The reason I asked this question is because I believe Impact has become a clusterfuck show and by looking at the quarter hour ratings both divisions draw some of the lowest ratings except The Beautiful People and Angelina Love.
Basically I believe TNA needs to make some massive roster cuts and at the same time they should make the cuts based on the ratings and charisma/mic skills.
I think they should get rid of both divisions and everyone in them except The Beautiful People, Angelina Love, Daffney (make them valets), Motor City Machine Guns, Shannon Moore, Kazarian (make Moore and Kazarian a tag team).
Then look at the remaining roster and cut guys with no charisma/mic skills like Rob Terry, Hernandez, Magnus, Orlando Jordan.
Then cut the older guys that never drew big ratings like Tomko, Rhino, Stevie, Raven.
You end up with a roster full of charisma/mic skills and ratings producers.
This is what I would do if I was in charge:
Obviously nobody would be exclusively stuck in the division I have them in, except the champs, members of tag teams would compete in the North American title picture sometimes, singles guys would tag team with someone occasionally, guys listed in the North American title picture would compete in the World title picture occasionally especially when it comes to when the World title holder is a face, heels in the North American title picture would compete for the World title and vice versa.
Obviously mix things up.
Authority figure Eric Bishoff
Flair doing what he’s doing now, hanging with Styles, Wolfe, Beer Money
The World Title:
Mr. Anderson
Sting
RVD
Jeff Hardy
Kurt Angle
The North American Title: Mid Card (Currently named Global Title)
Desmond Wolfe valet Chelsea Mid Card Champ as soon as possible, after a long run with the title he moves to the World title picture.
Matt Morgan valet Lacey Von Erich Next in line for Wolfe’s path above.
Pope Transitional champ between Wolfe and Morgan, after Morgan’s Run, Pope becomes the cream of the crop among mid carders holding the title many times.
AJ Styles
Jeff Jarrett (after Wolfe and Morgan graduate from the division and move to the world title picture, I'd turn Jarrett heel, which he's best at, and have him and Pope feud for the title with the title changing hands many times, I would drag this feud on for a long time)
Abyss
Samoa Joe (wrestling with clothes on)
The Tag Team Title:
Hall and Nash and Young (The Band) manager Hogan (yes, heel Hogan only involved with The Band’s business, nothing else. The Band would have a problem with everyone including other heels and they would act like God's gift to wrestling.)
Beer Money valet Sky
Team 3D
Motor City Machine Guns valet Love
Moore and Kaz valet Daffney
If Daniels returns (there are rumors), pair him with Moore and move Kaz to the North American title picture, and if so keep Rayne and make her Kaz valet.
No Knockouts division and no X-division.
Once every couple months there would be a grudge match among the female valets on a pay per view and there would be a storyline involved leading up to the pay per view with the females talking shit about each other and confronting each other outside the ring while a match is taking place involving their guys.
Nobody would be allowed to sign/join TNA that does not have charisma/mic skills unless it’s one of those rare guys that is a top of the line established star similar to what Brett Hart once was.
I'd bring back Foley and have him in a similar role as Flair, hanging with 3 or 4 babyfaces in the North American picture/tag team picture.
Not necessarily a stable, just like Flair's guys aren't technically a stable.
If you haven't noticed I'd use the valets for guys who need a boost in the ratings, or another words guys who still need to get "over" with the people who count, the ratings(not the Impact zone).
Once they are "over" in the ratings, if TNA has signed anyone that is not an established star I'd move that valet over to the new guy, and yes the new guy would have to have charisma/mic skills to get into TNA as I already addressed above.
Once a year at the biggest pay per view of the year I'd have Foley, Flair, Hogan wrestle.