ROMANVM HISTORIVM: A Roman History Mafia Game Thread

[Odo]

If I'm active now, and the whole reason for wanting to lynch me and Doddsy was inactivity, what's the reason we even need solving?

I don't mind being solved ftr so if there is a genuine reason for it then go ahead.

I'd like more people to answer the question I posed a while back about whether I'm beneficial or not town in the late game because this is actually game-related.

Nah, bigger problem is your entrance. Your inactivity compounds that

I don’t see why you want soneone to tell you if you’re shit or not. Make that decision yourself

 

[Ace]

Nah, bigger problem is your entrance. Your inactivity compounds that

I don’t see why you want soneone to tell you if you’re shit or not. Make that decision yourself

What specifically was wrong with my entrance though?

Like, do you actually look at my early vote and think that it is what I would do as scum?

That's just not my scum meta at all and I'm actually surprised you would think otherwise.

 

[Odo]

What specifically was wrong with my entrance though?

Like, do you actually look at my early vote and think that it is what I would do as scum?

That's just not my scum meta at all and I'm actually surprised you would think otherwise.

considering I took you out in 2 posts last time I played, I think it’s asinine to suggest that you can only be scum if you fall into the same pattern

I think it’s fine to consider you as scum until you provide compelling reasons not to. Do you have some up to date reads we could possibly discuss?

 

[Odo]

Sorry, 3 posts*

 

[Odo]

@Grimus Augustus when you get chance, could you update your op pls

 

[Alco]

What specifically was wrong with my entrance though?

Like, do you actually look at my early vote and think that it is what I would do as scum?

That's just not my scum meta at all and I'm actually surprised you would think otherwise.

That's purely a WIFOM defense though.

 

[Odo]

Incidentally, what are your thoughts on Blaine now?

 

[Ace]

considering I took you out in 2 posts last time I played, I think it’s asinine to suggest that you can only be scum if you fall into the same pattern

I think it’s fine to consider you as scum until you provide compelling reasons not to. Do you have some up to date reads we could possibly discuss?

The difference is in the other game I'd actually made proper posts as opposed to a vote without comment and a "because ur scum lol" type post.

In terms of reads I don't have many, I think there are definitely still question marks around CP given the duelist/daykill combo.

That's purely a WIFOM defense though.

It is. But that's precisely the point; I don't think there's much to be got either way from it as it was so limited in terms of what it is.

Incidentally, what are your thoughts on Blaine now?

Probably town if i remember something he posted hinted at something but i cant remember what and ive got a meeting now

brb

 

[Odo]

Wang, Alco, Lethal make up the solid town reads I have, with Magic and Mitch almost definitely being non mafia at a minimum

I think Blaine is likely town but he’s been coasting

which leaves a murky pool of Doddsy, flay, Peter, junk, CP and Ace. Obviously CP and junk have some nominal reasons to consider them town, and if we take Doddsys actual play, what little of it there is, then he falls into that too

 

[Alco]

Yea I don't think CP is scum from what I've seen.

 

[Alco]

Flay almost looks like an entirely different person lol as opposed to previous games

 

[Alco]

Like for Flay there's a bunch of questions with no follow-up, hardly any read to speak of and then a bunch of nothing.

 

[Ace]

I think its fair to read Flay scum tbh.

@Odo ito your poe list i'd have alco too and maybe remove doddsy to slight town leans, I'd also have junk as a scum lean rather than poe as he does seem to be slipping into his "try-too-hard-as-scum" meta.

 

[Odo]

I think its fair to read Flay scum tbh.

@Odo ito your poe list i'd have alco too and maybe remove doddsy to slight town leans, I'd also have junk as a scum lean rather than poe as he does seem to be slipping into his "try-too-hard-as-scum" meta.

Alco is town

 

[Odo]

I have the utmost confidence that our Vig knows what to do here tho, all things considered