Peaky Blinders Mafia - Game Thread

[Tweet]

Even moreso if night isn't skipped but instead the kills are just blocked.

 

[Odo]

so you think he legit thought he could away with wagoning Brad?

I never got a chance to finish the whole thread but Doddsy is the only one who has stuck out as suspicous to me from what i've read. im not really buying his suspicion on tweet.

in this post he implies he doesn't believe tweet intentionally voted brad and is reading him scum for it, but later



he says he's not saying tweet voted because he legit bought into the wagon and is now citing different reasoning. this seems a bit contradictory to me? if he didn't buy into the wagon then how can he unintentionally 'bite that bait'? doesn't really make sense, it seems like he found more solid reasoning after further questoning and is now using that instead (which it is more solid).

also if tweet is scum and knows the wagon is 'bait' wouldn't it make more sense for him not to get on knowing he risks suspicion as opposed to if he's town where he wouldn't care as much?

Vote Doodsy

so no comments on it

yeah, I’m not really sold on any of this, I don’t believe these are the best thoughts you could distil from the game so far.

the issue scum have early game is that they have to do something, especially if they have a reputation for activity as town, which tweet does. So the question, if tweet were scum and magic were town is ‘how do I as a scum player manage a strong player demanding I do something’ - in that case, I could easily see tweet thinking it was safer to limp on, especially if he hedged his bets by saying he knew it was ‘bait’

 

[Odo]

I just unvoted, I don't think this lynch is gonna hit scum.

you wont get any credit for this regardless of chimps flip, just FYI

 

[Doddsy]

We know that but what's your role?

Claim doesn’t really do anything for me, but i could easily see it being the Shelbys sister, the one fucking the commie at the start of the series tbh

That doesn't sound much like a virgin to me....


Unvote Vote Chimp

Been saying all day he's scummy, I'd rather a flip than not

 

[Tweet]

you wont get any credit for this regardless of chimps flip, just FYI

Gotta be honest, I don't think I give a fuck.

 

[PHEN0M]

For some reason i thought beloved princess with regards to role mechanics than virgin. That’s my fault.

unvote

 

[PHEN0M]

How much time do we have? That’s obviously something we want to keep around if he’s truthful. I don’t know if i want to lynch now. Which means he’s bluffing and is the janitor or some shit.

 

[Doddsy]

We have like an hour

 

[Laughable Chimp]

For some reason i thought beloved princess with regards to role mechanics than virgin. That’s my fault.

unvote

That still doesn't make sense. There is almost no scenarip where scum will willingly choose to shoot a beloved princess which skips night for some reason. And you did at least undertand my role skipped night.

 

[PHEN0M]

Beloved princess if shot at night skips the next day phase.

 

[PHEN0M]

Going to the next night phase so scum can kill again.

 

[Laughable Chimp]

And why are you unvoting? You can't tell me that was enough to no longer be willing to lynch me. Especially considering you listed other reasons to go after me as well.

 

[PHEN0M]

Is where my head went

 

[Rugrat]

How much time do we have? That’s obviously something we want to keep around if he’s truthful. I don’t know if i want to lynch now. Which means he’s bluffing and is the janitor or some shit.

The scum team aren't night killing Chimp, so even if legit it's not a role which would have huge benefit

 

[PHEN0M]

And why are you unvoting? You can't tell me that was enough to no longer be willing to lynch me. Especially considering you listed other reasons to go after me as well.

Well fuck me for reconsidering. Why would i want to keep someone alive who has a role that can hurt scum and make them have to maneuver accordingly, you’re right.