Norse Mythology Mafia - Game Thread

[Ace]

What are your thoughts on Hel/Surtr?

This feels like you're trying to change the direction here.

I mean, what you guys said sounds legit? I don't know what you want me to discuss lol.

Not a fan of hunting indies when we've got solid leads for scum, is all

 

[Evans]

I'm not a fan of lynching Magic based off relative inactivity, which could easily be the reason he is making weird uninformed posts and stuff.

I'm not saying he's town or anything but it hardly feels like the best case we have for a lynch at this point. I mean, we still have a cop in Lethal if people are that uncertain of Magic.

That's a complete downplay of the case and you know it

Let's look at the possibilities:

Lynch Magic: potentially remove an indy and either Hel or Surtr - or we mislynch an inactive player who's not even bothering to play. If we remove the arsonist, amazing. Means we're not getting blown up. Scum get to kill in the night.

Lynch Jeff: potentially remove scum, still have 2 indies in play - potentially an arsonist. Or we mislynch an info role and one of the most active players and according to OMBs census, scum still get to kill in the night.

This I feel is pretty accurate. Please tell me why it's not if you think it isn't?

Surely your logic can also apply to copping Jeff or Tweet?

 

[Smart Marx]

@Demo God What's changed that you seem to have all but forgotten your Tweet case?

Given your vigour in believing Tweet was town I'm surprised you haven't discussed him yet. Has something changed?

I said I'd let it breathe. There's just too much WIFOM and unknown with a possible second augmenter.

We have 3 scum and 2 indies to get so no need to get hung-up on Tweet right now.

I still don't get having the conviction to vote Lethal after he claims cop, but then augments him at night and there's the missing Nom augmentation. But Doddsy I think said there could be ways to augment without a visitor? It's a confusing mess.

 

[Comrade Khan]

SO @Lethal Banks I know it's Pals era and all, but...what the actual fuck man

You're honestly telling me you didn't immediately send in you cop target as me after yesterdays flip good lord.


Why would we be lynching me when Lethal still has his supercop shot and I've already been copped town once. Logic doesn't really add up.

 

[Smart Marx]

I'm not a fan of lynching Magic based off relative inactivity, which could easily be the reason he is making weird uninformed posts and stuff.

I'm not saying he's town or anything but it hardly feels like the best case we have for a lynch at this point. I mean, we still have a cop in Lethal if people are that uncertain of Magic.

If he's indy, Jeff would have to cop him and do you trust Jeff to do that?

 

[Ace]

I'd go for the best case for scum than go for an inactive who you gutread non-town tbh. That's all there is to it.

 

[Smart Marx]

SO @Lethal Banks I know it's Pals era and all, but...what the actual fuck man

You're honestly telling me you didn't immediately send in you cop target as me after yesterdays flip good lord.


Why would we be lynching me when Lethal still has his supercop shot and I've already been copped town once. Logic doesn't really add up.

I tried to ask this question, but was much subtler about it.

 

[Smart Marx]

I'd go for the best case for scum than go for an inactive who you gutread non-town tbh. That's all there is to it.

You're not worried that an arsonist could kill 5 people at once?

 

[Comrade Khan]

If he's indy, Jeff would have to cop him and do you trust Jeff to do that?

and even then, there's two indies. even if id get a negative result, it doesn't clear the other. just so were fair here

 

[Smart Marx]

and even then, there's two indies. even if id get a negative result, it doesn't clear the other. just so were fair here

Who's the other? Who else is getting indy spec?

 

[Comrade Khan]

@Demo God can I deduce you did the obvious move last night? Assuming by your town you also saw nothing?

 

[Evans]

Lol ninja'd Smark.

Arsonist = can kill plenty of town at once.
Scum = even if we lynch Jeff, they can still shoot.

What if we lynch Jeff or Tweet and they flip scum then Magic says "lol i'm caught" and detonates and takes more people out?

That leaves 2 scum alive + another indy with town severely depleted.

 

[Ace]

You're not worried that an arsonist could kill 5 people at once?

Wait what?

Is that what an arsonist does? Fucking hell.

Even so I just don't see much for the magic case other than him being inactive and EV having a gutread. So I don't see enough evidence that Magic has a particularly good chance of flipping Arsonist.

 

[Comrade Khan]

Who's the other? Who else is getting indy spec?

I'm going by the assumption that Sutr is also in the game as you guys have discussed. my shot is only for Hel. so im saying in theory, if I shoot my shot and hit the other indy, id still get a negative result.

 

[Smart Marx]

@Demo God can I deduce you did the obvious move last night? Assuming by your town you also saw nothing?

I think you could say that and all was quiet.