Round 1: Quadrant 3 Matchup 4

[The New F'n Show]

4. D-Lo Brown

vs 13.Shane McMahon

 

[Keith]

D-Lo Brown had a very strong midcard run, was really over with the fans, and I think had the talent to be a good world champion.

 

[AZUCAR!]

Shane

 

[Keith]

Don't talk shit! lol.

 

[Canadian Pothead]

I also went with D'Lo Brown, he had a great run with WWE and looked like a viable top heel when he had the chest pad.

 

[Smartmark]

Shane. Vince should have put the World Title on him for sure

 

[Heisenberg]

Both guys were good but I was a really big fan of Shane and some of the crazy bumps he took. Shame he's no longer with the WWE. So yeah, Shane O'Mac gets my vote!

 

[Troy]

D'Lo Brown was one of my favourites back in the day, was a solid European and Intercontinental champion so he gets my vote.

 

[Keith]

Shane was not even a proper wrestler, he was spot monkey who only wrestled full-time, yeah he was involved in some entertaining matches, but normally when he was being carried by a great talent.

 

[Chris]

Easily D'Lo for me, possibly the most underrated wrestler of all time.

Shane was probably the best non-wrestler in the ring though, had some amazing matches, despite not actually being a wrestler, but yeah, D'Lo gets this one.

 

[Slim]

Think about it though. Shane was NEVER a full time wrestler. Shane was not a fully trained professional wrestler and yet look at what he has done. Look at his memorable performances. Was he carried? Yeah but not completely. Then again what wrestlers aren't carried because it takes 2, or more, to have a match.

All of that Shane accomplished while not being a full time wrestler. He was a credible European champion, had an AWESOME match with Kurt Angle, and the list goes on. Just think... if Shane would HAVE BEEN a full time wrestler how much better he would have been, how polished he would have been. He would have been a success. He had the mic, he had the skills, he had the knowledge.

Not to take anything away from D'Lo but D'Lo was midcard for life. Upper midcard at the most. Shane could have been a world champion.

 

[The New F'n Show]

Agree with Slim's logic but I look at it frim the fact that Shane was always just going to be a special attraction. D'Lo for me, he was pretty entertaining in his heyday.

 

[Slim]

But that special attraction could put on some dang good matches.

plus... he's undefeated at WrestleMania

 

[PHX]

I liked Shane but was an actual wrestler and just mostly liked in ring wise for the crazy spots he has done. Went with D-Lo.

 

[Shaun]

I was a big D-Lo fan when I was younger, so I went with him.