Payback 2015
Match 1: Sheamus def. Dolph Ziggler (12:20)
An underrated gem from a pretty forgettable PPV. Sheamus pie faces Dolph and that just about sends Dolph into a frantic rage as he rushes Sheamus early. Dolph seems to have hurt Sheamus’ leg, after a clothesline to the outside. But Sheamus catches Dolph’s foot on a superkick attempt and then starts to dominate the match. Not much else interesting until Dolph starts to come back into the match. He gets Sheamus in the corner, and drives him down with knees, forcing Sheamus to sit in the corner. And as “payback” (haha) for what Sheamus did to him at Extreme Rules, Dolph pulls up his trunks and pretty much stinkfaces Sheamus. Sheamus loses his mind on the outside before he runs back inside, now pissed off. After hot shotting Dolph on the top rope, Sheamus bounces off them and goes for the Brogue Kick, Dolph ducks and then hits a Fameasser. Sheamus kicks out of that. Sheamus takes control of the match back after a powerbomb and then starts hitting the classics on him. He puts him in a Texas Cloverleaf, but Dolph manages to reach the ropes. Sheamus slaps Dolph and grabs him by the face. Dolph responds with a fucking nasty headbutt! Dolph superkicks Sheamus and as he covers him, we see Dolph is busted open. And busted open for real. That headbutt fucked him up. Sheamus kicks out and gets up first, Dolph is clearly weary off the headbutt and Sheamus finishes him with a Brogue Kick.
My Rating: ***1/2
Match 2: WWE Tag Team Championship 2 Out of 3 Falls Match - The New Day (Kofi & Big E.) (c) def. Cesaro & Tyson Kidd (12:40)
A really fun match, I really enjoyed it. The only thing I don’t like is that its a 12 minute 2 Out of 3 Falls Match. Why bother making it 2 out of 3 Falls if that’s all the time you give it? Other than that, really good match. The first fall is over in 2 minutes and Cesaro and Kidd just have fun with New Day in that time. Cesaro lifts Kofi up for a suplex and Tyson comes off the top rope with a crossbody. Big E.breaks up the pin, but Cesaro clotheslines him out of the way and swings Kofi around into a kick from Tyson. Tyson pins Kofi 1, 2, 3 to win the first fall. Xavier then gets on the apron and tries to claim “freebird rule.” Natalya goes over to pull Woods down. Tyson takes X out. Big E. goes for the Spear off the apron, but Tyson flips into the ring and lariets Kofi. Tyson suicide dives on Big E. but E. catches him and throws him over his head. The second fall is over soon enough. Kofi goes to throw Cesaro out of the ring, but Cesaro flips onto his feet on the apron, big boots Kofi, only for Big E. to take him out with the Spear off the apron. Tyson tries to make a brief comeback, he dropkicks Kofi out of the air. But Big E. catches him, and they drop Tyson with the Midnight Hour to win the second match. And this third fall is so fucking good. Tyson reaches Cesaro, who comes in like a house of fire. He uppercuts Kofi several times before pressing him over his head and throwing him into Big E. Then Cesaro takes a run at Kofi and uppercuts him so hard, it sends Kofi into the corner, the back of his head hitting the turnbuckle. Kofi leaps off the top rope and gets caught by Cesaro and takes a back breaker. For Tyson to come in and drop an elbow off Cesaro’s knee. Tyson then puts Kofi in the Sharpshooter, but Big E. saves it. Cesaro takes E. outside and tosses him over the announce table. Kidd launches Kofi into the air, and Cesaro uppercuts him on the drop. Cesaro covers Kofi, but Big E. stops the 3 count. Kofi winds up outside and as the referee is trying to get E. out, Xavier rolls in, rolls up Cesaro in a small package, the referee doesn’t even realize its Woods and not Kofi and counts the pinfall. New Day retain.
My Rating: ***3/4
Match 3: Bray Wyatt def. Ryback (10:54)
You wouldn’t expect a whole lot from this pairing, but this match turned out alright. A short lived feud which was done to give them something to do I think. Ryback has the upper hand early, using his power to muscle around Bray and knock him to the floor. But Bray takes control after Ryback rams his own shoulder into the ring post after Bray dodges. Bray plants Ryback’s face on the apron before he climbs back up and drops over Ryback with a senton. From that point on, it becomes a point that Ryback’s ribs are hurting, which will become his downfall. Bray shows some strength of his own here by lifting Ryback for a suplex, but then just tosses him across the ring. Ryback eventually starts to come back and the match is pretty even. Ryback leaps off the top rope with a splash which I don’t think anyone expected and then goes to his ribs. Ryback lifts Bray on his shoulders for the Shell Shock, but Bray grabs the top rope and in the struggle, the top turnbuckle pad gets flung off. As the referee goes to grab it, Bray shoves Ryback, into the exposed turnbuckle, ribs first and Bray wins the match after a Sister Abigail.
My Rating: ***1/4
Match 4: United States Championship I Quit Match - John Cena (c) def. Rusev (27:58)
This show seems pretty mixed as far as how people feel about it. This match has a pretty low rating on Cagematch, but I’ve also seen reviews that rate this at 4 stars. So I wasn’t sure what to expect. This match should be called “Do You Quit” Match. Because every 30 seconds, after everything they did in this match. Even the smallest shit that’s never beat anybody, they’re like “ask him!” And the referee would go “Do you quit.” And of course, for 28 minutes, the answer would be no every time. It honestly got annoying. Rusev tells Cena to quit before they even do anything. Honestly, it would’ve been hilarious if Cena had been like “Yeah, okay, I quit.” Rusev beats on Cena for a bit, before he brings in the steel steps and props them up in the corner. He whips Cena into them twice. Then he lays them on the mat and hits a tilt-a-whirl slam onto them. Rusev tries to do the Accolade on the steps, but Cena moves and AAs Rusev on the steps. The first big offense Cena’s had the match. Cena and Rusev go outside. Cena stands Rusev up against the barricade and literally tells Rusev what he’s about to do if he doesn’t say I quit. Rusev says no and then Cena Spears him through the barricade. Rusev definitely had time to move, but he didn’t feel like it I guess. They fight out into the crowd and wind up back on the entrance way. Rusev sees the pyrotechnics behind a small set up part of the set design. Cena AAs him behind it and then the pyrotechnics go off. We can’t see behind it, trying to give us the illusion Rusev was burnt by pyro. Except I’m almost definitely sure there is no magic button over there to make them go off and if there is, that’s incredibly unsafe. Dumb spot. Cena grabs a metal barrier, he hits Rusev with it and props it against the apron. But Rusev grabs Cena and suplexes him onto the barrier, bending it in half. That was pretty cool at least. Rusev throws Cena back in the ring and puts the Accolade on him until Cena passes out. While Cena is out, Rusev unscrews the turnbuckle from the ring post. Now, Bret Hart was declared the winner of the Submission Match he had with Austin because passed out and couldn’t continue. Austin never tapped out, which was the stipulation of the match. Well Cena is passed out here, he doesn’t move in like 3 minutes. What I’m getting at people, is that Rusev was robbed. Rusev wakes Cena up with a bottle of water, which he didn’t really need to do, I’m pretty sure whatever he was planning to do with that turnbuckle would’ve done the trick. Cena drops Rusev to the mat, and uses pulls the ring rope over Rusev’s face as he applies the STF. Rusev starts screaming in bulgarian, Lana actually has to get in the ring and take the mic herself to say “he quits.” I was unaware that somebody else was able to quit for you. Yeah, I don’t like this match. It’s not DUD territory bad, but this was pretty damn lame if you ask me.
My Rating: **
Match 5: Naomi & Tamina def. The Bella Twins (6:13)
So after a 28 minute Do You Wanna Quit match, I get to watch the Bella Twins. WWE were really attempting to turn the Bella Twins into babyfaces here. You had Naomi and Tamina working heel. Here’s the issue with that idea. We didn’t like the Bella Twins. You have Brie botching like hell while Naomi and Tamina keep her away from Nikki. Jerry Lawler, at some point during the match says “Who doesn’t like Nikki Bella?” The only thing stopping Nikki from being the Roman Reigns of the women’s division at that point was that WWE turned her heel again shortly after this, and stopped trying to get her over. Naomi backdrops Brie behind her, Brie lands on her head ‘cause she’s bad, she makes the cold tag to Nikki. Nikki starts to bring the match back for her team, but after a distraction from Tamina, Nikki gets hit with the ‘she calls that the rear view’. But kicks out of her finisher in this 6 minute match. Tamina throws Brie into the barricade, so she’s not a factor for when Nikki is on the top rope and Naomi throws her off. Naomi covers Nikki to take the win.
My Rating: *1/2
Match 6: Neville def. King Barrett via countout (7:22)
This match sucks too honestly. And that sucks because it shouldn’t. These two just didn’t click I guess. But it’s super not interesting. Neville hardly gets to do any of his big high flying moves. After a brief good start for Neville, Barrett takes control and starts beating on Neville. But Neville starts to come back after flipping on his feet off a back drop. Hilariously, Neville gets Barrett on the mat, and then flips, that’s it. He doesn’t move. It’s supposed to be a standing shooting star, but Neville flips in place. Barrett puts his elbow pad inside out to set up the Bullhammer. He tells Neville to get up. Neville dodges it and he gets Barrett back on the mat, then goes up for the Red Arrow. But Barrett rolls out of the ring, and Neville dives on him from the inside. Neville gets back in, but Barrett doesn’t and gets himself counted out. Oh, okay. So this match is completely pointless, nobody gets any points, or any momentum I guess. But Barrett just comes back in while Neville isn’t looking and attacks him. He puts on his cape, holds up his sceptor. Neville gets back in the ring, and Barrett takes a swing at him, but Neville ducks and switches behind him, to hit a German Suplex, and then he goes up and hits the Red Arrow. What an absolutely pointless endeavor this was.
My Rating: **
Main Event: WWE World Heavyweight Championship Fatal 4-Way Match - Seth Rollins (c) def. Roman Reigns, Dean Ambrose & Randy Orton (20:52)
But at least the main event delivered. You have Orton and the Shield. Talk about a 4th wheel honestly. But hey, it leads to a pretty good spot halfway through. The other stipulation for this match is that if Seth Rollins loses, Kane loses his job as director of operations for the Authority. Kane is at ringside for this match, Jamie Noble and Joey Mercury come to the ring with Rollins. Noble and Mercury pull Roman and Dean out right at the beginning of the match, that goes as well as you could expect for them. Rollins and Orton go outside which leads to Ambrose diving onto them through the middle rope. And then Roman dives on literally everyone but Kane. Rollins winds up getting ganged up on by Ambrose and Roman. They just take turns taking shots at them. Roman sets up a superman punch, but Kane pulls Roman out of the ring. Rollins and Ambrose go at it for a bit, and as Dean goes for the Dirty Deeds, Kane comes in and Chokeslams Dean. Dean kicks out and Kane tries to yell at the referee, but Orton yanks him off the apron, followed by a driveby from Reigns. Orton clotheslines Roman on the outside and goes back in and goes at it with Seth. Orton hits a nice superplex on Seth in the ring. They wind up outside and Orton soon finds Roman and Dean coming up to fight him, together, along with Rollins, they stomp Orton into the floor before breaking. They look at each other… they look at Orton… Rollins points at the table beside him and then they gang up on Orton again. The crowd starts to lose their minds because like old times, they’re working together again. Seth and Dean pick Orton up, stack him on Roman’s shoulders and then they throw him through the table! The crowd fucking loses their minds! Seth seems to forget that they’re not bros anymore and sticks his fist out between Dean and Roman, waiting for them to do the same. Dean and Roman laugh with him. The switch on Dean’s face is kind of funny. The way he goes from laughing to stoic is super quick. Roman’s not smiling anymore either, and now they start whooping Seth’s ass. They tear apart the other announce table, going to powerbomb him through that one. But Kane saves his ass. They lay Kane out, and Seth out on the table. They pick Kane up and powerbomb him over Seth laying on the table. But it doesn’t break. So the crowd starts to chant “one more time! One more time!” Dean and Roman give them what they want! They pick Kane back up and drop over Seth again, and this time, the table breaks. It just leaves us with Dean and Roman. It will never not bother me that we never got a feud between these two. The few times they got to fight each other, they showed incredible chemistry. They just have a sweet mini-match between themselves while everyone is out. The crowd is chanting “Ambrose.” They were firmly behind this man. Roman makes an attempt at a Spear, but Dean gets his foot up, and tries the Dirty Deeds. Roman escapes and knocks Dean back. Dean tries to rebound and clothesline, but Roman ducks and hits a Spear. Roman covers him and Rollins runs in to stop the 3 count. The 3 Shield members go at it. Roman is knocked down by Ambrose. He drops Seth with a Dirty Deeds, but Kane pulls Dean out of the ring and takes him out of the match with the steel steps. Roman tries to attack Kane, but he gets Chokeslammed on the bottom half of the steps. But Orton finally comes back and takes Kane down before he gets back in the ring to fight with Rollins. Noble and Mercury attempt to help, but they each get an RKO for that. Rollins gets caught in a powerslam in mid-air. Orton brings him to the ropes and hits a draping DDT. And then Orton sets Seth up for the RKO. Seth pushes him off as Kane comes back in, but Orton was ready and drops Kane with the RKO. Seth kicks Orton in the gut and hits him with a Pedigree for the 3 count. The first time Seth used the Pedigree if I’m not mistaken. Great main event. Lots of fun to watch.
My Rating: ****
Cagematch Rating: 6.36
My Rating: 6/10
This show got off to a pretty good start. I thought the first 3 matches on the show were really good, even if none of them were particularly mind blowing. But then it takes a drastic drop at the I Quit Match. The next couple matches really don’t help it’s cause either. But the main event was a damn great match that ended the show on a high. Overall, a forgettable show.