suresh, Poison Doctor
mikey damage - ?
PHEN0M - Double voter
Big Man - ?

3 scum (4 if you consider Jeff scum) and an SK have flipped so far [5 non-town]. Would be really nice if the OP were updated @Demo God if that's possible?

We started with 22 players. Rule of thumb that 1/3 is scum, so 7 non-town all up, so we're after 2 more from the pool left. Mass claim should shed some light.

 

[Bobby Barrows]

Grim Cornette - ?
Chris - ?
Tweet - Noah Bennett, x-shot Cop
Ace Dalton - Hiro Nakamura, x-shot time traveller (had role stolen)
Doddsy - Kaito Nakamura, Odd Day Duelist
Alco - ?
TKOK - ?
Lethal Banks - Mohinder Suresh, Poison Doctor
mikey damage - ?
PHEN0M - Double voter
Big Man - ?

3 scum (4 if you consider Jeff scum) and an SK have flipped so far [5 non-town]. Would be really nice if the OP were updated @Demo God if that's possible?

We started with 22 players. Rule of thumb that 1/3 is scum, so 7 non-town all up, so we're after 2 more from the pool left. Mass claim should shed some light.

My claim should be pretty obvious for anyone paying even the slightest bit of attention.

 

[Doddsy]

Well those flips kinda complicate things.

As far as who I wouldn't lynch - PHEN0M and Doddsy are my only ones so far. Going to have to re-evaluate my whole thought process.



He even said he lied about the Ace result because he read him so strongly as town.

Does that mean you're considering tweet?

 

[Lethal]

Does that mean you're considering tweet?

Yup

 

[Lethal]

My claim should be pretty obvious for anyone paying even the slightest bit of attention.

I feel your shade here is undeserved and thus not appreciated. I'm not going to spell things out for those not looking for it.

 

[Alco]

I do think the Tweetster is town

Lethal being the healer here is probably also fine given Junk flipped the way she did.

 

[Lethal]

Midday 1 Vote Count

Poyser (3) - Rugrat, Odo, Jeff Valley Driver
Mi$$ Bli$$ (1) - Lethal Banks
Rugrat (1) - Big Man
Lethal Banks (6) - Gambitto, Raidokken, Mi$$ Bli$$, Poyser, PHEN0M
PHENOM (1) - Grim Cornette
Gambitto (2) - Laughable Chimp, Hank
Jeff Valley Driver (2) - Guts, Tweet
Ace Dalton (1) - Alco

Final Day 1 Vote Count

Poyser (14) - Rugrat, Odo, Jeff Valley Driver, Big Man, Laughable Chimp, Raidokken, Tweet, Mi$$ Bli$$, Alco, Guts, PHEN0M, Gambitto, Hank
Mi$$ Bli$$ (1) - Lethal Banks
Tweet (1) - Doddsy
Gambitto (1) - Grim Cornette
Big Man (1) - Poyser

Final Day 2 Vote Count

Laughable Chimp (5) - Mi$$ Bli$$, Gambitto, Chr1st0, Doddsy, Guts
Guts (2) - Tweet, Laughable Chimp
Gambitto (1) - Grim Cornette
Jeff Valley Driver (2) - PHEN0M
Ace Dalton (2) - Jeff Valley Driver, TKOK

Final Day 3 Vote Count

Guts (11) - Tweet, Doddsy, PHEN0M, Gambitto, Chr1st0, Jeff Valley Driver, Raidokken, Lethal Banks, Big Man, Chris

Final Day 4 Vote Count

Jeff Valley Driver (12) - Gambitto, Raidokken, PHEN0M, Doddsy, Ace Dalton, Chris, Alco, Tweet, Big Man, NotBrutus, Lethal Banks
Alco (1) - Mi$$ Bli$$

Midday 5 Vote Count

NotBrutus (6) - Lethal Banks, Alco, PHEN0M, Tweet, TKOK

That's all the votes throughout the game (colours for the flipped players, bold/underline colours for my reads)

Thoughts?

Barry hasn't voted since Day 2, and ended both days on Gambit.

Chris was not on Poyser, not on day 2, end of the wagon on D3, 7th vote on Jeff, not on brutus.

Updated Reads:

Grim Cornette - ?, Bomb [skating by, haven't seen much from him, also the votes parked on Gambit then no votes]
Chris - ? [found more scummy posts than towny posts in initial ISO, re-visited his post D2 comments and no change]
Tweet - Noah Bennett, x-shot Cop [copped TKOK town, Guts scum, see no reason for him to bus Guts as he had a good footing in the game. Has something on Mikey.]
Ace Dalton - Hiro Nakamura, x-shot time traveller (had role stolen) [will revisit this town read as I can't remember why - can delay actions of a player...odd role]
Doddsy - Kaito Nakamura, Odd Day Duelist [again, town on role spec - scum having a 2-shot duellist + execution seems way too OP]
Alco - ? [will ISO to try and gain some form of a read - didn't buy Gambit as town from his claim, sussed Ace]
TKOK - ? [copped town, but II GF is a possibility]
Lethal Banks - Mohinder Suresh, Poison Doctor
mikey damage - ? [haven't been able to find a single reason to town read him, and brutus flipped town. Tweet hinted something about him]
PHEN0M - ?, Double voter [town on role spec and balance of play - don't think there'd be DV with executioner and vote buyer]
Big Man - ? [only because I always read him scum and will read differently now - can change read. Points for the Poyser argument.]

 

[Lethal]

Occams Razor would suggest that Jeff wouldn't use my ability on gambit tho lol

But Jeff said he did which is what led to the lynch

 

[Ace]

But Jeff said he did which is what led to the lynch

Gambit was dead in the water anyway and Jeff making the play he did gives him two benefits - 1) it makes him look good and may see town keep him onboard for a day or two, and 2) Jeff needs GF dead to win and Gambit woule be a shot in the dark for him.

 

[Alco]

I think you make a compelling argument on Chris with the votes.

This reminds me of that game where he went from 10/1 to win as sole scum survivor. Skating by, making himself look reasonably town, but never taking a real solid stance on anything.

I have the impression he's doing a bit of the same here. He's asking a lot of questions, he's throwing up a lot of theories on what could go on games-mechanics-wise, but I don't have the feeling he's going strongly on any scum read of his.

 

[Alco]

Has Chris really only voted two times?

 

[Alco]

Not that my four votes are much better

 

[Tweet]

If you want another argument for why I'm town, I was on Gambits ass from page two onward.

 

[Big Man]

I’m town. I pressured gambit early as well and then Poyser discredited by push by trying to say I didn’t push him at all which would be an absolutely ridiculous thing for a teammate to do in response to a bus.

also if I did that play with Poyser I would make sure to benefit from it and do something with my thread position, not do absolutely nothing until end game comes around when people start suspecting everybody otherwise what was the point?

 

[Bobby Barrows]

Midday 1 Vote Count

Poyser (3) - Rugrat, Odo, Jeff Valley Driver
Mi$$ Bli$$ (1) - Lethal Banks
Rugrat (1) - Big Man
Lethal Banks (6) - Gambitto, Raidokken, Mi$$ Bli$$, Poyser, PHEN0M
PHENOM (1) - Grim Cornette
Gambitto (2) - Laughable Chimp, Hank
Jeff Valley Driver (2) - Guts, Tweet
Ace Dalton (1) - Alco

Final Day 1 Vote Count

Poyser (14) - Rugrat, Odo, Jeff Valley Driver, Big Man, Laughable Chimp, Raidokken, Tweet, Mi$$ Bli$$, Alco, Guts, PHEN0M, Gambitto, Hank
Mi$$ Bli$$ (1) - Lethal Banks
Tweet (1) - Doddsy
Gambitto (1) - Grim Cornette
Big Man (1) - Poyser

Final Day 2 Vote Count

Laughable Chimp (5) - Mi$$ Bli$$, Gambitto, Chr1st0, Doddsy, Guts
Guts (2) - Tweet, Laughable Chimp
Gambitto (1) - Grim Cornette
Jeff Valley Driver (2) - PHEN0M
Ace Dalton (2) - Jeff Valley Driver, TKOK

Final Day 3 Vote Count

Guts (11) - Tweet, Doddsy, PHEN0M, Gambitto, Chr1st0, Jeff Valley Driver, Raidokken, Lethal Banks, Big Man, Chris

Final Day 4 Vote Count

Jeff Valley Driver (12) - Gambitto, Raidokken, PHEN0M, Doddsy, Ace Dalton, Chris, Alco, Tweet, Big Man, NotBrutus, Lethal Banks
Alco (1) - Mi$$ Bli$$

Midday 5 Vote Count

NotBrutus (6) - Lethal Banks, Alco, PHEN0M, Tweet, TKOK

That's all the votes throughout the game (colours for the flipped players, bold/underline colours for my reads)

Thoughts?

Barry hasn't voted since Day 2, and ended both days on Gambit.

Chris was not on Poyser, not on day 2, end of the wagon on D3, 7th vote on Jeff, not on brutus.

Updated Reads:

Grim Cornette - ?, Bomb [skating by, haven't seen much from him, also the votes parked on Gambit then no votes]
Chris - ? [found more scummy posts than towny posts in initial ISO, re-visited his post D2 comments and no change]
Tweet - Noah Bennett, x-shot Cop [copped TKOK town, Guts scum, see no reason for him to bus Guts as he had a good footing in the game. Has something on Mikey.]
Ace Dalton - Hiro Nakamura, x-shot time traveller (had role stolen) [will revisit this town read as I can't remember why - can delay actions of a player...odd role]
Doddsy - Kaito Nakamura, Odd Day Duelist [again, town on role spec - scum having a 2-shot duellist + execution seems way too OP]
Alco - ? [will ISO to try and gain some form of a read - didn't buy Gambit as town from his claim, sussed Ace]
TKOK - ? [copped town, but II GF is a possibility]
Lethal Banks - Mohinder Suresh, Poison Doctor
mikey damage - ? [haven't been able to find a single reason to town read him, and brutus flipped town. Tweet hinted something about him]
PHEN0M - ?, Double voter [town on role spec and balance of play - don't think there'd be DV with executioner and vote buyer]
Big Man - ? [only because I always read him scum and will read differently now - can change read. Points for the Poyser argument.]

Feels like you're just simplifying everything down to vote counts, I've also become much more active as the game has gone on. Not only that, you keep forgetting that I'm fairly sure I voted Brutus on D5. Here you go:

Lel aight. Just would like to thank Junk for essentially poisoning the well in regards to any character attached to my role. It's now going to be much harder to actually garner any form of trust when the basic idea is that no matter who I claim, town probably won't take it at face value.

Vote Doddsy to win.

vote Brutus

We're done here.