Round 1: Quadrant 1 Matchup 2

[The New F'n Show]

2. Eddie Guerrero- Frog Splash
[video=youtube;NS6slM9IYz4]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NS6slM9IYz4&list=UUCCtvN5wChXN19EjTFsgbnA&index=6[/video]

15. CM Punk- Pepsi Plunge
[video=youtube;Cz51K-c8Y8s]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Cz51K-c8Y8s[/video]

 

[Chris Dresdon]

I love the Frog Splash, but the Pepsi Plunge looks more effective even though it requires more to set-up for it and follow through with the execution.

 

[Captain Charisma]

Hard one actually because Eddie delivers frog splash so damn well that it put me in a short dilemma here. But I voted for Pepsi Plunge as it is harder to deliver that move with perfection. Punk delivered it well in all those years. Top rope moves are always risky. Pepsi Plunge.

Damn I voted on Frog Splash accidentaly

 

[Phenomenal One]

Pepsi Plunge looks really good but Punk didn't use this move nearly 7 years. And noone uses in scene,i already forgot it. But Frog Splash is more similiar and i think it's looks better than Plunge. My vote on Frog Splash.

 

[zigglerHEEL]

Eddie doesn't even have the best frog splash and it's not his best signature move (three amigos).... voted Pepsi Plunge but don't expect either to go very far in this

 

[Keith]

I actually loved how Eddie delivers the frog splash so I went with that.

 

[Chris]

Voted Frog Splash because I don't think the Pepsi Plunge looks realistic at all. One of those moves that requires too much set-up and help from the other guy that it's almost impossible to suspend belief.

 

[Dale]

Eddie doesn't even have the best frog splash and it's not his best signature move (three amigos).... voted Pepsi Plunge but don't expect either to go very far in this

Who does? I'm guessing you're going with RVD because I can only think of D'Lo outside of those two because Chavo's fucking sucks.

Voted Frogsplash, thought he executed it the best and I don't like the Pepsi Plunge for reasons Chris stated.

 

[zigglerHEEL]

Who does? I'm guessing you're going with RVD because I can only think of D'Lo outside of those two because Chavo's fucking sucks.

Voted Frogsplash, thought he executed it the best and I don't like the Pepsi Plunge for reasons Chris stated.

Yeah RVD's for sure, bigger air, harder impact and he sells the shit out of it.... for the record I'm a big fan of Eddie just can't vote for his frog splash when I feel there is one from the same era that is clearly better and I hear what you guys are saying about the Pepsi Plunge, don't think either move should go very far in this

 

[Troy]

Voted for Eddie's frogsplash even though I prefer RVD's, my only gripe with Eddie's is he doesn't sell any pain after hitting it whereas RVD actually plays off that it hurts him landing it. Pepsi Plunge is just too unrealistic even for wrestling.

 

[The New F'n Show]

Voted for the Frog Splash, Eddie had a great one, also fixed the wrong vote from before but it didn't matter. Eddie moves on.