Norse Mythology Mafia - Game Thread

[Smart Marx]

I'm going by the assumption that Sutr is also in the game as you guys have discussed. my shot is only for Hel. so im saying in theory, if I shoot my shot and hit the other indy, id still get a negative result.

OHHHHHH

Then yeah, it wouldn't help if Magic is the arsonist then.

 

[Alco]

Which one of the above options would you pick?

Looks like both leave us potentially in a pickle

If Magic's inactive, chances are very low he's the scum leader I reckon? If the consensus is that there's more chance of getting rid of a mafia, I would go for that option. Ie Jeff in your scenario.

 

[Ace]

If he's indy, Jeff would have to cop him and do you trust Jeff to do that?

Yep that's true tbf.

 

[Comrade Khan]

Wait what?

Is that what an arsonist does? Fucking hell.

Even so I just don't see much for the magic case other than him being inactive and EV having a gutread. So I don't see enough evidence that Magic has a particularly good chance of flipping Arsonist.

arsonist primes a person each night. they can also detonate instead, killing all the ppl previously primed. it's a big fucking problem if we have one. and give the lack of kills. im going to say it's EXTREMELY likely. especially that Odo has used them before recently.

 

[Smart Marx]

Wait what?

Is that what an arsonist does? Fucking hell.

Even so I just don't see much for the magic case other than him being inactive and EV having a gutread. So I don't see enough evidence that Magic has a particularly good chance of flipping Arsonist.

You think his play in the second life matches his play as town in his first?

And yes. That's why the SK hasn't been killing. They prime victims and then set them all on fire at once. If you're to believe the theme spec.

 

[Alco]

You're not worried that an arsonist could kill 5 people at once?

Oh is this true?

That's pretty important info tbh

 

[Evans]

Wait what?

Is that what an arsonist does? Fucking hell.

Even so I just don't see much for the magic case other than him being inactive and EV having a gutread. So I don't see enough evidence that Magic has a particularly good chance of flipping Arsonist.

Ace, it's not just him being inactive. Look at the change in his play.

D1 Town Magic - inactive still compared to the rest of us but still given town reads and demanding town follow him.
Magic V2 - "lol whats an augment" and disappearing for 48 hours?

He isn't town.

Remember how you were deadset on me being scum/indy last game because of the colour orange and you couldn't see past it? You're doing it here. Trust me that Magic isn't town and if the arsonist claim is right, then we can keep town in good numbers

 

[Evans]

I agree hunting scum over indy is normally the best play but when you factor in the flavour of Surtr is literally BLOWING UP Asgard.

I think we need to refocus.

 

[Smart Marx]

Oh is this true?

That's pretty important info tbh

The lack of sk kills and theme spec from EV makes me believe it's possible.

 

[Ace]

arsonist primes a person each night. they can also detonate instead, killing all the ppl previously primed. it's a big fucking problem if we have one. and give the lack of kills. im going to say it's EXTREMELY likely. especially that Odo has used them before recently.

You think his play in the second life matches his play as town in his first?

And yes. That's why the SK hasn't been killing. They prime victims and then set them all on fire at once. If you're to believe the theme spec.

Arsonist sounds like a garbage role tbh. But yes that does change things with regards to my scumhunting priority.

And Demo, no, but he has generally been inactive in his second life and while it certainly is noticeable, the reason for that could very easily just be inactivity. I just feel in the current situation there are better arguments.

 

[Comrade Khan]

OHHHHHH

Then yeah, it wouldn't help if Magic is the arsonist then.

indeed. Just want to make sure we've got all the cards in front of us.

Regarding magic :

1) he went from actively emotionally playing in his first life, to backseat doing fuckall in his second
2) asking for full claim would track with an arsonist that wants to know where he should prime yet (wifom)
3) the way he's playing screams indy for sure, not sure if its him that said it, but a few of the vets have told me the best way to play indy is simply "to not play". so again that would track

 

[Smart Marx]

I agree hunting scum over indy is normally the best play but when you factor in the flavour of Surtr is literally BLOWING UP Asgard.

I think we need to refocus.

He's a pretty flamey dude in Thor, too.

 

[Evans]

I'm not hammering unless it's Magic at this rate.

 

[Comrade Khan]

If we are lynching scum over indy, we're lynching Tweet. Lynching me makes 0 sense with Lethal still alive.

 

[Smart Marx]

I'm not hammering unless it's Magic at this rate.

I don't hate the conviction.