Norse Mythology Mafia - Game Thread

[Xenus]

What else brings people back? He could be a scum reviver but still reviver.

My thought was some sort of delayed stump? Perhaps it’s his augmented role and it was redacted? CP can confirm.

 

[Xenus]

I think both. I don't think you know what Brutus is and I don't think I was thinking what you're thinking. Don't really wanna add more at this JUNKture

How do you feel about Lethal’s claim?

 

[CraigPelton]

Pretty sure I'm just back to life and that's that.

 

[Xenus]

My thought was some sort of delayed stump? Perhaps it’s his augmented role and it was redacted? CP can confirm.

No this is trash. He had an augmented role. Probably a reviver.

 

[Xenus]

Pretty sure I'm just back to life and that's that.

 

[Xenus]

Oh man I thought that was going to be a “welcome” gif. Disregard. I’m not softing reviver.

 

[Doddsy]

How do you feel about Lethal’s claim?

I buy it currently. The details seem beyond bullshitting, and with you claiming to be his Seraph, as well as claiming the Allfather himself in a game about Norse mythology. More liable to buy it than not. The annoyance at being sussed after claiming cop seems legit as well.

As for the Jeff being GF part, I'll keep it in mind as I have been sus of him, but don't think my suspicions are strong enough right now to override a cop result. Maybe later on in the game it can be re-evaluated but I'm more comfortable going for a third party as of now

 

[CraigPelton]

1. Ace
2. Evans
4. Alco
5. Jeff
6. Lethal
7. Barry
8. Tweet
9. Smark
10. TKOK
12. OMB
13. Xenus
14. Magic v2
15. Gambit
16. Doddsy
17. Chloe
18. Rugrat
19. Big Man
21. Brutus


tbh

How is Ace not a town read with PHEN0M's flip? Why is Alco town? I agree he looked good early but he's been kind of coasty since. I'm also not sure how you don't have Chloe as town. Seems kind of obvious.

 

[CraigPelton]

vote Big Man

Let's get a claim from Big Man. We're not lynching Lethal, that's for sure. If you think Lethal is scum then Xenus has to be scum too and tied his fate to Lethal's back on d1. NAH.

 

[Xenus]

I'd lean that way, too, but I don't like that overly harsh comeback Xenus had at Lethal for even including him on his list.

Something doesn't smell right here and I'd like to hear from the horse's mouth.

The posts above should answer this, Smark, in case you say I’m ignoring you.

 

[CraigPelton]

Having a look at PHEN0M and Jeff's mentions and interactions with each other.

I know they were all probably busy yesterday but Poyser, Jeff and Magic have been very underwhelming as opposed to usual standards.

PHEN0M names 3 people who were yet to really post much at the start of the game. Magic v1 was town, and given that PHEN0M was pushing Poyser as well and hinted at blocking him at one point, I'm gonna wager that Poyser aka Magic v2 is town as well. Jeff could be the token scummate mention here.

Also Jeff I'm not really a fan of you going "I'm not claiming" again upon your first re-entry post.

Why? Would you claim off this wagon? Would you expect town me to claim off this wagon? I think we both know the answer.

To be fair, last time i remember Jeff doing that, he was town.

Defends Jeff here, though the point is true.

Nice of Jeff to join us, would be nice if my day one choice for scum would do the same. YOU CANT HIDE FROM ME @Poyser

When was the last time he bailed THIS hard? Inactivity is not a tell I remember with him, so I'm seeing it more as NULL atm

He shaded you for being busy and not posting, calling it WEAK and voting you, even though he said the exact same thing and has since...not posted

My Phenom senses are tingling.

Yeah don't think PHEN0M does this to a scummate. Nothing about this interaction rules out s/s to me though.

Unvote

Just won’t make my own reads anymore and sheep. Let me know who to vote.

Vote: Jeff

PHEN0M does vote Jeff here but it's just a part of his fake tantrum. He doesn't actually push Jeff at all. Jeff asks him why he's voting him later as you'll see.

oh good. you're here.

why are you voting me?

I was blah earlier on this morning and said I’d vote wherever and Doddsy politely asked at the time so i indulged him.

Yeah, the Jeff vote had no weight to it.

what are your actual reads then...

I literally just gave them...

so you did....

Kinda feels like a forced and unnecessary interaction here.

any specific reason for these?

See above post for CP.

I forget who asked me about lethal earlier But as I explained there, don’t think lethal as scum picks now to debut the italics gimmick. It draws Unnecessary attention to himself. His claim further cements him as town to me.

As for the Kok. I stole that from Magic V1. He can read him well, and if he said he’s town, i trust him.

That line of posts trying to get me to give up “information” i might have is really a bad look. You wanted more scum reads, you got it, would love more Gambit votes here.

what the hell are you talking about Phenom?

Gambit is pushing PHEN0M at this point and PHEN0M OMGUSes. Jeff doesn't really get involved and just lobs some more neutral interaction posts at both of them and as we know proceeds to do nothing for the rest of the phase.

 

[CraigPelton]

I'm still thinking Jeff could be scum here. Pushing a Lethal mislynch in this situation isn't risky at all for him since he did catch Lethal in a lie. Despite a number of interactions with flipped scum PHEN0M, none of them give us any reason to think he's more likely to be town.

 

[CraigPelton]

But yeah, claim from Big Man first. Probably not gonna lynch Jeff today in any event given the cop result and there being other scum out there to catch.

brb sleep

 

[Xenus]

I'm still thinking Jeff could be scum here. Pushing a Lethal mislynch in this situation isn't risky at all for him since he did catch Lethal in a lie. Despite a number of interactions with flipped scum PHEN0M, none of them give us any reason to think he's more likely to be town.

This is where I was but then it would have to be the perfect storm. They’d either be

(1) faking info that lethal doesn’t have a passive role, which he used last night, following a claim of a passive role, which is just ballsy as fuck and I don’t see it; or

(2) rolecopped the guy who claimed D1, saw he was the cop, then faked the info to catch him in the lie. Jeff was really specific about it being the passive role, so it can’t be that a kill didn’t go through (like when I faked info on Odo in the WS Reloaded Mafia). But I don’t think you waste a rolecop on someone who claims D1, including an augmented role.

Does anyone have the order of resolution? With Phenom flipping Jailkeeper I need to check something.

 

[CraigPelton]

This is where I was but then it would have to be the perfect storm. They’d either be

(1) faking info that lethal doesn’t have a passive role, which he used last night, following a claim of a passive role, which is just ballsy as fuck and I don’t see it; or

(2) rolecopped the guy who claimed D1, saw he was the cop, then faked the info to catch him in the lie. Jeff was really specific about it being the passive role, so it can’t be that a kill didn’t go through (like when I faked info on Odo in the WS Reloaded Mafia). But I don’t think you waste a rolecop on someone who claims D1, including an augmented role.

Does anyone have the order of resolution? With Phenom flipping Jailkeeper I need to check something.

I think Jeff may have a passive role where he sees visitors to himself. He said he wasn't a watcher iirc but he knows Lethal used a role. Magic v1 was the tracker. Lethal says he used his role ON Jeff, which we are to believe if you are legit.

If so, this invalidates both of your arguments for why it's unlikely to be a scum play.