Norse Mythology Mafia - Game Thread

[TKOK]

@CraigPelton Do you still have your role? cause i would like to be healed.

 

[Xenus]

I think Jeff may have a passive role where he sees visitors to himself. He said he wasn't a watcher iirc but he knows Lethal used a role. Magic v1 was the tracker. Lethal says he used his role ON Jeff, which we are to believe if you are legit.

If so, this invalidates both of your arguments for why it's unlikely to be a scum play.

Like a motion detector?

 

[Roy Mustang]

Well I don't plan on sticking around all night

I do look forward to Lethal telling me where he went last night however....

I mean a tracker already flipped so that kind of narrows it down. And if you aren't a watcher that means a JOAT or a follower?

Not particularly sure how that passive role can be proven or disprove without him dying, but we'll give the kid a chance to speak his peace.

I get what he is hinting at and if Jeff is right we need an explanation from Lethal.

 

[Xenus]

I’ll follow the confirmed town tbhayley and Vote Big Man

I didn't say we don't let him explain, but if he has an active role and just claimed a passive role then we have to lynch him because it's more likely he's just scum. we can't let people lie about their role and then get away with it if they're caught as it makes things easier for scum. if you're going to lie as town you make sure you don't get caught,

I mean either Lethal is going to say Jeff is lying or admit that he lied about his role. if it's the former then we know one of them is scum and I don't see Jeff taking the 1 for 1 like that. if it's the latter then it's not really convinient since he had that info unless he's bussing lethal. and he wouldn't bus lethal like this either since players who get lynched lose the game.

And these posts together are scummy as fuck. If lethal is town (which I assume he is) then not only has Big Man identified the only defence that Lethal may have before he comes into the thread, but then says we lynch him anyway.

 

[Smart Marx]

Well the cat may as well be let out of the bag.

I'm also the X-shot cop, but obviously didn't want to divulge that part so early in the game. But I'm getting sussed for absolutely everything, so it was pointless.

N1 - Gambit, Asgard Aligned. Went on a hunch due to his ability to blend in so well.
N2 - Jeff, Asgard Aligned. Contradictory statements, fluffy cases, prime cop target tbh.

I am also the Steward of Valhalla, my survival being very important i.e if I die, Valhalla is closed.

Bark up another tree.

Vote: Ace

 

[Smart Marx]

You know what we’re not about to do? Lynch the claimed cop.

 

[Roy Mustang]

Gambit was being pretty heavily town read day one wasn't he? Why did you go for him over someone who was getting more suspicion?

Yeah I don't think anyone scum read me day 1. Hell only Phenom called me scum day 2.

 

[Smart Marx]

Why would scum Lethal say he copped Jeff town and then accuse him of being the GF?

He wouldn’t.

 

[Roy Mustang]

Reading back but this is bullshit. No buys from me.



My PM specifically mentions Odin. Lethal has to be legit or my role is fucking terrible and Odo is not a terrible host. Like, WOAT.

As in your role or just flavor? Btw the reason I bought Lethal is because the person Flay is claiming is Odin's son and avenges his death

 

[Smart Marx]

Why the fuck would you lie

How many times have I said DON’T lie about your role. I’m claiming so everyone has all the info here.

I’m Freki and Geri. I’m Odin’s wolves and protect him basically and I’m a Seraph.

So Lethal is not lying about being Odin unless my entire role is broken.

So you’re protecting Lethal? Every night no matter?

Should Lethal die we know you’re lying? Yes?

 

[Roy Mustang]

@CraigPelton has risen from the dead

AHHH ZOMBIE!

I don't see why he'd say he copped Jeff as town when there was appetite to lynch Jeff as well.

Tbf that I can still see Lethal doing as he isn't someone who leads lynch without having info.

Why would you immediately jump to “Reviver”? That role is completely broken if Town because we know CP is town. I assume it must have caveats, but no need to tell us them if there are.

This game makes no sense. Odo is a really good host and there seems to be fuckery all over the place.

Scum or indy reviver isn't impossible. Feel like whoever did should claim before I trust CP is town 100%

 

[Roy Mustang]

Something doesn't add the fuck up. Jeff I want a full claim now. I'm reading Lethal's day 1 posts to see if he even mentioned me.

 

[Roy Mustang]

Having a look at PHEN0M and Jeff's mentions and interactions with each other.PHEN0M names 3 people who were yet to really post much at the start of the game. Magic v1 was town, and given that PHEN0M was pushing Poyser as well and hinted at blocking him at one point, I'm gonna wager that Poyser aka Magic v2 is town as well. Jeff could be the token scummate mention here.


Defends Jeff here, though the point is true.


Yeah don't think PHEN0M does this to a scummate. Nothing about this interaction rules out s/s to me though.

PHEN0M does vote Jeff here but it's just a part of his fake tantrum. He doesn't actually push Jeff at all. Jeff asks him why he's voting him later as you'll see.

Yeah, the Jeff vote had no weight to it.


Kinda feels like a forced and unnecessary interaction here.



Gambit is pushing PHEN0M at this point and PHEN0M OMGUSes. Jeff doesn't really get involved and just lobs some more neutral interaction posts at both of them and as we know proceeds to do nothing for the rest of the phase.

Phen0m 100% would bus if he felt is was a good idea. So I can see Jeff being scum. Gut is screaming here that something obvious is in our faces regarding Jeff and Lethal

 

[Xenus]

So you’re protecting Lethal? Every night no matter?

Should Lethal die we know you’re lying? Yes?

I can’t answer this without doing what you perceive to be flaming or revealing things that there’s no benefit to me revealing.

 

[Roy Mustang]

This is where I was but then it would have to be the perfect storm. They’d either be

(1) faking info that lethal doesn’t have a passive role, which he used last night, following a claim of a passive role, which is just ballsy as fuck and I don’t see it; or

(2) rolecopped the guy who claimed D1, saw he was the cop, then faked the info to catch him in the lie. Jeff was really specific about it being the passive role, so it can’t be that a kill didn’t go through (like when I faked info on Odo in the WS Reloaded Mafia). But I don’t think you waste a rolecop on someone who claims D1, including an augmented role.

Does anyone have the order of resolution? With Phenom flipping Jailkeeper I need to check something.

3) He is an alert mafioso or an alert townie who knows who targets him? Or a JOAT I guess. Or some weaker version of a watcher or tracker.