Peaky Blinders Mafia - Game Thread

[Smart Marx]

Having a provable role early prevents him from worrying about mass claim later as well.

 

[CraigPelton]

Why would he have announced it at all as scum? It would cause more confusion if he didn't, which is the point of scum.

To look town.

But I don't think Odo is scum. I'm just saying that's quite the assumption by Magic, that he HAD to announce the daykill. If he's scum with a daykill and doesn't have to announce it, but he's obviously planning on claiming a town dayvig, he's going to announce the kill in the thread.

 

[Grimoire Lenin]

If he's scum, because most people will assume he's town as they are currently doing.

That just doesn't seem like a very cash money thing to do. He'd be read town anyways because he's been actively pushing for people on D1.

 

[Smart Marx]

That just doesn't seem like a very cash money thing to do. He'd be read town anyways because he's been actively pushing for people on D1.

Then also read my next post.

 

[CraigPelton]

Like I find it odd Magic would give a strong player like Odo a town read over a completely unfounded assumption. He's usually a lot more careful with stronger players.

 

[CraigPelton]

Yeah Barry is being his usual arrogantly obtuse self lol

 

[Smart Marx]

To look town.

But I don't think Odo is scum. I'm just saying that's quite the assumption by Magic, that he HAD to announce the daykill. If he's scum with a daykill and doesn't have to announce it, but he's obviously planning on claiming a town dayvig, he's going to announce the kill in the thread.

This, pretty much. Odo could have done it to look town, but I don't think he's scum either.

 

[Grimoire Lenin]

Magic telling me to scumhunt when I can't scumhunt for shit is

I'm much more content to look for town players and work off POE from there.

 

[Grimoire Lenin]

Yeah Barry is being his usual arrogantly obtuse self lol

I prefer the term acute.

 

[CraigPelton]

I'm gonna stay on Chimp. Not a fan of his OMGUS or people not even acknowledging my vote on him or my calling for more votes. Feels like he might be trying to capitalize on Sky and Barry's lack of ability to detect irony as well by making it seem like there's a wagon of substance on me when there really isn't at all.

I also feel good about Tweet and PHEN0M who have both also voted Chimp.

 

[CraigPelton]

I liked Big Man's post on Doddsy initially but I'm a little disappointed that that's literally all he has commented on. Doddsy is a player who is easy to make look like scum when he's town. That's why I tend to keep him around and in my POE whenever I'm scum.

 

[Rugrat]

@TheRedPrince i asked you a question

 

[CraigPelton]

I'm sure I asked this before, but why do you think Chimp would be more flippant with his role as mafia. As SK he was much more covert trying to draw less attention, so wouldn't he be less worried as drawing this kinda attention as town?

Personally, I think it's null and he'll play obnoxiously as either town or mafia because that's what he does, but it'd make more sense if he was town than mafia.

Nah I think he plays into his meta more as scum rather than trying to vote the right people. I think he was playing his town game last game.

 

[Doddsy]

I liked Big Man's post on Doddsy initially but I'm a little disappointed that that's literally all he has commented on. Doddsy is a player who is easy to make look like scum when he's town. That's why I tend to keep him around and in my POE whenever I'm scum.

It's so true it hurts

 

[Showtime]

Are you calling CP town then?

no, but that isn't a line of reasoning against him at all.