Norse Mythology Mafia - Game Thread

[Doddsy]

Hey Gambit how's that scum rep in treating you?

 

[Doddsy]

Might be worth a mass then, as the BG may well have just been Alco guarding someone

 

[Ace]

I mean that could have made Xenus' claim much easier to decide on

Haha fuck. Forgot that Xenus claimed Seraph :

Hey Gambit how's that scum rep in treating you?

Is this based off something?

 

[Ace]

Might be worth a mass then, as the BG may well have just been Alco guarding someone

Prolly best to wait for daytime, no?

 

[Doddsy]

Me being sus on Big Man already

 

[Doddsy]

Prolly best to wait for daytime, no?

Oh shit I forgot we got day skipped

 

[Ace]

Oh shit I forgot we got day skipped

lol.

Also I thought you might have had actual info, rip.

I know you've said earlier that EV and Grim didn't look good off of the quick lynch (I disagree btw, don't think they make such an aggressive play as scum as it seems unnecessary).

What other reads do you have?

 

[Doddsy]

1. Ace
2. Evans
3. CP
5. Jeff
6. Lethal
7. Barry
8. Tweet
9. Smark
12. OMB
16. Doddsy
19. Big Man
21. Brutus



Beyond Reproach:
Smark
Brutus

Likely Town:
Lethal
OMB
Ace

Mid(gard):
CP (really wish you'd healed Rugrat so you can prove you still have the role, should be clearable with reviver flip)
Evans (Double Vote Hammer could be an either way role. Sus on quick Magic hammer/scum motivated to kill him without speaking i.e. offer to hunt scum, known indy, plenty of time left to allow for him to say something)
Tweet (honestly not sure. Hell, might be the indy and has a seperate win condition to encourage him augmenting both sides. Hel specced as the other indy, maybe he's just looking to make more deaths from conditions like poison which net them a hel soul)

Them Sus Bois:
Barry (don't think he's claimed yet, sus on Magic's quick hammer. If is scum, likely so with Evans)
Jeff (Stated many a time. Still not super confident with the claim, especially considering the numerous investigative we have already)
Big Man (general play I've not liked much. Did push Xenus early which is a + in his favour, but sussing a team mate is pretty common so not enough to shake me entirely

 

[Doddsy]

Also something I want to be thought of towards endgame:

Everyone is assuming bussing will be very unlikely due to the stipulation of not being able to win it lynched.

Would be very clever to sacrifice someone in order to get that strong of a town move

 

[Ace]

Interesting.

Not sure if I'm being silly and forgetting something but is the Brutus read purely on play?
Can't say I agree with you on Evans/Barry either - I certainly don't see them both fast-lynching as scum.

I can give you most of your other reads although I'm not clear at all on where I stand personally on a bunch of them given shenanigans (Jeff, Tweet) and also just trying to read them (Big Man, OMB)

 

[Doddsy]

Interesting.

Not sure if I'm being silly and forgetting something but is the Brutus read purely on play?
Can't say I agree with you on Evans/Barry either - I certainly don't see them both fast-lynching as scum.

I can give you most of your other reads although I'm not clear at all on where I stand personally on a bunch of them given shenanigans (Jeff, Tweet) and also just trying to read them (Big Man, OMB)

I have reason to believe Brutus is town but not gonna elaborate unless required.

 

[Ace]

I have reason to believe Brutus is town but not gonna elaborate unless required.

You make a good point about bussing - aggressive bussing is not an early-game play but we're nearing a point (if we haven't reached it already) where scum will need to get involved in appropriate wagons on their mates or stick out like a sore thumb.

 

[Roy Mustang]

Hey bitches will need to catch up but CP is 100% town. No problem claiming during day either

Sent from my SM-A202F using Tapatalk

 

[Roy Mustang]

Someone fill me on why we didn't lynch jeff. I see we made a good lynch on magic though (him being indy made sense) so not complaining

Sent from my SM-A202F using Tapatalk

 

[Ace]

Someone fill me on why we didn't lynch jeff. I see we made a good lynch on magic though (him being indy made sense) so not complaining

Sent from my SM-A202F using Tapatalk

Basically the belief that he was possibly redirected cos blatantly faking a report on Chloe seems unnecessary and counter-intuitive in a game with the Hel/Valhalla mechanic.

Magic was widely read as playing an indie game and setup spec indicated he could likely be an arsonist which would mean that he could be more threatening than scum if he wasn't lynched immediately.