Prey At Night: The Strangers Mafia Game Thread

[Evans]

You wanna parrott sky lol. It was almost entirely feel and process of elimination

I'm not parroting Sky but we play mafia here by explaining our reads and reasonings. I understand you play via clearing mechanically but you must have reasonings from the small amount of game you read to allocate scum reads specifically to Lethal, myself and Sky at the time?

Because mechanically, Blaine isn't cleared as town at all and there must be a reason why you trust him to believe him in this situation.

 

[Poyser]

Yes, but it wasn't established at the time mate. Fuck, why is that so hard to understand? Either he was vigged or he was killed by serial killer. We now know it was a vig meant for you, so that cleared that up.

My god.

It was never an extra kill though? Vig is pretty standard mate

 

[Bobby Barrows]

It was never an extra kill though? Vig is pretty standard mate

Well I'm glad you were able to divinate the game's setup before me.

Fuck me, I guess.

 

[CakeWalker]

Hopefully someone gets some results tonight, that are helpful.

 

[Poyser]

OMB flipping town has thrown me a little bit, so I’m gonna have to readjust a few things. I’m still fairly sure Blaine and cake are legit, and I don’t at all see why Evans would randomly out him jailkeeping me after the hammer as some kind of scum plot lol, so I’d say he’s probably town as well. Lethal pretty much has to be either vig or SK, other than a random chance scum have an extra night kill but that seems unlikely. Ratchet almost certainly survivor. Leaves

Barry
Sky
Polar Bear

Either way tomorrow is more than likely lylo so don’t be rushing anything. We should mass claim as well

 

[Poyser]

Obv if I’m wrong on any of them, then it’s Evans as that’s the weakest town read

Barry and Sky seem pretty nailed on to me. Not sure I can see a world where they’re not scum

 

[TOP GUY TIME]

OMB flipping town has thrown me a little bit, so I’m gonna have to readjust a few things. I’m still fairly sure Blaine and cake are legit, and I don’t at all see why Evans would randomly out him jailkeeping me after the hammer as some kind of scum plot lol, so I’d say he’s probably town as well. Lethal pretty much has to be either vig or SK, other than a random chance scum have an extra night kill but that seems unlikely. Ratchet almost certainly survivor. Leaves

Barry
Sky
Polar Bear

Either way tomorrow is more than likely lylo so don’t be rushing anything. We should mass claim as well

No kills can happen tonight i believe so i don't think we are in LYLO just yet

 

[Poyser]

No kills can happen tonight i believe so i don't think we are in LYLO just yet

At 9 alive it’s more than likely 5/3/1. Might not technically be lylo but it is when you consider that the survivor would side with scum at 3/3/1. And for all we know there could be an SK as well in which case we are probably just fucked unless the scum team is only 2 man but I doubt that too

 

[CakeWalker]

Lynch wrong tomorrow, ratchet will side with Mafia.

 

[Polar Bear]

I'm not parroting Sky but we play mafia here by explaining our reads and reasonings. I understand you play via clearing mechanically but you must have reasonings from the small amount of game you read to allocate scum reads specifically to Lethal, myself and Sky at the time?

Because mechanically, Blaine isn't cleared as town at all and there must be a reason why you trust him to believe him in this situation.

I've already explained this. It's about feel, reads, instinct, and mechanics

Blaine posts out of night feel genuine and natural for someone who has results (not faking them). Thus I believe Blaine, so Blaine and his results go in the town column with me

10 alive, me, Blaine, and cake in the town column, leave 7

You guys said pendex was indy survivor so that leaves 6

I've already explained sky so that puts sky in the bad guy column

That leaves 5

I like Noirs post so I put them in neutral, that leave 4

And so on until you have the reads list

 

[Polar Bear]

At this current moment lethal claim jives so he goes in the town column. That literally leaves 4.

3 scum out of the 4.

 

[TOP GUY TIME]

At this current moment lethal claim jives so he goes in the town column. That literally leaves 4.

3 scum out of the 4.

In this case, who would you want to lynch first?

 

[Sky]

I've already explained this. It's about feel, reads, instinct, and mechanics

Blaine posts out of night feel genuine and natural for someone who has results (not faking them). Thus I believe Blaine, so Blaine and his results go in the town column with me

10 alive, me, Blaine, and cake in the town column, leave 7

You guys said pendex was indy survivor so that leaves 6

I've already explained sky so that puts sky in the bad guy column

That leaves 5

I like Noirs post so I put them in neutral, that leave 4

And so on until you have the reads list

That still doesn't explain anything. In Mafia you can't just make up random shit until you get a mechanical result, that's not how it works

 

[Pendex]

Lynch wrong tomorrow, ratchet will side with Mafia.

To be honest, I won't side with anyone unless it's clear that the game is over. I'm quite happy just abstaining my vote if that's preferred.

 

[Evans]

I've already explained this. It's about feel, reads, instinct, and mechanics

Blaine posts out of night feel genuine and natural for someone who has results (not faking them). Thus I believe Blaine, so Blaine and his results go in the town column with me

10 alive, me, Blaine, and cake in the town column, leave 7

You guys said pendex was indy survivor so that leaves 6

I've already explained sky so that puts sky in the bad guy column

That leaves 5

I like Noirs post so I put them in neutral, that leave 4

And so on until you have the reads list

Yeah but I’m asking what you feel and why.

out of those 4, gun to head - who’s scum and who’s the town? And why?