Round 1: Quadrant 2 Matchup 4

[The New F'n Show]

Kevin Nash/Diesel

Bam Bam Bigelow

 

[Deuce]

Bam Bam Bigelow got a bigger reaction and was more entertaining as a Heel so he has my vote.

 

[PHX]

Bigger reaction? Did you not see the NWO?

Nash takes this one on his NWO run mostly the original one.

 

[The New F'n Show]

It's Nash for the NWO, also was pretty good as Diesel when he first debuted.

 

[John McHenry]

LOL Bam Bam Bigger reaction

Yeah Nash has this one in the bag times like 5 he should get pretty close to the end.

 

[Canadian Pothead]

Not very hard, went with Kevin Nash if just on his run in the New World Order, but I don't want my vote to discount Bam Bam Bigelow who I believe was an amazing heel and one of the best big man wrestlers in history.

 

[Kiffy Lube]

Just Nash's career proves he was a bigger heel than Bam Bam was but you could easily notch that up to politics which is something that I think should be a positive in this tournament anyways.

 

[Troy]

Nash was clearly the better heel out of these two. The heat that he and Hall got back when they started the NWO in WCW was insane.

 

[Keith]

Bigger reaction? Did you not see the NWO?

Nash takes this one on his NWO run mostly the original one.

But Nash was one member of the group that is the point. The reason the NWO were so successful IMO was more to do with how orignal the idea was, how it kept people on their toes from week to week, and because of the impact of Hogan's heel turn. Nash was just one part of the bigger picture, quite an effective part I'll grant you, but just one part none the less.

If you take most of his career as a heel (or face for that matter) he has just been bland, and has played one crap or dull character after the next.

Scott the reason Nash got over as Diesel was because Vince knew how to promote him, and because a lot of the time he had Shawn Michaels to play with.

Bigelow in the mould of Vader was an excellent killer heel, who cut exciting promos, had a fantastic look and delivered more often and not in the rind. Bam Bam, by a country mile.

 

[Chris Dresdon]

But Nash was one member of the group that is the point. The reason the NWO were so successful IMO was more to do with how orignal the idea was, how it kept people on their toes from week to week, and because of the impact of Hogan's heel turn. Nash was just one part of the bigger picture, quite an effective part I'll grant you, but just one part none the less.

If you take most of his career as a heel (or face for that matter) he has just been bland, and has played one crap or dull character after the next.

Scott the reason Nash got over as Diesel was because Vince knew how to promote him, and because a lot of the time he had Shawn Michaels to play with.

Bigelow in the mould of Vader was an excellent killer heel, who cut exciting promos, had a fantastic look and delivered more often and not in the rind. Bam Bam, by a country mile.

I'm going to go with Bam Bam as well, with the argument made by Keith as my justification. Bigelow wasn't as big a star as Nash, but that doesn't matter. Not to mention, and this is totally irrelevent to the "Greatest Heel" argument but Bigelow is part of one of the most memorable scenes in cinema, at least as far as my tastes go.

 

[The New F'n Show]

Nash moves on in a pretty close vote.